Home 3D Art Showcase & Critiques

Time to post some work...

Hi all-

I've been on the forum a while now but haven't to date posted any work. Well, all that's about to change! I'm currently working as a primary school teacher, but am looking to change careers and work in 3D for games as this is my passion (or obsession, if my wife is to be believed).

The following images represent the last few months' work in my spare time- I've just left my fulltime job to become a supply teacher so that I can work on portfolio and developing my skills. These pieces are the third 3D model I've done onwards. The first two are so hideous no-one deserves to have them inflicted upon their eyes!

(apologies for the photobucket links- I guess I've not posted enough to be able to attach images yet).

First up, a soldier type that I did after watching a gnomon DVD on integrating ZBrush into low poly workflow. This was also my first attempt at texturing. He came in at 8.5K and has two textures, one for his head and goggles, and one for everything else. Were I to model him now I think I could easily shave about 2K off by making better choices about edgeloops and poly flow!



soldier_front.jpg

soldier_sides.jpg

soldier_rear.jpg


Some basic posing...we don't talk about what happened when I tried to rig his legs :P


soldier_gunfire.jpg

Trying out facial bones and alternate textures...

soldier_heads.jpg

This is the ZBrush sculpt that I created intially- the topology for the low res was then done in Topogun

soldierZB.jpg

The texture mapping for this guy was my first run through, so I didn't use my texture space optimally.


Model number four was this "toad" alien guy, based on a sketch I did a couple of years back. I know aliens are tres passe but please bear with me! I wanted to have a go at some hard surface stuff. He's just under 6K with one texture for everything. NB- giving his over-long arms was a design decision rather than crappy proportions- although I'm not too sure about the result!

toad_front.jpg

toad_rear.jpg

toad_closeup.jpg

His ZB sculpt...

toadZB.jpg

Once I finished him I wanted to make a weapon and a mount for him. I went for a komodo dragon as the basis for the design. I sculpted and modelled this in two days, plus another three to get the maps and textures done (due to some massive normal mapping errors that took a day to figure out). He is 3.2K with one texture.

komodo_side.jpg

Straight to the Zb sculpt...

komodoZB.jpg

The weapon was two days' hard push start to finish . I found time along the way to do a concept paintover before starting the game mesh and texturing, which I've included as well!

gunconceptcopy.jpg


And the low. This is 850 polys and one texture.


assault_cannon_views.jpg

and everything put together for this project:

toad_posed_front.jpg

toad_posed_side.jpg


That's 10K poly all in with three textures, the main guy at 2056 and the others at 1024. Looking at them together, I would make the komodo the biggest texture, but at the time of making the alien, I didn't know I was modelling the rest!

I haven't posted wires or maps initially, but should anyone wish to crit those as well, I can stick 'em up!

Next up is a female low-tech sci fi character and some work on environment stuff- plus I have a bunch of cyborg and robot designs to model, but they'll have to wait while I get my organic modelling better!

Thanks for being patient with my very long thread- all critique welcome as I am seeking to improve to the point where someone would consider my skillset of employable quality!!

Thanks a bunch

~P~

Replies

  • praxedes
    A couple of images which would have taken me over the limit...

    closeup on the human's face

    soldier_closeup.jpg

    some more posing

    soldier_pointing.jpg

    the ZB for the gun (ZB used to add rivet detail- mostly modelled in Maya)

    gunZB.jpg

    a nice side view of the gun low poly model

    assault_cannon_side.jpg

    and, as a random one, here's the very first thing I ever made in 3D (but not one of the two revolting game models I did), courtesy of Blender and a LOT of help on the Blendernewbies forums!

    goblinrender10.jpg
  • Ninjas
    Offline / Send Message
    Ninjas polycounter lvl 18
    My favorite piece is the lizard. I love how his skin material looks, but I think it would look much better with more geo. A lot of things that should be popped out are flat, and the elbows and tail could use more edge loops

    The next best piece is the soldier, although I think the legs are too long. His mouth also looks really huge.

    Nice work overall
  • conte
    Offline / Send Message
    conte polycounter lvl 18
    imho, frog is best thing here.
    first character needs more texture work.
  • d00kie
    Offline / Send Message
    d00kie polycounter lvl 17
    nice work!

    The soldier is pretty good. But like previously mentioned, it needs some more love on the textures. You've got a great sculpt, but mediocre textures! Show those textures the same love you gave the sculpt and he'll be badass.
    Also, he seems a bit feminine in the waist area to me. I'd widen his waist just a bit more so it doesn't go in as much. Just a thought!
    Now that I look at it, are his arms too short? Bah, maybe it's just these old eyes.

    The lizard mount looks good too, but there's one thing about the design that's bothering me. Why are there spikes on the top of the tail near the saddle and not on the end? It'd make for sweet tailwhipping, bashing action were they on the end! Not unless those spikes are there to deter other hijacking frogmen.

    The design of the frogman also makes me sad that he doesn't have frog feet. I know you're done and all with the model and it looks great, but if he had exposed frog feet or some kind of frog feet boots, it'd be killer.
  • Canden Picard
    Good stuff man, THe style feels a little Gears of war-ish. That isnt a bad thing, just feels like it.
  • Rumkugel
    Offline / Send Message
    Rumkugel polycounter lvl 14
    the boot´s shape on the grunt look wonky.
    also the vest, makes him look like a raver on the christopher street day (it being too small some sizes)
    would make it larger, more bulky.
  • praxedes
    Thanks all for the comments! Much appreciated as it all helps improve my work!

    @Ninjas- you're right re. more geometry on the lizard- I was trying to keep the whole piece under 10K just to see if I could keep to the limit. However, those blades around his head- by switching out the spheres for icospheres I can save (drumroll...) 500 polys!!! which lets me do a shitload for the rest of the beast.

    @conte/d00kie- cool; I enjoy texturing and am happy to put some more time in on his. What kind of thing are you thinking? Oh- froggy feet would indeed be cool but at the time I had a real thing for wanting to make boots. I guess I should stick to the design and not cram everything onto one model :)

    @Rumkugel- fair enough, it's my first armour piece. I will get better!!

    @ Picard-I have been playing a lot of GoW it's true :)

    Thanks all for the crits! I'll update where I can and post new stuff ASAP. One question- I wondered if the red on the gun was too saturated? OPinions appreciated!

    ~P~
  • crazyfingers
    Offline / Send Message
    crazyfingers polycounter lvl 10
    Too saturated, I think real men use pink guns ;)
  • praxedes
    I actually DID laugh out loud for that! :D
  • Harry
    Offline / Send Message
    Harry polycounter lvl 13
    on your soldier dude, looks nice but somehow the textures feel a bit washed out or weak, should be an easy fix.
    Also he's carrying around ammunition for a weapon he doesnt have... And doesnt seem to have any supplies for the p90 ;)
  • throttlekitty
    Offline / Send Message
    throttlekitty ngon master
    I rather like the textures on the soldier. But the way the backpack comes even with the vest in the back is a bit distracting to the eye, maybe giving it a little drag/weight would help?
  • praxedes
    Thanks again for the advice. I also had issues with the placement of the backpack, as from certain angles it looks too inline with the waist. I'm experimenting with altenate texturing for him. Like I said, he was my first texture project and when I did them, I didn't have a renderer (for some reason my expensive BOXX crashes out when asked to render an 8k character from Maya)- so I was relying entirely on the Maya perspective window for how the textures looked, which wasn't ideal!

    Got some ideas about moving this forward now, though, thanks- now to decide between fixing these guys up or cracking on with my new piece before returning to the world of work next week!

    Cheers

    ~P~
  • praxedes
    oh- regards the soldier's ammo....I have no answer. He must have grabbed the wrong bag as he left base.

    I'll look into it :D

    ~P~
  • Harry
    Offline / Send Message
    Harry polycounter lvl 13
    praxedes wrote: »
    oh- regards the soldier's ammo....I have no answer. He must have grabbed the wrong bag as he left base.

    I'll look into it :D

    ~P~


    It's not really something worth changing, but for your curiousity, this is how p90 magazines look (this is an airsoft one by the look of it but the general shape and plasticness is the same)
    tm_p90mag_300rd_1_mark.jpg
  • praxedes
    @Harry- cool thanks! I am planning to make a couple of tweaks, and that doesn't look like it'd take long to do so I will try to add these in :)

    ~P~
  • c0ldhands
    Offline / Send Message
    c0ldhands polycounter lvl 15
    Is the frog a bit Locust(GOW) inspired or is it just me?
  • poopinmymouth
    Offline / Send Message
    poopinmymouth polycounter lvl 19
    I feel like the execution on these is wildly inconsistent. You have some great sculpting on the human, both on his anatomy and his clothing. The arms of the frog, and parts of the lizard have really nice details too, but then the overall structure of the lizard is kind of awkward, he doesn't really feel like real anatomy is being applied. It's like the medium and small scale details are right, but the overall proportions are off. But your proportions on the human are spot on.

    Then on the textures, you have some really nice details on the lizard skin, and the metal bits of the frog, but the human is all very smooth colors without enough variation and grit.

    I think you clearly have a good eye, and it looks like you understand the principles of next-gen art creation, but I would try to work up the cohesion of the pieces. Try to get the diffuse map to match the material types better, especially in color, saturation, and brightness values. On overlapping elements like the frog's teethe, they need to feel more anchored into the head.

    I'm pretty sure if you keep using your critical eye, especially at the texturing stage, and make several more pieces, you'll really see your art progress.
  • praxedes
    @poopinmymouth:

    that's really useful, thanks. I'm pretty satisified that the texturing on the human is not up to par based on suggestions from the thread, and I'm inclined to agree regards the big lizard's anatomy as well. It was a fast sculpt and I think that is reflected in the quality of the anatomy.

    I'm very interested in texturing, and am intrigued by what you mean by matching the diffuse to material types better- I am probably being dense but could you clarify, possibly using an example screenshot for reference? I understand if this would take too much time but it'd be really helpful! On the frog's teeth, I'm guessing it's to do with the lighting and shading painted into the map to reflect the occlusion that would occur where the two surfaces meet?

    I've begun my next piece and want to really progress! The critique from this forum has been invaluable in re-evaluating what I have done so far with a more critical eye, as it's very easy to get too close to the work staring at it for hours on end! Thanks to all who have taken the time to comment. I hope to show some revised work on the soldier textures shortly (I won't be re-visiting the lizard; time to move to new peices!).

    ~P~
Sign In or Register to comment.