Home› critique

critique

Discussion List

Topic
Replies
Latest Post

Need portfolio feedback! Recent graduate

Hello! I am a recent graduate and currently looking for jobs! I am applying for 3D artist and 3D character artist positions. Excited about indie, small teams and AAA opportunities.I am looking for ad…
9 Last
LizNSkaya

[WIP] Fish restaurant tiles, my first material in substance designer

Hello,This is my very first attempt at creating my own material from scratch and my very first post on polycount. I wanted to try to create a lot of different shapes so that I would become more famil…
4 Last
Baya

3D Beginner Looking for Critique

Hi Guys, I've recently started doing 3d Art, and I'm looking to improve, especially my painting technique. So here's some 3D models I've done and painted.So first of all, a flatshaded? lowish po…
14 Last
wdawg

Portfolio critique - 3D character artist

Hi, I was hoping to get some feedback on my current portfolio/showreel. I've been looking for entry level 3D artist position since i graduated last year with no luck, so any feedback or ideas on how …
7 Last
Blackforks

Badass jacket guy sculpt (Feedback welcome)

This is the current stage, any feedback/suggestions would be greatly appreciated :) 
2 Last
Gumbata

[WIP] - Evelynn V3. Cyberpunk Character NieR inpired

Hello everyone. I'm creating a new version of the main character of the game i'm solo developing at the moment, and since i think i got some better skills since the last time i made her since it's th…
3 Last
kanga

XM25 CDTE - Grenade Launcher

Hi, I recently made this model, I tried a different workflow than usual. I was aiming for lower polycount than I usually end up with, and in some areas you can really notice it. I also tried new thin…
0 Last
SamIndeed

Woman face sculpt- practice

Hello again! I'm sculpting a female face to try and get some practice. Last character sculpt I did I jumped into the details way too early, so this one I'm trying to take slow and get as much critiqu…
2 Last
kianacreates

3D environment Artist Portfolio Critique

Hello everybody. I posted a similar topic a couple of years ago and now i am back with more experience.I would like to get some feedback for my portfolio. Right now I am working as a freelance, but m…
3 Last
NickXenos

USS Discovery in TOS style - Critique

This is a small project I've been working on to try to learn how to use materials a bit better- it has a good variety of shapes to test the look of textures on.  (Also, to see if the design coul…
0 Last
Brandross

Fantasy models for 3D printing (critique)

These are some recent sculpts of DnD characters for 3D printing.  Thorough critique would be much appreciated.  I'm specifically looking to improve my character design, shape/line, anatomy,…
0 Last
Alex_Garton

KH Chakram model: Looking for critique

I have made this Chakram (from Kingdom Hearts) as a test. I would like to get a critique of this model and some advice. I want to improve on my texturing.
3 Last
Soukillaz

PBR Old Binocular, Looking for critique on Texturing

An old Binocular i modeled and textured to learn Substance Painter. Id love to hear your critique, and how i should improve. Some said its a bit "toy-like" due to the not so good metal, but idk how t…
5 Last
Slothfuldrake

Fighting animation critique needed!

Hi! I was wondering if anyone could give me some feedback on this animation I've been working on, specifically in terms of timing and posing, but really I'd be interested in any thoughts you have on …
2 Last
RichyD

Critique on W.I.P- Stylized crab and goldfish

Hey guys, I had a funny idea enter my mind a few days ago and basically; I want to convey a crab rescuing a goldfish from captivity and setting it free into the ocean. I'm planning on making a l…
0 Last
Cherelle

Critique please! World of Warcraft inspired scene

HI guys, i'm trying to practice creating scenes and textures in the World of Warcraft art style! I started this scene a couple days ago and I think i'm happy with it in terms of what is in the scene …
0 Last
ThisisVictoriaZ

Showcasing My Tree Bark Substance- Critiques Welcome

I wanted to make my first tree bark substance for my personal project. I did some learning from a list of artist and how they approach making the base shape for bark. I applied the techniques and inc…
2 Last
Ida_Jay

Showcasing My Forest Ground Substance - Critiques Welcome

I took a crack at making a needle filled ground Substance that will be apart of a Forest Scene I'm making in Unreal. I'm going to make another substance Similar to this soon using the new skills I've…
0 Last
Ida_Jay

Creating New Environment

I want to make a post for anyone needed suggestions on what to create next. I am making a Skyrim environment but don't know which to do. Others opinions can help. 
2 Last
Ashervisalis

[WIP] Character Critique

Hi,Id like to get your opinion on this character i'm working on and maybe get some tips on hair / haircards.Please be brutally honest, thank you.
4 Last
sarasumm

STUDENT IN NEED FOR A PORTFOLIO FEED BACK.

Hi, I am a studen of MA college Amsterdam. i would love to have your opion and facts about my portfolio. Pleas don't hold back give me all the bad review u got and a solution if necessary. …
7 Last
3dReaper

Child Character (Stylised) - Critiques and Comments sought Maya/Arnold

I'm doing a childs head character and wanted to post updates here and request any feedback or critiques.  I'm modelling in Maya, and Rendering With Arnold.The topology i'm pretty happy with save…
1 Last
oskarkeo

mp7, want Critiques, tear me apart

Made in blender,Took around 4-5 days on and off to make.If you have any Critiques or see anything that's off, give me a heads up
3 Last
Stranger

[ZBrush] Rouge Titan sculpt

I finished up an organic sculpting class, but I think I can push this character more.  My goal is to make a realistic Rouge Titan and have it as a portfolio piece.  I tried doing the fiber …
0 Last
Sheers

Help needed with the look of an environment for our Unity game

I'm trying to get a specific look for a 3D environment that I'm having built for my game. My 3D environment artist is fantastic and has done a fabulous job so far. We are, however, having a hard time…
6 Last
omatase

My second hand painted model ever made.

This is the model i made critiques would be awesome. (it has 1103 polys)  
4 Last
manu12el

Domids CritWorkImprovement Thread

A Thread for Critiquing and ImprovingHey there! My name is Dom and I'm a student in my 3rd year of a Games Course practising 3D and 2D. I've spent a lot of my  time drawing and painting trying t…
0 Last
Domids

Portfolio Critique

Hey Everyone,I'm Raul, a 3D character artist / 3D generalist, graduating as a Game Art & Design student.  I can use some feedback on my portfolio, and I was hoping you guys could help m…
1 Last
pmiller001

Environment Art - Critiques Appreciated!

Hi all,First time posting with this site, exciting! So I've been working away at this piece for a while, It's not quite finished yet, but there's something that is off that I can't quite place. …
2 Last
eveyart

Popular Tags