Thanks for the feedback! Though I planned the masks being transformative for the wearer (a la Majora's Mask), the way I modeled the bottom parts of the masks, they would be hanging a slight distance away from the cheeks, rather than flush with the face (because of the discomfort it could cause). You were spot on about them…
Seriously, find good authentic references. By using these tacky, fake Halloween knock-off style things, your work will turn out just that... tacky and fake looking. Also, do material breakdowns before texturing so you know what you're trying to recreate. Right now I can't tell what anything is really made of, it just looks…