feedback

Topic	Replies	Latest Post
M84 Stun Grenade C&C I recently finished this grenade and was happy with it, but now looking back it seems pretty dull and boring and doesn't really stand out. Anything else that can be added/fixed up to make it more of …	0 Last	Danballs3D Sep 2020
Flame: Critique needed! Hi there! I am new to this forum, but I am really in need of critical feedback! I hope you guys can help.I did a sculpt and it definitely lacks in many ways, as perfection wasn't my goal here. B…	2 Last	Sblendid Sep 2020
Need some feedback i would like to know what can be improved. It is supposed to be a female face in her 20s. I usually find myself struggling with knowing if a part should be bigger or everything around it should be sm…	2 Last	DavidCruz Sep 2020
Head Sculpt - Feedback/critique - Zbrush Currently wanting to do a smaller project to work on some texturing, thought a bust would be appropriate, afew issues with the geometry that i cant seem to Zremesh out, they go away when i dynamesh b…	4 Last	GarethStandfield Aug 2020
Batman Armory - Need Feedback Hey, i am making a scene and I really need someone elses feedback. Because i am working on this scene for some time and i think i lose my objectivity about this scene. I hope you can help me :)	4 Last	JamesBrisnehan Aug 2020
i need feedback on a portrait sculpt aside from asymmetry, what can I do to improve this sculpt? the likeness is based on young Liza Minnelli but my main goal is to make the face look natural.	8 Last	birb Aug 2020
Adding New Details Feedback - Zbrush - WIP So as of right now, everything is symmetrical i will brake that once i have a grasp on were im going. The head and shoulders i like, but the larger scales i like them on the neck but when i adde…	0 Last	GarethStandfield Aug 2020
CV Feedback For a long time I've been wondering what I could improve in my CV, but not knowing anyone, I never had feedback from a 3D Artist or professional from the industry.I'd really appreciate some honest fe…	11 Last	NikhilR Aug 2020
[WIP] Link - BOTW Fanart Making this thread so I have a place to showcase my new WIP, a fanart model of Link from Breath of the Wild! This isn't just a random project, I have a few intentions and goals with it: - I…	3 Last	abrynildsen Jul 2020
Can you give a feedback of my portfolio please? Hi there,I appreciate if someone can give me a feedback of my portfolio. I want to be a game artist (modeler, prop or environment artist), but I don't have luck finding a job.Please help me!!! h…	2 Last	JulioCruzalta Jul 2020
Portfolio feedback wanted. Hey everybody, I am currently finishing up grad school and have begun applying to jobs so I would like some feedback on my portfolio. My team and I are about a month away from finishing our caps…	6 Last	AustinLabarbera Jul 2020
WIP need critiques been working on this for a while and need some critiques on this....a) does it had to be more lit - is it too dark?anywhere it needs any changes thank you in advance	2 Last	roshankarel Jun 2020
Portfolio Feedback (3D Modeling) Hello Everyone,I've made a few posts on Polycount before and got some great feedback for some characters I did. I made a ton of progress through that process so I wanted to share my portfolio as well…	2 Last	Astrocoolbug Jun 2020
[WIP] Beginner Character Artist Anatomy Project Hello Everyone, I’m new to Zbrush for a couple of weeks and I’ve been on a journey to become a Character Artist. After couple of anatomy studies, I went and started this project to put my anatom…	1 Last	carvuliero Jun 2020
1865 Gatling Gun (WIP) \| Critique Wanted Hello there! This is an 1865 gatling gun that I've been working on. I'd like some feedback on the textures I have so far before I export and render them. Anything I could add or change?. The texturin…	12 Last	NURBS Jun 2020
WIP Stylized elf character feedback and critiques Hello. This is my latest project and i am kinda stuck in the sculpting process. I am trying to create a stylized character with inspiration from the Overwatch style. I would like some feedback/critiq…	0 Last	wisra May 2020
What do you think about this topology? Hello, this is my first post in this forum :)I'm modeling a M4 weapon and this is the lower receiver part with high poly, (I have to finish to model the inside of the top circular shape.)There are in…	2 Last	EduardJaumira May 2020
(DESIGNER) Hearthstone WIP Hi guys I'm into a SD challenge with "wooden planks" as theme, I'm making WoW Tavern's floor with some HS cards and mana coins, this is my WIP. Some feedback would be nice! I'll be updating the post,…	0 Last	icebollero May 2020
[WIP] Sci-Fi Corridor. Looking for critiques/feedback please. Would help a ton. Hello fellow artist. Today i come to thee in search of your feedback skills. I recently started making some 3d environments (some based on concept art and others on some ideas that i get) Though none…	4 Last	jStins May 2020
WIP Game Character Model - Looking for general feedback + specific feedback on face appeal Hey y'allBeen working on this guy for a while. Loosely based off a sketch from https://www.artstation.com/artwork/Y5aXVThe model is very much WIP at the moment. Would love some overall critique and f…	2 Last	KaladinCraig May 2020
Feedback on my Showreel for a Job (Click Youtube Video) I would really appreciate feedback on my Showreel if I ever want to present it to an industry to apply for jobs.Show Reel Video: https://youtu.be/Ozz22dUPOYI	1 Last	HarlequinWerewolf May 2020
Portfolio Feedback Hello everyone,My portfolio: https://www.artstation.com/user-ab621255001f805fI'd like to have a feedback on it.I'm currently looking for work and i wonder if this kind of level is enough to get me in…	1 Last	Ashervisalis May 2020
(WIP) Colt M1911 I'm making an M1911 and would like some feedback. I have the low poly and unwrapping done but not the high poly yet. Please tell me what you think and if there's anything I could improve on.	7 Last	NURBS Apr 2020
Arm anatomy studies Feedback wanted I was wondering, im looking for feedback, but and this might sound very silly! but how will i know when i can go back to making characters for portfolios? My current projects have not got me much att…	0 Last	GarethStandfield Mar 2020
(Portfolio Feedback) 3D Environment Artist Portfolio: https://aquiney.artstation.com/Hey everyone. I'd really appreciate it if anybody could give me some feedback on my current portfolio. I've just graduated from my Masters at University…	2 Last	Axemeister Mar 2020
Feedback for textures and lighting---P250 Hi everyone, I've been working on this model for past couple of weeks. Now I'm looking for feedback on my textures and recommendations on how to fix the lighting, because I'm having a hard time setti…	6 Last	Tiggis Feb 2020
[WIP] Sombra \| Early concept \| 3D Rendition Hello Polycount!! I'm working on a new project for my portfolio and I wanted to do a deep-dive on the Overwatch style. I'm taking Sombra's early concept and turning it into 3D. I'd like to get some f…	1 Last	JCorsiArt Feb 2020
Portfolio and Career Advice Hi there,I'm an aspiring 3D artist, looking to get into Games doing props and environments. I'm from New Zealand and it's been really tough finding work. University didn't prepare me at all which was…	10 Last	poopipe Feb 2020
From Character Creation to Animation - Project Progress Hello, I am working on a project where I create a character and go through all the processes to animate it. I am using this thread to keep track of my progress, keep myself accountable and get some m…	7 Last	nhernand Feb 2020
Feedback on 3D Modeling Portfolio Hi, I am a recent graduate. I am currently working on my art and portfolio to get a job in the industry, so I would really appreciate some feedback on what I have so far. I want to work mainly on sty…	6 Last	nhernand Feb 2020
Character face in need of anatomy feedback please Hello, i want to create a warrior around and i am just starting with his face, the reference i have been using are from males between 40 to 50 years old.I feel there is something odd in his eyes/fore…	6 Last	DanielLince Jan 2020
[need some feedback] [Blender] Birth of an Electromancer As a Max user I am slowly trying to learn Blender, and thought I would be a little creative while doing so Blender.Here is my "Birth of an Electromancer" low sampled renders from Blender.I like the a…	2 Last	Zoddo Jan 2020
Recent Re-Work. Feedback is welcomed Here are a few models that I went back to for some re-touching. Just worked on smoothing groups, topology, and added some color to the models. Nothing to complex. Let me what are your thoughts in the…	1 Last	Unknown_Target Dec 2019
Junior 3D Artist Portfolio Feedback Hi everyoneI'm Ivan, a Junior 3D Artist who've been in this industry for 1 year. I just wanted to show my portfolio to everyone here, so you can check out and tell me what do you think about it.I'm a…	6 Last	RipperSplitter Dec 2019
Portfolio Presentation and General Issues. Hey everyone,I was hoping to get some critiques on my Artstation portfolio. You can see it here:https://www.artstation.com/mattkniftonI was hoping for pointers on if I am consistently going wrong any…	2 Last	MdK Dec 2019
Stone Ground Material. How can I make this better? Hey, I did this stone material today with materialize and one of my own reference images. The screenshot on the plane is made in unityI am trying to achieve realism / photorealism for a project. Sinc…	5 Last	VanessaCeline Nov 2019
need feedback/critics I started doing animation less than a month ago and this is my second animation of all time. There are many mistakes, but this is the best I can do at the moment. I know that feedback / criticism is …	0 Last	nalor Nov 2019
Need your Feedback (3D Animation Exercise_12) .Standing-up from Chair \| Spline+ \| Body Mechanicshttps://www.syncsketch.com/sketch/1961399d8c3a/	0 Last	hardiklakhalani Oct 2019
Anatomy studies - Looking for a feedback Hello there polycounters !i've decided to leave my comfort zones and create this postI'm planing to post here my anatomy studies which i'll do as usual, with no time restrictions, and by doing speeds…	0 Last	EvilSylvanas Oct 2019
[WIP] Stylized City Environment Hello everyone, I'm starting a new project that will be ambitious for me. As the title suggests, I'm going to create a stylized environment. It has been a while since I created an environment so I kn…	16 Last	ThatsBurt Oct 2019
[WIP] Bilgewater - 3D Environment Hello there!It´s been a while since the last time I post here, but here I am again :D I decided to start a new environment project with some main objectives to achieve in mind. And I am looking for s…	18 Last	Kebet Sep 2019
Sketchbook: Shawn Cassie looking for critical feedback please im new to this forum and zbrush. much appreciated. This is a printscreen but im going to post bpr renders.Please tell me what is wrong with my bpr render as it do…	8 Last	ShawnCassie Sep 2019
Likeness studies - Zbrush. Heya, i do a likeness study between most of my projects to try see how much iv improved this round id like to try take it a little further and ask for what people think im doing wrong!I can see afew …	0 Last	GarethStandfield Sep 2019
Looking for Portfolio Feedback Hey there! So I graduated this year and I want to find a job as a 3D Artist (maybe Environment Artist).As I want to improve myself and with it, my chance of finding a job, I would appreciate any kind…	3 Last	Ireyon Sep 2019
Art Progression feedback (am i good enough to land an internship at a game studio) Hello and thanks for taking your time to read this!So I don't really know how to structure this, but I'll post a link to my Artstation aswell as post an image from a speed prop I made yesterday.Link …	10 Last	Hiro3D Aug 2019
Demoreel feedback Hello guys!I'm an Environment and prop Artist who just finished my studies and I need some feedback on my Demoreel from my last projects, basic things like composition, shots, music... or anything yo…	2 Last	ItzOmega Aug 2019
Critique on W.I.P- Stylized crab and goldfish Hey guys, I had a funny idea enter my mind a few days ago and basically; I want to convey a crab rescuing a goldfish from captivity and setting it free into the ocean. I'm planning on making a l…	0 Last	Cherelle Jul 2019
Tips to improve to be a good Environment Artist. feel free to add tips and comments. Even tips for portfolio presentation ...	1 Last	Alex_J Jul 2019
Artstation challenge Feedback Hi! this is my WIP from the artstation challenge. Any Feedback is wellcome :3 https://www.artstation.com/contests/the-legend-of-king-arthur/challenges/69/submissions/46452	0 Last	JavierGago Jul 2019
Nils Friberg portfolio critique Hello all!I'm currently in the process of updating my portfolio, and would love some feedback on it.Is it hard to find stuff? Are the project thumbnails good? Does it load too slow? Are all the proje…	4 Last	modebloggen Dec 2015