Home› critique

critique

Discussion List

Topic
Replies
Latest Post

Portfolio Critique

HeyI'm trying to get into the game industry as an Environment Artist and I received an onslaught of rejections. Now I know this is part of the industry and I'm usually understanding of it but I've be…
7 Last
RobinK

Forest Cabin - Looking for feedback

Hi, this is my very first project. I used UE4 for screenshots, Blender for some models, Quixel Megascans for other models and practically all materials. I would like to receive feedback and suggestio…
2 Last
Donato

First Prop Study - Looking for Critique

      So, this is my first attempt at a potentially game ready prop. At this point I'm not really sure what to look for or improve here. I know the textures could be higher res and han…
2 Last
dondon

(WIP) Raccoon Character Sculpt

Heya guys, this is my first time posting on here, so here it goes. I've been working on a Raccoon character in Zbrush as of late and I would like some feedback on it. Here is how it's looking so far.…
4 Last
EdwardJivkov

[WIP] Military Police Officer

Hey y'all, back at it again with another post. Here is another work in progress I have going on currently. I've been working on a Military/Police type character in Zbrush/Maya and here is how it's lo…
2 Last
EdwardJivkov

[WIP] Sea Of Theives Fan Art - Pirate Lord's Staff

Sup folks,I've recently been playing a lot of Sea Of Thieves and couldn't resist attempting some fan art!Currently working on the Pirate Lord's staff trying to incorporate some style found throughout…
10 Last
Glynnybob

First model textured in substance painter -- Guidance well appreciated!

2 Last
June

[WIP] Dishonored Delilah - Fan Art

I'm creating this thread to track my progress on my new project, a Delilah bust. I really want to learn stylized sculpting, and for these past few days I've made a few sculpts, but none of them …
3 Last
abrynildsen

Dead - Arnold maya please give some critcism

1 Last
ashutosh1106

WIP Game Character Model - Looking for general feedback + specific feedback on face appeal

Hey y'allBeen working on this guy for a while. Loosely based off a sketch from https://www.artstation.com/artwork/Y5aXVThe model is very much WIP at the moment. Would love some overall critique and f…
2 Last
KaladinCraig

Feedback on my Showreel for a Job (Click Youtube Video)

I would really appreciate feedback on my Showreel if I ever want to present it to an industry to apply for jobs.Show Reel Video: https://youtu.be/Ozz22dUPOYI
1 Last
HarlequinWerewolf

Sturmgeschütz.III Ausf.A Game Ready Model

Here is a model of a german tank from WWII that I created for an indie game, high poly, low poly & textures.24K Tris1 Texture Set at 4KFeedback is very much appreciated.
2 Last
Zi0

[WIP] - Demon Hunter

Hi polycount.New project for me, a character  from the artist Alexis Rives , The demon hunter . https://www.artstation.com/deadslugCritique and feedback are more than welcome. I will try to…
8 Last
rollin

Rose "Overwatch Concept" WIP

Hey guys so I can use some feedback on this girl that I'm working on. some tips on how to make her more like the concept will help greatly, what can I I do to make it feel right, how show a approach …
9 Last
ChrisTheArtist

NEED HELP! Rose Game character

Hey guys so I can use some feedback on this girl that I'm working on. some tips on how to make her more like the concept will help greatly, what can I I do to make it feel right, how show a approach …
0 Last
ChrisTheArtist

Tokyo Metro Environment (UE4)

Hello polycounters!Here is my *late* submission for the EXP + DiNusty Cyberpunk challenge. I wish I could have finished it in time for submission but I started late so I just decided to carry on with…
10 Last
snake85027

[WIP] Wyvern - looking for critique

Hey everyone :)I am working on my very first wyvern and am currently unsure about the anatomy. Some help, critique and tips would be very nice and more than welcome.Thanks in advance :) and the origi…
9 Last
Carrath

Sketchbook: PeterBombka

crabs like exosuitesamurai with kimono like fabricdragonbirldmonkeyscavanger girl
0 Last
peterbombka

Portfolio feedback - A.Rogalski

Hey, I would like to ask you for feedback to my portfolio. I mainly aim at prop art. I will gladly hear your comments  =) https://arogal.artstation.com/
3 Last
ARogalski

Old Wooden Crate - Really Need Feedback

Hi everyone, At the point where I really want to start improving overall but particularly in texturing, so I modeled a simple crate and followed a standard high to low poly workflow using Zbrush…
2 Last
Volkknight

WIP Rainforest Environment - Looking for Critique

Hi everyone,This is a project I have been working on for a while. I am just trying to improve my modelling overall and learn as many techniques as possible. I also wanted to include some animals to m…
0 Last
wesley97

Spacesuit Helmet display v2

This is what I've done to improve what I did in the previous version (https://polycount.com/discussion/216724/spacesuit-helmet-display#latest)though to be fair the image doesn't show the helmet as mu…
0 Last
supremeloser123

[WIP] Killer Pig face

Hi guys I shared progress the my new project, i'd really welcome any kind of feedback and critique.
0 Last
JMarcos28

SunsetOverdrive TrimSheet Test

Insomniac games did a GDC talk a while back and I wanted to quickly test some of their techniques.https://www.gdcvault.com/play/1022324/The-Ultimate-Trim-Texturing-TechniquesOriginal document:Just lo…
6 Last
MattAllum12

Journey to a Character Artist (Daily Update)

Hi guys, my name's Annabelle and I am currently working every day on my portfolio to eventually become a character artist. In this thread I will share my work from every day, kind of as is I was…
40 Last
Tits

Hellboy - feedback needed!

Hello guys!Long story short: I need feedback! :)Long story long: I'm new to 3D and everything that is around it. I've been told that if I want to learn faster I need some sort of mentorship or commun…
4 Last
d333p

Stylized Game Character Design

Hey so I've been working on this character for a game while on quarantine and so I made it this far in my work. Please feel free to critique anything you feel needs improvement. This character means …
2 Last
ChrisTheArtist

male head study critique

I'm doing something wrong but I don't know what, I was hoping people here can lead me in he right direction been doing studies almost daily and very few come out looking anatomically correct. I've fo…
6 Last
HaTariq

Alex' improvement topic critics welcome !

Hi, I'm new in the community, I see a lot of amazing work here and I'd love to be a concept artist one day, I'm in an animation school and I thought it could be cool if I post my progression here. I …
1 Last
Will_Maccabe

[WIP] [Looking for Feedback] Fable Character Fan Art

Hey Folks!I wanted to create a character based within the fable universe which I spent many hours in when I was younger. I'm currently just sculpting out the basic idea using 'Tipple' concept art by …
11 Last
Glynnybob

Inception Totem Scene

Hello I'm learning how to make photo realistic renders, this is my first attempt. I've tried to apply most of what I learned from Blender Guru's tutorial Photorealism Explained. The scene was made us…
0 Last
AB3LL1

Just getting started in blender all critiques are welcomed. looking for guidance and ideas

if you can please link to tutorials, advice, and insight on 3d environmental art. The tutorial that helped me with this was https://youtu.be/5pi1MxqpmKw
7 Last
GL4D_TO_B3_HERE

Szary - Grey Walkyrie

Hi again PolypeopleNew character!  this one is a OC based on a concept art done by Makkon.i 'm doing my best to give it proper justice, beginning with anatomy ( still working on it ) :
14 Last
seimax

3D character Facial appeal

I’m working a stylized game character model for my future projects and I’m a little stuck on his facial appeal. I’m trying to push the miles morales look and get the hair design with the other dude. …
0 Last
ChrisTheArtist

[WIP] Stone Golem - critique

Hi,Working on a stylized stone golem, for the purpose of being an enemy in game.Not looking to copy exact Refs, but to create something unique and fun to look at.Modeling, posture and silhouette…
1 Last
Crazy_pixel

3D Character Design Wizard Critique

whats up I'm working on a design for a video game character. I'm trying to achieve the overwatch art style and I've done a lot of research and technical direction in terms of polycount and modeling. …
1 Last
DavidCruz

PM-39 — SCI-FI weapon concept

My first experience of work in Fusion 360. Rendered in Cycles. This weapon was inspired by Kriss Vector and closed project "0x10c" by Notch.
2 Last
Apofex

Blaster Master Game Idea concept

Hey guys, looking for feedback and thoughts on the game concept idea i'm working on to bring back blaster master an old NES game to current gen. More screens here https://www.artstation.com…
2 Last
Will_Maccabe

Face Illustrations

Hello, over the past month and a half I've been working on faces. These are the illustrations I've created and the progress I've made. The last two were satisfying to create and I hope to continue to…
2 Last
Will_Maccabe

Droid Design - WIP

I'm working on this protocol droid inspired model and struggling with the design of the head. Ideally, I would like to keep it looking non-human, but I don't really like the shape it is now. Any sugg…
0 Last
sarasumm

Zbrush skull Critique

I think I know what direction to go but I've found that critiques speed the decision making process up dramatically. I still have to add more detail but I think I got the major forms where they shoul…
7 Last
HaTariq

[WIP] Abandoned Train Wagon, Yes, Yet Another Abandoned Scene... [UE4]

Hello fellow polycount people. I finally dared to post something online and I am very excited to share my newest personal project with you guys.I had the idea to make a small, playable scene in …
18 Last
Tiodorr

Help a 2D Environment artist become a 3D Environment artist and land a job

Hello I'm Ryan and I plan to make a career change. Doing 2D art for 5 years now, i have dabbled in freelance work but it never grew to make me stop doing my night-shift work in the weekends. I have b…
1 Last
teodar23

[3DS Max] Spherical objects… are there better ways to model this?

Hey there guys, I’m new to Polycount and just looking for a little guidance. I’m in my last semester of art school and I’m currently putting together a character/prop modeling portfolio. One thi…
8 Last
Ghogiel

Character Concept - Crit Me!

HI everyone!Nervous to post asking for crit for the first time haha!I'm going to be doing a lot of concept art for a personal project over the coming months and I'd like some crit/advice on how to ta…
1 Last
svrart

[WIP] Supernatural Monitor, in the vein of the "New Weird" genre

Started as an imaginary terminal for the Sketchfab october challenge, I had to abandon the project due to time problem - but could pick it up again recently!Remodeled the base and turned the terminal…
6 Last
Götterfunke

High poly lantern - Advice needed!

Hey, I modeled this lantern and made most of the small holes using boolean with a mesh pattern I created. The topology was obviously awful after that, and spent a good time fixing it manually. It's s…
3 Last
Dinka

Arisaka Type-38 Rifle - C&C Much Appreciated

Hello,I recently finished my game ready Arisaka Type-38 rifle and would like to know if this is portfolio ready?Here is the Artstation link: https://www.artstation.com/artwork/Z58zzGAttached are…
3 Last
StarWyvern

Need feedback/advice on my model.

 Hi guys. I made this model for my portfolio. But textures looks bad especially plastic material.  :s Here is my mode. https://skfb.ly/6Q9IY
3 Last
fatninja

Beginner 3D Artist looking for portfolio review

Hello all, I am a recent college graduate(May 2019) trying to get my career started as a 3D artist, really anything to get me started. I've been told to add more variety to my portfolio such as asset…
4 Last
HaTariq

Popular Tags