i think most of the guys liked the idea of dire/radiant and single item competition
we could do like that: (if you guys agree)
dire this month (following the one people used before on the posts =] )
single item for a hero (should we narrow it to a main weapon or could be open for other like head piece,armor or mount?)
@Tvidotto don't know what happened, however link of my item in first post goes just to its image instead of workshop page. Could you please look into it?
I'm really not a fan of posting the poll on reddit. Reddit isn't the most consistent community in the world and they only judge items by how they look instead of how much work was put into then and how well thy fit the heroes. I think we should keep the voting just on polycount or select some judges.
Having a public poll is a great way to gauge, well, the public. Reddit is a pretty diverse community in that regard, even though they tend to hivemind when votes are public. That being said, unlike reddit where you see the results before you make a decision to up or downvote, the results for this poll are hidden until you decide.
I do think it's a great idea to have some people as official judges with weight on their votes to go through the work and rate in on a few different scales: Design, execution, compatibility, and overall. Or something like that.
I think between the two different voting styles we'd be able to get some agreeable results.
I'm really not a fan of posting the poll on reddit. Reddit isn't the most consistent community in the world and they only judge items by how they look instead of how much work was put into then and how well thy fit the heroes. I think we should keep the voting just on polycount or select some judges.
Having a public poll is a great way to gauge, well, the public. Reddit is a pretty diverse community in that regard, even though they tend to hivemind when votes are public. That being said, unlike reddit where you see the results before you make a decision to up or downvote, the results for this poll are hidden until you decide.
I do think it's a great idea to have some people as official judges with weight on their votes to go through the work and rate in on a few different scales: Design, execution, compatibility, and overall. Or something like that.
I think between the two different voting styles we'd be able to get some agreeable results.
that is a good idea indeed, we could make in a future 2 kind of winners
one with judges and one public!
Like Chaemirix said, reddit is nice because they are direct on the point. if they dont like they say =]
sometimes the ammount of work is not the most important aspect, we are doing that for the dota community, the ammount of work is probably not the most important thing. in that place some judges from polycount would help it =]
Replies
we could do like that: (if you guys agree)
dire this month (following the one people used before on the posts =] )
single item for a hero (should we narrow it to a main weapon or could be open for other like head piece,armor or mount?)
could be called "The Evil Month" =]
Personally I prefer to be open for all types of items. I would love to make a single mount
preparing the post!
btw, if i forgot any item on this month plz let me know
I've made the changes to my post. It's on page 9. If it's too late I understand.:(
thanks!
updated both, the image link on Konras item and added FungalLord
i think we are good to go now?
http://www.polycount.com/forum/showthread.php?p=1873113
im planning to make a single pool with multiple options for set and single item, if someone doesnt agree with that let me know soon =]
---FINISHED SETS
Wild tide by Mantra
The Wood's Warrior by DeerHunter
The Aegis of the Wood by Prophet9
Vitamin C Deficiency by Zenchuck
FungalLord by Willypup and Robo
---FINISHED SINGLE ITEMS
Savage Riptide by DUSK
Charred Runestick by Coyo.Te
Force of Nature by JIM
VOCIOUS AEON by Konras
Bludgeon of the Aquatic Steed by Airborn Studios
let me know if i need to change anything
http://www.reddit.com/r/DotA2/comments/1ht3at/help_us_choose_the_winners_on_our_unnoficial/
I do think it's a great idea to have some people as official judges with weight on their votes to go through the work and rate in on a few different scales: Design, execution, compatibility, and overall. Or something like that.
I think between the two different voting styles we'd be able to get some agreeable results.
that is a good idea indeed, we could make in a future 2 kind of winners
one with judges and one public!
Like Chaemirix said, reddit is nice because they are direct on the point. if they dont like they say =]
sometimes the ammount of work is not the most important aspect, we are doing that for the dota community, the ammount of work is probably not the most important thing. in that place some judges from polycount would help it =]
BEST SET
Vitamin C Deficiency by Zenchuck
BEST ITEM
Bludgeon of the Aquatic Steed by Airborn Studios
the pool
congrats guys!