Home› critique

critique

Discussion List

Topic
Replies
Latest Post

Car Modelling Workflow?

I am creating my first vehicle, and several people have told me i am not approaching it right or using the correct workflow. I've watched a couple car modelling timelapses and I guess i am just dense…
4 Last
sacboi

AK47 Bayonet Game Ready

Hello Polycounters, I've made this asset to be included in a Arma3 Mod, but I'd really like to get some feedbacks. The entire model was made in Blender, for the textures I've used a huge node setup w…
7 Last
AB3LL1

Skateboard prop (Critique wanted)

Hi Guys, I'm updating my portfolio and I need some critiques of my latest piece, I'd really like to know if theres anything you feel could be pushed further before I post the final renders on Artstat…
3 Last
Mutant_Toast

First post - Critique/advice on 3d female face/bust

Hi everyone, just joined polycount :) I've hit a bit of a brick wall with this sculpt I'm working on , this is my first try at a full female bust. I'm at the stage of mid frequency changes -&nbs…
0 Last
River_Rose

Critique, Game environment: 90's post apocalyptic school encampment

Hey EveryoneFirst time posting on polycount :). Just finished my first game environment, a 90's post apocalyptic school encampment. Showcasing my final renders and hoping for some critique / poi…
5 Last
Westbarbary

First low-poly, pixel model for a gaming asset. Please critique!

So after three months learning blender for modelling and gimp for uv painting I've come up with this. It's created for a mobile game using UE4 and will be unlit in the engine. The props, wheels, rudd…
4 Last
graysan

Abandoned post-apocalyptic hospital.I would love some feedback,Please critique

 
4 Last
ashutosh1106

Looking for feedback on first pass Beach scene

Hey...whoever comes across this. First, I hope you're well and are staying safe. I am trying to stretch myself a bit and work on a scene with a lot more organic elements. The concept I'm working off …
7 Last
Daniel_Mallett

Could a kind admin, pls help delete? Thanks!

Admin, pls help delete~ thanks!
0 Last
spidlee

Northern Campsite

Hello!I wanted to get some feedback on my latest project before I add it to my portfolio. It's a small scene I made based off of my coursework to teach myself environment art. I created the models wi…
19 Last
wHromek

M84 Stun Grenade C&C

I recently finished this grenade and was happy with it, but now looking back it seems pretty dull and boring and doesn't really stand out. Anything else that can be added/fixed up to make it more of …
0 Last
Danballs3D

3D Game Asset C&C

Hi polycount, I'm making this stylized daggerbased on Becca Hallstedt concept (https://www.artstation.com/artwork/NYGLD)and i'm looking for improvements on highpoly and a better way to make…
0 Last
gfcamerini

SIG MPX

A SIG MPX I modeled during my free time. Really wanted to push my texturing with this piece and learn UE 4 for rendering. Hope you like it! I would love to get any feed back on my texturing and rende…
3 Last
teodar23

Diaries Of A Druid (UE4) _ Critiques are welcome!

Hello there dear polycounters , this is my first work inside of Unreal Engine i made it during the Organic World Building in UE4 course by Anthony Vaccaro . Just wanted to ask your opinion about basi…
2 Last
TheMadNomad

Library Room Environment Critique

Hi everyone, I recently finished this environment and I'm hoping to add it to my portfolio. The scene is rendered in UE4. I created it to reuse a lot of old assets (including the lamps, chair, and ta…
16 Last
sympatik

Substance Painter-Baking Problems

As you can see below, I have a problem with my mesh after baking in Substance Painter I have no idea how to fix it. I tried changing the Max Frontal/Rear Distance and baking, re-importing the High/Ga…
5 Last
gnoop

(WIP) Tree Stump Diorama Log

LOG 1Hello all,Recently, I have been working on several game ready objects with the intent to assemble them in a small diorama. The scene is intended to include a hatchet, oil lamp, and a tree stump.…
4 Last
Humble_Dragon

Bellamina Sculpt Face - Critiques Needed

Hi there, so I've been practising facial likeness sculpting for the first time on Zbrush so I decided to recreate this art 'Bellamina's Blood Fist' by Arhiee and concept by Shirin. Im currently looki…
4 Last
ChristheLancer97

Any suggestions for what I can do to improve?

Other than more practice of course, something I am constantly doing. I am aiming to adopt a more stylized style for my characters. What I have here was an improvement to what I have made many months …
6 Last
Brian "Panda" Choi

Environment Art Portfolio Critique

Hi everyone, over the past few months I have worked on two major projects that I hope can replace my current portfolio. My goal is to be a game environment artist, so I would like your opinion on whe…
9 Last
b_beauchamp

Sketchbook: Anthea van Leeuwen

Hey y'all, just setting this up here to have a place where I can post my WIPs!To start this bad boy off: here's a concept I've been working on the past week or so. After finishing my onigiri robot, i…
1 Last
Antheavl

[WIP] Black Viking woman

This is a part of a personal project I am doing to add to my portfolio. Any C&C will be appreciated
4 Last
HarlequinWerewolf

[FINISHED] Shady Factory UE4

hi this is my 2nd UE 4 project(abandoned the 1st one because the scope was too big), im really looking forward to completing this one.here i just blocked the large pieces and some primary props, i on…
10 Last
labeeb

[WIP] Conservatory / Greenhouse in UE4

EDIT: Critique + Advice welcomedAbout a year ago I made this thread for this project. With current events, I have time to finally return to it with a better plan. Below are the images from last Augus…
12 Last
screenshotrian

Looking for actual Critiques

Hello. I'm looking for feedback, and hopefully I've finally come to the right place.This is the cover I drew for my 1k-page book:Now the first (and at times the only) question I tend to get is, "What…
9 Last
yamazakiofthevoid

Witch Hunter - 3D Character

Fell in love at first sight with this fanstastic concept by Mike Franchina, brilliant silohuette and choice of elements, had a quick run modeling this, but I' d love to get back and detail more. I'd …
0 Last
MaxDeAntonis

Stylized Environment (looking for feedback)

I just finished this environment, but was looking for some feedback before I add this to my artstation portfolio. Let me know what you guys think should be changed. Was going for a stylized hand pain…
2 Last
BradyJ

Head Sculpt - Feedback/critique - Zbrush

Currently wanting to do a smaller project to work on some texturing, thought a bust would be appropriate, afew issues with the geometry that i cant seem to Zremesh out, they go away when i dynamesh b…
4 Last
GarethStandfield

i need feedback on a portrait sculpt

aside from asymmetry, what can I do to improve this sculpt? the likeness is based on young Liza Minnelli but my main goal is to make the face look natural.
8 Last
birb

Portfolio Critique

Hello,I am a recent art school graduate pursuing a career in video games and I have been apply to 3D artist full-time jobs and internship employment. I want to make sure my portfolio is in tip top sh…
1 Last
Ashervisalis

I first implemented my concept

Hello everyone, I am showing you my work. For the first time I presented myself as a concept artist. Please evaluate and give advice on future achievements! (My artstation link: https://www…
4 Last
Osmann

Adding New Details Feedback - Zbrush - WIP

So as of right now, everything is symmetrical i will brake that once i have a grasp on were im going. The head and shoulders i like, but the larger scales i like them on the neck but when i adde…
0 Last
GarethStandfield

City Subway Train Lighting

Hi Guys,Here is my very first lighting study using the popular city subway train environment by Dekogon Studios. The aim was to light it using only the sunlight coming through the window and skylight…
0 Last
Muzammil

Jacob - Black Sun Shinobi

So the time has come again for me to do another project and I decided to do a character design for a video I had in mind. This is an original design i'm working on. I want to set a deadline from 2 we…
0 Last
ChrisTheArtist

Handpainted Witch

Hello everyone! I've been meaning to update my portfolio for awhile, and I'm starting it off with a handpainted witch for cozy_wire's #WitchChallengeBased on my own extremely rough concept.  Cri…
4 Last
kateblacks

Recent graduate looking for career advice

I am a recent graduate from DigiPen Institute of Technology where I studied for my Bachelors of Fine Arts in Digital Art and Animation. I graduated this April and have been struggling starting my car…
17 Last
NikhilR

[WIP] Day Man - Early progress

Alright, one character for portfolio done, time to work on another. Wanted to show you some progress on character i've began creating, it's based on this concept ->>> https://www.artstation.…
5 Last
Aydhe

I Need Help Anatomy Critiques About Stylize Character

Hello guys, I could not resolve anatomy this character on concept. And I need advice. Please help me! Thanks...
5 Last
yunuskilic

Portfolio feedback wanted.

Hey everybody, I am currently finishing up grad school and have begun applying to jobs so I would like some feedback on my portfolio. My team and I are about a month away from finishing our caps…
6 Last
AustinLabarbera

Female Sculpt WIP (Looking for feedback)

Hi! This is a sculpt I'm currently working on I want to push it to be as realistic as possible, but as it now it looks more uncanny than realistic, and I can't figure out what part I need to work on …
6 Last
Brian "Panda" Choi

[WIP] Frankenstein - Early progress

This project is for learning the anatomy of the human face and leveling up my skill in zbrush. Feedback is alweays welcome
2 Last
wenslay

Knight shield model, feedback critique required

Hey all,Finished up this model yesterday, looking to get some critique on it, so I can improve my future models. The model is based of Vadim Boyko shield concept. The model is sitting at ar…
5 Last
Joey_Pistachio

M67 & M-84 Grenades. Game Ready.

Hello, I'm really new to this site and was looking for some critiques on my 3D work. Normally I don't get actual feedback even when I ask for it but I really want to improve and hopefully break into …
5 Last
Boosted24v

Critique and guidance - need Portfolio improvement for freelance work

I need your wise guidance and judging to improve my portfolio for freelance work!Hi all. I would like to move slowly from full time into freelance territory and would love to hear your feedback on my…
2 Last
Theo Bod

PPSh-41

Hello guys! This is my first post in this section and I wanted to share my latest work. It is a model of a soviet machine gun called "PPSh-41" which  I've done for a Unreal Engine Game Level I'm…
2 Last
Zi0

Character Modeling Facial Topology Critique

I'm working on getting a better understanding of the topology required for proper deformation when it comes to character models, specificaly for the facial geometry. I made the head of a base mo…
2 Last
Indie

Flying village

Hello guys, This is my last project.I have a problem with this though, big one. I've spent around 150+hrs working on this + many hours thinking about this, and it looks like I've wasted alot of …
4 Last
d333p

Gnome wip critique

I need some help with the overall shape, I can't exactly figure out if I got the proportions of the body and face right. Something feels off, should I do him a little bit taller, or wider? It's still…
3 Last
Mepra

[WIP] Rose Overwatch Game Ready Character

Hey guys I could use to help on her armor. I know it doesn’t look right or proportional so what can I do to make it look better and right? Her leg armor feels off I modeled them inside Maya and topog…
12 Last
slosh

1865 Gatling Gun (WIP) | Critique Wanted

Hello there! This is an 1865 gatling gun that I've been working on. I'd like some feedback on the textures I have so far before I export and render them. Anything I could add or change?. The texturin…
12 Last
NURBS

Popular Tags