Home 3D Art Showcase & Critiques

Glock 17

Game model of the Glock 17 semi-automatic pistol (rigged and animated for game)
comments and criticism encouraged just trying to improve my model/texture before I use it for another game
glock_17_by_dodgeandburnpro-d5n7ppj.jpg

Replies

  • odium
    Offline / Send Message
    odium polycounter lvl 18
    Oh... Quake 1 engine?

    I kid!!!

    Flats, wires etc, otherwise we may as well crit the carpet in the local loo.
  • DodgeAndBurn
    odium wrote: »
    Oh... Quake 1 engine?

    I kid!!!

    Flats, wires etc, otherwise we may as well crit the carpet in the local loo.

    Will have to dig them out because they're on an old hard drive somewhere, just had this render lying around so I thought I'd throw it up here and see what you guys think,the wireframe and textures are inbound
  • DodgeAndBurn
    vector2_by_dodgeandburnpro-d5n8tb4.jpg
    vector1_by_dodgeandburnpro-d5n8t4o.jpg
    vector3_by_dodgeandburnpro-d5n8tej.jpg

    Vector render from 2 different angles and a shot of the rig, actually managed to find the textures but they are unbelievably bad UV's and such so Ill re-do those before I upload ( I made this model at the end of my first year of modelling so I hadn't really learnt the ins and outs of UVing at this point

    {Edit} Just thought I'd add the poly count is just short of 6k tri's without a clean up
  • wirrexx
    Offline / Send Message
    wirrexx quad damage
    did you just project the Texture onto the modell? cause it needs alot of work or is it the lightning .

    The pros: Clean Modell very clean

    The Cons: Bad texture, very bad.


    Tips: Could've made the glock highpoly and projected the detailed parts onto the Low poly. Even a AO map would've helped it =).

    Keep at it! =)
  • DodgeAndBurn
    wirrexx wrote: »
    did you just project the Texture onto the modell? cause it needs alot of work or is it the lightning .

    The pros: Clean Modell very clean

    The Cons: Bad texture, very bad.


    Tips: Could've made the glock highpoly and projected the detailed parts onto the Low poly. Even a AO map would've helped it =).

    Keep at it! =)

    Thanks very much for the encouragement, the texture was taken from a side view of the actually gun and I used the plainer parts of the weapon to generate the sides and other bits that weren't visible on the image, I've since learnt that is a bad technique and I was thinking of scrapping the texture and starting again anyway. I will keep updated with any progress
  • odium
    Offline / Send Message
    odium polycounter lvl 18
    That is a LOT of wasted polies :(
  • DodgeAndBurn
    odium wrote: »
    That is a LOT of wasted polies :(

    I wouldn't say alot but yeah I haven't gone through clean up as this is a model I made after about 8 months of modeling and I've just decided to drag in out now I have a bit more experience, also I don't know if you can see but there are extrudes on the slide that go inwards so that accounts for the polys there, aside from the grip on the handle that's a bit high I don't really see where I could reduce, if its not too much trouble could you circle where I could reduce?
  • S_ource
    Offline / Send Message
    S_ource polycounter lvl 9
    you could reduce on grip, don't need much detail anyway since it will be covered by a hand. The trigger and trigger guard has loops that does not add to much detail or shape, such things you could reduce.
  • SouthpawSid
    Offline / Send Message
    SouthpawSid polycounter lvl 7
    this is the type of modeling I typically see in Maya users for whatever reason (some, not all of course). Not trying to be a jerk. Just noticing. Lots of of edge loops left in that don't need to be there >_<

    Let's see a nice hi res glock to get some normal map info from! Then go back and optimize your lo res, new UVS, sexy bakes, all that jazz. Keep going :)
  • skurmedel
    For the rig, you don't really need any joints for this. They are just gonna complicate matters.

    Instead you can do more or less everything with simple hierarchies and constraints. Most of the moving parts move around a well defined axis and have more or less only one degree of freedom. Just make sure when you are done modelling that everything has a sensible pivots, clean transforms and good names and it's gonna be a breeze.
  • DodgeAndBurn
    S_ource wrote: »
    you could reduce on grip, don't need much detail anyway since it will be covered by a hand. The trigger and trigger guard has loops that does not add to much detail or shape, such things you could reduce.

    Genuinely helpful comment, straight to the point and very clear.
    Thanks you very much for the help
  • DodgeAndBurn
    this is the type of modeling I typically see in Maya users for whatever reason (some, not all of course). Not trying to be a jerk. Just noticing. Lots of of edge loops left in that don't need to be there >_<

    Let's see a nice hi res glock to get some normal map info from! Then go back and optimize your lo res, new UVS, sexy bakes, all that jazz. Keep going :)

    Thanks for the reply

    As I mentioned earlier I made this very early on when I was learning modeling and didn't really know about edge flow or optimization or anything. Just thought I'd post this as an early example of my work, now I have some feed back on where to improve on it I think I'm defiantly going to pull it out the cupboard and do some work on it.

    As for the high res model to bake would you suggest hard surface sculpting in Z brush or just going high poly in maya as I don't really have much experience with sculpting?
  • DodgeAndBurn
    skurmedel wrote: »
    For the rig, you don't really need any joints for this. They are just gonna complicate matters.

    Instead you can do more or less everything with simple hierarchies and constraints. Most of the moving parts move around a well defined axis and have more or less only one degree of freedom. Just make sure when you are done modelling that everything has a sensible pivots, clean transforms and good names and it's gonna be a breeze.

    Not sure if I made it clear in my earlier post but I already have this weapon functioning in a game engine so the rig isn't really a problem.

    I'm not entirely sure how I would go about doing this hierarchie method, is it literally just parenting the objects to controllers similar to a facial rig?

    A link to as tutorial explaining this would be helpful thanks :)
  • skurmedel
  • skurmedel
    Not sure if I made it clear in my earlier post but I already have this weapon functioning in a game engine so the rig isn't really a problem.

    I'm not entirely sure how I would go about doing this hierarchie method, is it literally just parenting the objects to controllers similar to a facial rig?

    A link to as tutorial explaining this would be helpful thanks :)

    Sorry, didn't read too well :) Thought you would bake the animations.
Sign In or Register to comment.