Home› critique

critique

Discussion List

Topic
Replies
Latest Post

Wallace Sword

Here I share my new project. Please feel free to comment.
2 Last
MagicAnton

Sketchbook: Seun Gesi

Names: Seun (≈Shawn) or SquiglyAbout me: Studio art student looking for workCareer Objective: 3D Modeler/Sculptor (prefer characters, open to other subjects)Software I Use: Blender, Zbrush, Nomad Scu…
0 Last
seungesi

Environment swamp painting

Part of a personal project I'm working on, finally "finished" this painting of a swamp with a cocoon thing hanging from the branches. Looking for some honest feedback 
0 Last
_Nexius

[Feedback] Tunnel under a road

Looking for feedback on this render. I'm unsure about the lighting in the tunnel and I want to find a way to make tree trunk roots. Any thoughts?
4 Last
Jordz

I need feedback in my animation (please any suggestion will help)

https://syncsketch.com/sketch/610a96072e82/
1 Last
WeatherMan

Been trying to up my face game with some studies, any feedback or recomendation??

hi, ive been working on some face studies, and most of them look kinda ok, but off for some reason, (this one is a bit stylized) if anyone has some feedback, that would be great, i just plugged some …
6 Last
Proyecto Tejon

I need feedback in my animation (please any suggestion will help)

https://syncsketch.com/sketch/610a96072e82/
3 Last
kanga

Please Critique My 3D Portfolio (Any Suggestion will Help)

I want to get a job in a bigger gaming company as a 3D artist, but I mostly worked in small companies so I don't know if my artworks are good enough. Let me know what I should change, what I should w…
5 Last
Chino1989

Pirate Ship W.I.P Build Log

Hello everyone,I am new to the forum, just recently joined. I am not exactly sure if this is the right place for this post. I am currently working on a pirate ship model in Blender and I wanted t…
3 Last
Rosehaven11

My idle animation for a runner game! Critique wanted

Heya, been working on this character design and idle animation for a while now and think I have it at a place I want it. It runs at 8fps and has 5 frames. Would love to hear peoples thoughts and opin…
1 Last
CarrotCabbage

[WIP] Need Critique on My Machine Gun (M2HB)

Modeled in Blender3D and textured in substance. Want to make sure before I send it into Blender to render it that its looking good. Here is a few snapshots of the model in Substance Painter viewport …
25 Last
Oren3Ds

Elf. Critique please

Hi, everyone! This is my second 3D work at ZBrush. For texturing (if possible call it texturing ha-ha) used Substance Painter. I need some critique about general things which i should consider in…
2 Last
Crazy_pixel

W.I.P. Some critique please )

Hello, everyone. I am new to 3D, this is my third work that is destined to be completed. Now I am at the stage of sculpting (ZBrush) and I want to ask for constructive critique. At the moment, the ch…
1 Last
Crazy_pixel

Sketchbook: thelittleone

I started learning Zbrush a couple months ago. I'm really bad about sharing my work so I thought starting a digital sketchbook would be a good place for me to start! :# I am most interested in 3D Pr…
7 Last
thelittleone

Please DESTROY my portfolio (with crit!)

Hi everyone! First time posting here. Lately I’ve come to the realization that my portfolio ( https://www.artstation.com/eekium ) is almost definitely lacking. I’ve been doing 3D art f…
2 Last
fdfxd2

My Sketchbook Critics welcome !!!

Hi everyone ! I'm pushing myself to get some feedbacks so here I am, and I will try to post everyday for quick improvement !So here are my few sketches from today, I wanted to draw a knight who is go…
3 Last
Eric Chadwick

Grunt Goblin

Hi everyone. I just finished a 3D model of mine based on a Grunt Goblin from Halo Wars 2 for a module in my university course for Games Art. I was just wondering if anyone could offer me any critique…
2 Last
MharkCudal

[WIP] First time sculpting stylized rocks, looking for feedback!

Hey everyone, this is my first time working on stylized assets, really going for a Warcraft kind of feel, I'd appreciate any feedback!
8 Last
Alan314

Looking for some feedback on my environment art

Hello guys!I typically work on 3d environments, but I want to try to learn painting as well to help me learn lighting and composition. So I'm just gonna post my studies here and you guys can leave an…
3 Last
BradyJ

Portfolio review of an aspiring junior 3d artist

Hello, guys i would life your honest opinion on my portfolio as i am struggling to start my career at the moment as a junior 3d artist or generalist, i have been told in the past that my portfolio wa…
6 Last
jeffry

[WIP] Forest Ruins Environment (UE4)

Hi everyone, first time poster here on Polycount. I was hoping to get some feedback on my current project.I'm trying to create a natural looking game environment for these stone structures and sword …
1 Last
Skinner3D

HI. Im fairly new to 3d and this is my first serious project that i actually finished

What could i do better? https://sketchfab.com/3d-models/stylized-old-camera-18d3de3fcf46424ebdc83c42f1697e36Thanks!
3 Last
jose.fuentes

[WIP] Kirin Creature Sculpt - looking for feedback!

Hello! I'm new member here and this is my first post. I look forward to hearing from you all!I've been working on and off with this Kirin model. I was recently working on its backside and notice…
0 Last
Owldera

Unity 2020 Realistic Haunted House scene Looking for feedback

Hi! I am a prop and Environment artist, and i am working on a scene in unity in my free time. I have made everything from scratch using, zbrush, maya, substance painter, photoshop. Sculpting the mirr…
0 Last
Alcoglory

Victorian Thief's Desk (WIP)

Hello, I have been working on a Victorian Thief's desk for a while and composited a finalized bake of the objects in Substance. I wanted to get some feed back, though, on whether or not the community…
2 Last
Humble_Dragon

Bob

Hello, guys! Beginning my journey here! Would be happy to hear some critique and tips on how to improve the character(and in general the skills). I know myself some troubles to take care of in the fu…
0 Last
PIXLm

3D Victorian House Model [WIP]

Hellooo,I was hoping if anyone was available to offer some critique and help with a current model I am working on for my portfolio. I've only recently gotten into Maya as part of my degree so some fe…
0 Last
Dolypsy892

Detergent Bottle Feedback

Hello guys! I want model complex things. I think that maybe a detergent bottle it's not the correct decision, but the organic shape that those bottles have, I think they serve as a good practice.&nbs…
2 Last
MegaSofteae

Gameboy Advance SP

Hello, I'm new to using 3D and I've been practicing blender for about half a year now. I've made little projects in the past for fun but this week I decided to challenge myself with my first animated…
0 Last
Natebrn

[WIP] Zbrush Ecorche Sculpt Critique. All feedback is much appreciated

Hi guys. Im doing an ecorche study as practice to learn anatomy. This will hopefully a portfolio piece that I will texture and render in arnold. For now im still blocking in the the torso atm. If you…
5 Last
ShawnCassie

Mace Windu - WIP

Hello everyone!I am working on a likeness of Samuel L Jackson as Mace Windu. My plan is to post progress here and hopefully get some feedback from all you skilled artists. So far I am still work…
5 Last
NathanielScheurer

Horned Oxsaur

Hey! I've just registered in polycount to share some art with all of you, I hope this will improve my art with your feedback =)!I recently participated in the ArtStation Challenge Grand Space Op…
4 Last
joseppares3d

[FEEDBACK] Junior portfolio review

Hello everyone!I´m a 3D student and I would love to hear some feedbacks and critiques of my portfolio. The point is to improve and reach a job as a junior 3d artist.Thank you very much.https://www.ar…
6 Last
3dWar

Portfolio Critique

Hi all :)I'm a current second year Game Art student, I'm applying for game industry internships at the moment and would greatly appreciate any feedback and critique anyone would mind giving of my por…
3 Last
PolyHertz

First Maya object model (key) - Am I on the right track?

Hi, I am a complete beginner on AutoDesk Maya, this is my first attempt at creating a key that I designed: https://www.artstation.com/artwork/5X2aY1I am an architectural designer so I have knowledge …
5 Last
francisbaud

2d concept art. Female faun (sketches, critique)

Hello everyone! I'm a 2d artist generalist from Ukraine.  My portfolio: https://www.artstation.com/oksaThis is one of my personal projects I'm currently working on. I finished this concept two d…
2 Last
birb

How should I move forward to improve?

Hello everyone! Something's been bugging me since the start of the year, I feel like I'm getting nowhere as an aspiring 3D artist, specializing in environment. My ever dream is to work in the video g…
5 Last
poopipe

[WIP] Castle reconstruction critique

An ongoing project to restore a well known castle ruin to it's former 17th century glory using Blender and post edit in Photoshop. Help me to make this appear more photoreal?
0 Last
jonathankarlssonse

Colt 1911 (Feedback)

Hi everybody!I made Colt 1911 and currently looking for any feedback or critique.I would deeply appreciate any advice on how to improve this piece.6.3k triangles, 1 texture set 4096x4096.
1 Last
Zi0

The Victorian

Hey everyone! I thought I'd wrap up this project and give it it's final touches. It's been a fun small project, however I didn't want to grind it out too long as there's so much more that I want to e…
1 Last
Ashervisalis

Traveling Robot Monk + Environment (Finished)

I have been working on a full character + plus environment (the base environment was given to me by my partner, Eden West, from her King Arthur challenge on artstation, I essentially built on top of …
5 Last
Mr_Nova

Portfolio Feedback

Hi all, I'm currently in a position where I can pour all my time into improving myself enough to get my foot in the door as a 3D Character Artist but I'm a bit lost regarding the standard of my …
1 Last
birb

Conrinthian Helmet. Feedback please!

Hi everyone! First post on here and hoping to get a decent bit of feedback. Wanting to work in games as a prop artist. Can you guys point out any flaws in my Topology? I tried to optimise the me…
0 Last
lukegallowaysmith

Field Radio Critique

Hi everyone!I've been doing this prop for some time and finally finished.I would deeply appreciate if someone would critique this piece. From geo to textures.It was intended to be game-ready but 16k …
0 Last
ducklover

Portfolio critique / review

Hello guys! I am a concept artist/illustrator based in Costa Rica, I have been studying concept art for a couple of years and I wanted to ask for some direction or insight from professionals! Some fr…
1 Last
carvuliero

ArtStation Portfolio and Critique Help

I am an amateur 3d artist that wants to start looking for junior artistic positions and I was interested in a critique and help to see what is good and what I need to add before I can start looking f…
2 Last
Jean_Pierre_Varg

I need critique on my animation quality

Ignore the fact that it's an MLP brony animation, that's not important. I've been animating for about 4, roughly 5 years, and I have always been trying to improve my skills and craft. I never asked f…
1 Last
EVernier

3D Character Artist - Portfolio Feedback & critique

Hello, everyone. First of all, I want to apologize beforehand because English is NOT my main language, so forgive me if I get mistaken in something here. I am looking for some feedback and critique o…
5 Last
Moneido

battle axe critique required

Hey all. looking for some tips/feedback on a model of an axe I've been working on, concept is by josh Harris.and here is my attempt, just a quick render from marmoset. I tried keeping true to th…
2 Last
MaxAmmo

[Finished] Overgrown Crash Environment - UE4

Starting a new environment to further practice foliage skills and general environment art. Aiming towards a dense forest scene with a single central prop (Tree + Capsule) as the focus. I intend for t…
27 Last
teodar23

Popular Tags