I would like critique and tips

Skov

I made a mirror using a lot of different tools and i dont know if this prop i made would be good enough quality for games.
https://www.artstation.com/artwork/L22L3k

Ged

nice work, looks good, the topology isn't wonderful but its certainly passable. you could have avoided all the pinching in the center of the mirror by having mostly quad polys that go across the mirror instead of to a point, that probably doesn't effect the final result but is neater work. The dirt around the edge of the mirror reads a bit heavy handed on the viewer but that could just be the viewer. Personally I think a few more pieces of this quality in your portfolio and you will be in a decent position to apply for jobs.

Brian "Panda" Choi

Now make it actually reflect in a game engine like RDR2.

Several edgeloops on the flat faces of the frame need to be removed as they do little to contribute to the silhouette.

Skov

Brian "Panda" Choi said:

Now make it actually reflect in a game engine like RDR2.

Several edgeloops on the flat faces of the frame need to be removed as they do little to contribute to the silhouette.

I thought about those edgeloops as well. Also how would i put it into RDR2 im not familiar with that engine.

Brian "Panda" Choi

Well, there are alternative free ones a lot of us are using at work and hobby stuff.

Unreal and Unity to name a few.

Skov

Thanks i will try out unreal then I just thought by RDR2 you meant Red Dead Redemtion 2 and i definitely don't have that engine

Brian "Panda" Choi

I could somewhat understand that confusion.  I forgot to make RDR2 a posessive RDR2's.

shabba

Is it gold trim? Maybe consider pbr for gold having black albedo+whatever you grunge on top. If its not, then disregard this

Ashervisalis

@shabba I'm curious why you're suggesting the gold part have a black albedo!

Skov

Ashervisalis said:

@shabba I'm curious why you're suggesting the gold part have a black albedo!

Yeah i am as well i could understand what you meant if it was vray or corona or something alike that kind of renderer, but otherwise im not sure what you mean. @shabba

Skov

Im starting to make a bunch of other models as well to make a whole house. Does this effect work

Ged

Hey nice idea making a house, What effect do you mean? the worn fabric or the white dusty stuff? Id recommend just comparing it to some reference, 

Skov

yeah the fabric and dust effect. I kinda did a full house now xD gonna work on it a bit more though

Skov

Btw BriBrian "Panda" Choi said:

Now make it actually reflect in a game engine like RDR2.

This is a screengrab from unreal engine