Firstly I will admit that I want to be anonymous as I dont really want to earn myself any sort of reputation in the games industry that may further hinder my chances at work by being a negative person as I about to make the following rant.
I want to know what people think of my situation and if I should stick to 3D for games, change fields such as 3D in Architecture/Design, or just drop the ball all together and give up. So that is basically my main question.
So here are my points:
1. Lack of jobs in the industry.
I spend a vast amount of time looking for work in the industry I use many top/popular games recruitment websites, agencies, etc, I Google various key words to find new sources. I go through similar forum posts to find jobs, and email companies directly. I hardly ever, ever, ever find a JUNIOR or ENTRY LEVEL in this field and occasional find my specific role. When I do find junior job I jump on it but so do 5000 others, so I am told on different occasions by the agencies. Then there are many deal breakers, such as countries/visas, specific software, Maya over max, zbrush over mudbox, etc. Shipped Titles, Proven experience, I saw a Junior Advert asking for 1 shipped AAA title, Please just die.
2. Industry is flooded with applicants.
Given this is the situation with most jobs with the recession, we always hear and see that the games industry is flooded with more people than other areas such as 3D visualising / architecture, etc. Oh how I wish I would have known that before so I would have never pursued what it seems like every silly boys dream of working in the games industry. I always enjoyed more hands on courses in school such as art, and playing games was always my hobby I think I was given an Atari at the age of 6 or something where I played all my ping pong type games. I actually thought I made a clever choice of career by combining what I do and what I enjoy as a career path. Now I live a bit in regret. Do what you enjoy they said! I doubt it will happen but people need to stop pursuing this field, playing games is not the same as making them. Our value as aspiring 3D artist is at zero.
3. Portfolio expectations OVERKILL.
Yes portfolios are needed and need to be top quality. But why are juniors artist or inexperience artist suppose to have work that might pretty much trash the lead artists work at the company. Is that how much the industry is over flooded, is this what we have stoop so low for? Killer portfolio demonstrating all necessary skills, awesome artistic flare for laughable 16k a year job. That is near minimum wages that is like what a junior administrator gets with no skill set besides common sense.
Are we that worthless as 3D artist if our portfolio is not top notch amazing?
4. Lack of Rewards.
I think its hilarious how the industry tries to undersell us by claiming that we do what we do because we love it, yes we do, and I love doing 3D. But not over playing games or going out with my family or going on holiday. It is still work and if there was no career in it I would have drop it after my 3rd model. We have families, we have bills too, and we would like to live comfortably. Juniors start at 16K, seniors and leads can get up to 35K and thats about it, unless you become a director and earn around 150k a year but you have better luck winning the lottery. What are the rewards of being a game artist? Oh the title itself
Whoopee doo. Doubt anyone will be impressed by that, my family dont understand 3D, so when I show them my work they dont really know what to think of it.
Most people dont, and they dont appreciate the amount of time and man power invested into a film like Transformers etc, Seriously the title is oversold Id like anyone try to sell themselves to a lady at the bar by expressing they are a game artist, it wont do anything for you, my example is a joke but you get the drift.
5. Practice makes perfect.
Practice, Practice, Practice till you have a killer portfolio! After 3 Years of my graduate degree and 2 years training outside that I have done over 200 hours of following tutorials 300 hours replicating it, Many hours and months of modelling my own objects, building up my portfolio. My day consist of doing 3D work, Watching tutorials, reading 3d forums, looking up 3D jobs, and playing video games. My eyes are sore, my back hurts I have constant headaches my eye just starting twitching, Have I had a decent chance at a 3D job yet? Maybe once, future looking bright? No! And Im bloody young!
I dont even remember the things I learn from some of my tutorials I spent hours doing, all the particles, rigging and animation tutorials have all become blurs whilst I focused on props and environments, its impossible.
6. Mod/Indie groups a bit of a joke.
Tried a couple of them, first one I join I worked really hard but people were lazy especially director and it died out very quickly and I left. I tried to join a few top ones which I got accepted to which was all great till they started imposing their silly, oh how silly contracts. One wanted me to work just for credits in the game whilst they were making a paid product, I refused. The second one had royalties involved but they put a nasty in the contracts saying all my work belongs to them and they have the right to terminate me from the group at any time which will in return nil my royalties, felt a bit like a scam. Funny thing is the directors told me they had about 50 or so people under the same conditions all I can say is grow a pair for all those people, this is why we are abused.
7. Overtime and Sweatshop.
Game industry has so much horror stories. Most but not all games industry make you work unpaid overtime which basically contradicts minimum wages. Boom Welcome to slavery. Some are even referred as sweatshops because of the extreme overtime and working conditions, oh how proud I is to be a wannabe game artist, the joy... wannabe gangster and drugs and robbery looking good right about now.
8. Freelance, Out-sourcing.
Ok whilst this can be a good thing too, not really for a junior as you wont really get work without some kind of experience or reputation or again a killer portfolio. Now the bad thing about freelance or out-sourcing is competition get ready to fight against aspiring artists from 3rd world countries such as India, their pricing makes me drop the ball and go home very quickly. Not something I have big experience with just lots of research, not looking very good to be honest.
Conclusion:
Because I left myself as anonymous it will be hard to judge my skill and why I am not getting a chance at the industry but I will try to explain myself.
Firstly I have followed many of the How to break into the industry tips, from various websites, forums, and books I have fully done my research on what to do even to the point of how a game artist should go on about a interview. I think my two main areas of concern is probably my portfolio and networking.
My Portfolio: My portfolio is decent enough, to be fair it shows intermediate level work, its show I can do all parts from modelling to texturing to importing to a game engine and a building a fully finished environment. Its not one of these amateurish ones that you would instantly laugh at. The only thing I can see that is missing in my work is that wow factor. My work doesnt make you say OMG WOW HOLY CRAP! How did he do that? I am at that stage of making my work look from decent/good to amazing/professional, which unfortunately is going to bleed my eyes to death with all the more practicing. Its a big shame that I need to be a pro to get a junior job.
Networking: None really, I am not sure how to go on about this, I do get involved in the forums and always post my work up for feedback and make improvements and do occasional post on others work. Ive tried mixing with the mod groups too, and met a few nice artists, all which are unemployed too, and similarly depressed. So what am I suppose to do in terms of networking? Should I stalk a director that is in need of an organ and plan to bump into him by mistake become his friend over time and offer my kidney and expect a job in return lol.
I have been following the dos and donts, Ive been willing to accept Internships and low wages of up to around 14k a year. I am willing to relocate to a completely different country of which I dont even speak the language as long as I was offered a job. Am I really being unreasonable?
I hardly ever get responses from my job applications, the occasional Auto-mail confirmation, Thanks but no thanks, or thanks we will get in touch if we have suitable vacancy. Ive had just 1 interview since the 5 years I set my eyes on the industry.
My ambition in this industry has gone rotten, so what do you think, time to drop the ball and give up, or shall I keep trying because I am sure a job offer would wipe out the negativity and put a smile on my face.
Replies
People will be seen as bad persons if they are assholes, not for being realistic or asking questions, but as it is now no one can realistically tell you what is wrong unless we can see your portfolio.
The fastest way to get some answers here on polycount would be "here's my portfolio, why am I not getting any responses from companies?"
http://www.sloperama.com/advice.html
Getting your first job is 90% networking and portfolio, those are the only 2 things you should worry about. Honestly you should post your work if you really want good feedback and advice.
Because aspects of the job make it hard for him to get a job, and then offer no justifications for being in that job? :thumbup:
I would personally agree with the above statements. I'm in the pre-rendered CG industry, situation is a little better there.
and to #3, it isn't so much people expecting a over the top amazing portfolio, it is that you are competing with people that have a amazing over the top portfolio for the position.
I've been told too many times that the games industry is small and a bad reputation will hurt you. So better play it safe
You might THINK that portfolio expectations are overkill ... but thats because you haven't worked in an actual studio and seen the TORRENTS of utter BOLLOCKS that we receive on a DAILY BASIS.
"It is still work and if there was no career in it I would have drop it after my 3rd model. We have families, we have bills too, and we would like to live comfortably."
Then go work in admin / another arbitrary office job. If there was no possible career in games ... I would still be making them. I think a lot of other people would aswell. You don't go into games for the money
Then I read this: "Networking: None really."
To quote Adam Savage, "Well there's your problem!"
It made your entire rant seem for nothing. I know that's not the case, but I'm a huge believer in networking being something thats key for a lot of people to land jobs.
I haven't gotten a single one of the jobs I've had in this industry without the help of those that I know. I've never just gotten it with cold-call applications to job postings. These are friends I made and help I got before I was the admin of Polycount.
As a side anecdote: Almost 1 year and 90+ emails between me and Ubisoft before I ever sat down at a desk working for them. And this wasn't an entry level position. It can take time.
What I need to clarify, though, is this: Networking isn't the solution. It's not a guarantee for a job. It's just the way I've always gotten a job. You can certainly get a job via a job application through a website. Lots have. And if you're talented enough and fit exactly what the studio needs, then whether you've cold-called the job or had a friend get you in through the side window won't matter how you've gotten the job because you're now being paid.
This job certainly has its rewards and your claim that it doesn't is false. If you're at a company and feel like you're being exploited because you're a passionate person than its your responsibility to do something about it, not theirs.
The horror stories of overtime are just that, horror stories. You have control over whether or not you're going to work 40+ hours or not and if you think its justified. No one is tying you down and lashing you until you do. The only time I've worked overtime, was because the work I committed to needed to be finished by a time that I agreed to have it ready for. And this is true for many cases of overtime. Very little (read: once in the past 7 years) was I doing overtime because it demanded by the studio. And even then it was at a time and duration that was made aware to us weeks before it happened.
TL;DR: Chin up, and if this is something you want to do you'll eventually get that job. It's not slave work and manual labor, it's game art and a job the majority of those who do it love doing. Like any job, it has its ups and downs, but the positives of this job far outweigh the negatives. And its not often you can find a job where you love what you do and you're surrounded with peers who love what they do. It's worth the effort needed.
Yet I see plenty of people around me, with the ability to really make some great stuff in those respective areas, and instead, want to push mediocre portfolio's in 2D/3D arts to enter the game industry.
Same thing with people who are good in other areas. Some kid who has a knack for being a civil engineer, or has good family connections to start a restaurant, wants in on the game industry, nothing bad in-it-self, but in this world, nowadays, people should be picking up the safer and more logical solutions.
I guess what I'm trying to say is that it's ironic on how people complain about this point, when they themselves could be better at something else in said respective area.
For everything that is holy, we need more technical programmers...honestly.
When in doubt, C4!
Show us your portfolio.
I've clearly stated Help on the networking part, not people repeating what I said but tips on how I can fix that situation.
I've also stated that is it's unfair we can't get a junior level jobs without wow/amazing portfolio.
I think it's really easy for artists who are inside looking out on us who are starving in the rain and dismissing the surrounding problems.
1-3 hours a day sometimes none, seriously are trying to say I'm dumb enough to play 10 hours a day and not realise that was my downfall? At the moment I see my playing as advantage plus to put on my CV as a hobby.
http://drewhunt3d.carbonmade.com/
you've just got to stay determined ...freelance is an awesome place to start...you won't be doing the next-gen blizzard MMO..but there is work out there if you are looking for it..as far a networking...Hi I'm Drew...if you want an honest critique of your portfolio...I'll give you one and not out you...ahunt32@gmail.com
Yeah... see even hearing you say you are finding it hard with your experience and portfolio makes me very wary of the field.
It's already out there and i've had feedback, just not directly linked to this thread. Unfortunately it's going to say that way as you can there are some people who don't agree with me and start spreading facepalming images and dismissive single paragraphs.
I wouldn't say I'm terrible fucking artist, but thanks.
I dont think i would be in the top 10 applications of say 500 applications maybe around the 50th or 100th it's hard to estimate.
Think of this way I have a passed an Art test with a company and then had interview which went well, but then was told they are looking for senior staff and would let me know when junior vacancy is available.
I was told by people on these vary forums that I am good enough to start looking for freelance work, on places like indie/royalty forums.
Newb level = no jobs
Intermidiate lvl = no jobs
intermidiate creeping up to pro = no jobs
Pro level = All jobs here, including juniors and interns. Lol.
As far as JR and Entry level positions being listed, nobody lists that. Companies don't want unskilled people. If you see a job that asks for 2-3 years of experience that's code for an entry level job.
Check this out, I made this portfolio in 2009 and it's gotten me two jobs: BUSTED ASS PORTFOLIO
(I've only recently realized it doesn't work correctly in chrome - HAH!)
that is just how it works in a competitive job market for any field.
Like you said earlier you think you prolly rank in 50th or lower in say 500 submissions, and for the person doing the hiring there trying to get the best bang for there buck. Which is where networking comes in, if someone already in the industry thinks you can grow on the job to acceptable quality they might take a chance on you.
Even if I was curious about hiring you, after reading this thread and wanted to see some of your work I couldn't(which is a very bad thing).
Its really hard to know if you're any good, if you're really doing much to improve your work, if you're over or underestimating the quality of your own work, etc. Which in turn really makes it hard to even give you any advice. You can try to convince me that your work is good, that you're working very hard at improving, but its all pretty meaningless to just say it.
So unfortunately the net result of this thread is just going to be people calling your out for being a weirdo who creates a new account and is afraid to show his work, which isn't all that unreasonable, and people who feel pity for you and give you the "Hey, keep at it, man" speech. If all you're after is pity thats ok I guess, but if you want serious advice on your work and your career, you need to drop the anonymous stuff and be real.
Hah! Don't confuse me on someone looking from inside out.
Don't you dare tell me about unfair.
I bust my ass all day doing graphic design work at a University in the ass of Redneck, USA for not much over min wage, no benefits and the Uni cock-blocking my bosses. I just finished a month and half of design work in under two weeks WHILE doing a complete website redesign for HR, running registers, answering the phones, preparing for a business trip next week and being laid off all of September (with accompanying unemployment office bullshit). That's AFTER a month and half of getting $500+k worth of NEW merchandise in our store, tagging/data entry/photographing/sorting AND the start of the semester rush with 3500+ web orders and countless students in the store.
So suck it up and get it done.
And yes I will post the facepalm. It's highly appropriate here. You post a rant on your view of the industry and why wont they hire you and then immediately give use the exact reasons why you aren't being hired.
I'm not trying to be an ass. I wish you all the luck in the world. I know you can do it. I really do want you to succeed but you have to look at it realistically.
No place will open a junior position just because you want the experience. If your portfolio is good enough, that covers the experience. They won't hire you on your potential. It's simple as that.
You want networking? You're at the right place. Network. Go do it. Respond to your portfolio critiques. Critique other's work. ENGAGE with the other posters around here. Make friends. If you in an area with the meetups/sketchgroups, GO!
Sure the economy is down, the industry this, the industry that, blame the industry, whatever, the jobs are there if you look enough and MAKE them want you. Make yourself an asset and not a liability.
You say you rank 50th or lower? Well, how many artists are in an average studio? Answer that and see where you fall.
You don't show any confidence in your abilities or your attitude. And I'm talking real confidence, not arrogance.
You don't show us that you are someone that would be fun to work with.
You don't come across as someone who can get it done.
You're wary of the field. You don't want it bad enough.
You're being overly defensive.
You're sulking.
You want a pity party.
You want us to tell you to buck up and it'll be okay.
But it won't happen unless you make it happen.
When was the last time your bosses told you they loved you?
When was the last time YOUR bosses CRIED when they knew you had to take time off?
Whatever you choose good luck. By the way, about the horror stories there are plenty more happy stories, they are just not as flashy or exciting as the horror ones, so people don't tell them.
This isn't a thread to gain popularity or land a job from. It isnt a thread for people to feel pity for me either, these are problems I've been facing and thinking in my head all the time so I've come and out and written it all down which in return gave me stress relieved and get opinions on it, I'm actually glad some people have admitted to similar problems I thought I'd just get bashed because I had negative review on the situation. I've also asked questions on the main post which most haven't really replied directly to.
I'm not afraid of putting out work. This is keeping in order. People complain about their bosses all the time, but hardly ever to their bosses faces, this is somewhat similar, don't shit where you eat. Although I'm not eating much....
That still isn't enough though. You talk about not having an amazing portfolio. Well that's probably your number 1 problem. In the end it's all about art. I look at my folio and I know why I get passed up for jobs and I have years of experience, strong technical understandings on pipelines and tech art related tasks and basically anything else an enviro guy would need to know. I have worked on several titles and contributed on many titles as a freelancer BUT my biggest down fall is my portfolio.
I look at it and it's decent but it's not amazing. You look at guys like, well what Snefer has been doing recently and that is amazing work. That is the type of stuff that will land you jobs. That is the type of stuff that will teach you new techniques and will be a way to push yourself.
I love playing games BUT I also like to work and just this Monday I was let go from my job. I could have come home and just played Gears 3 or Rage but shit man, I got bills to pay and I can't be fucking around. I got on the phone, updated my folio, updated my linkedin, my resume, site info, posted on facebook, tweeted my followers, etc. I got the message out there as fast as possible that I was looking for a job. I got on every site and started applying to any job that was available and even sent my stuff to places that didn't have postings just in case they were still looking. It takes a lot of time to fill out all the apps, browse the sites, send all the stuff out but what else are you doing that is preventing you from getting it done? Games? Family? Movies? Other job? I've got a family, 2 small kids that want to hang out all the time and have fun and trust me I would rather do that any day of the week but you gotta sacrifice sometimes. I do that because I love what I do and want to stay a part of this industry and because of my persistence I already have several job leads, art tests and potentials. I've had several people I know on here call me a stubborn bastard and they are right. Don't just sit there and hang your head, it won't get you anywhere.
There are so many let downs in life and this industry as well with cancelled projects, studio closures, massive layoffs, politics, etc but it's a great thing to be a part of in the end and beats the hell out of retail or some office job.
So get back to work on your folio and make some kick ass pieces cause that is what is going to land you your job, and do some fucking networking for gods sake.
I have the outlook that getting hired is a side effect or bonus... I enjoy what I do, i'd be doing it regardless because its what interests me, and it just so happens that by doing it i will eventually develop my skills to a point where other people will have a use for my ability.
So wrong, I think you broke a few of the seven deadly sins with the comment.
Besides that I really can't take you seriously flashing that Naruto icon about, surely you must be a kid.
Well then, spend less time creating threads to whine about how terrible your situation is, and more time creating productive threads, getting critiques on your work etc. I have no sympathy for someone who is going to hide behind an anonymous account and cry. Its just a waste of everyone's time.
This is more like taking out a classified ad anonymously in the paper to rant, than simply ranting to your friends. Your friends at-least know who you are and can possibly relate. With this you're just some random guy, and honestly, who cares?
"Besides that I really can't take you seriously flashing that Naruto icon about, surely you must be a kid."
Now i think youre a fucking tool. Ah well, i probably wont have to work with you, right?
Ok Berserk boy. I feel where you coming from since you have a icon from an anime too. F* tool? really? I deserved that?
Im not one of those people who tried and failed and came to rant about the industry, I just realize how much time ill need to dedicate only to get better and better, and to not even be guaranteed a job when I get there. Or having to relocate possibly to another country, work overtime, etc etc.
Dunno, but ill be watching this thread. The Industry isn't the same for people just entering as it is for people who have been doing 3d since 199#
Good luck with everything.
Thanks... But it may be because im referring to UK wages? Pound salary. I doubt they are really that far off as that what people have said on forums, salary websites and Salaries mention on job adverts...
Hey, that's the nice thing about creating an account just to bitch right? No accountability. At-least JackWhat has the decency to stand by his statements when he's being an asshole.
Snemmy actually gave you some very good advice, but you're far too dismissive and defensive to listen. You brush off his post because he... has an anime character for an avatar? Good move.
I agree, if you people just put their love for game art aside and saw the work as overall it will probably wont have much attraction for it. I guess the that the burden of something that is a hobby/work.
EarthQuake you keep mentioning that this thread is pointless and useless and im some random guy, why dont you get out of it already why contradict yourself.
you kids today with your fancy uv tools, and 4096x4096 maps...-waves cane-
Also, networking is important. Here's how I broke into the industry.
I competed in the eat3d Competition #1 and won 3rd place. I got the contact info of one of the judges who worked at ID Software. I sent him an email, and got an art test. Then I became an intern, and now I'm full time.
Thanks Mheyman, This is what I like a bit of harsh post, but still constructive. I have read it and believe me I am considering the things you said. Although you pointed out the most common thing to much "get over it" doesn't work like that mate... You can't go to Africa and Say "ITS TOUGH GET OVER IT" the goverment can't tell you "ITS TOUGH GET OVER IT". But nethertheless you made some good points. Thanks.
Telling a mod and one of the most helpful and best member of our community to "get out" of a thread is making you look like an arogant asshole. I guess you're right, its probably a good idea not to post your work.