WOW disney is getting desparate

arshlevon · Oct 2005

.. this is so funny.. disney is basically funding a complete rip off of madagascar.. only difference is that it looks horrible, i mean really bad... like student film bad.. what are they thinking?? its like disney is that washed up star.. burtout, and addicted to coke, turning tricks for extra cash..
http://www.jimhillmedia.com/article.php?id=1697

MoP · Oct 2005

Holy crap... what a rip.

Also, Warner Brothers might have something to say about Disney's upcoming "Chicken Little" movie...

Joshua Stubbles · Oct 2005

I wouldn't say the Disney one looks like crap. It's a more realistic look, that's all. But it's a HUGE rip, and undeserving of attention

oXYnary · Oct 2005

I dont know.. Dont forget "Antz" was a response to "A Bugs Life" (even though it was released earlier-Antz). Seems they both do it.

gauss · Oct 2005

man if you're going to rip something... why Madagascar?

arshlevon · Oct 2005

i dont think it looks very realistic at all.. i think it looks more like some forth graders got a hold of a fur plugin..

the similarities between antz and bugslife were that they both had ants in it.. now if antz took place on a farm and not NewYork and starred a ant that invented stuff and went off and found a bunch of other bugs to stop the grasshoppers,and the bugs he broght back just so happend to be a beetle, a spider, a stickbug, a praying mantis,a caterpiller and a ladybug then it would be more like what disney is doing here..

MoP · Oct 2005

arsh, if you read the full article, those screengrabs were taken from incomplete, non-final shots of the movie... so it's essentially WIP... i wouldn't take any of those screens as finals ... still, it's pretty dumb to rip Madagascar!

oXYnary: At least Antz and A Bug's Life had fairly different characterisation! This one looks identical to Madagascar, they just changed the visual style... dumb!

Wells · Oct 2005

what really clinched it was the comical group of penguins. good god.

jzero · Oct 2005

Antz == Bug's Life
Shark Tale == Finding Nemo
Chicken Run == Valiant
Ice Age == Brother Bear (pushing it a little)

Do I hear an echo from my Cronenberg thread posts?

/jzero

Ninjas · Oct 2005

Okay, from what I heard this movie got the green light first, and from other screens I've seen it looks god awful. Why would you release barely lit, shadowless images with billboard trees in the background unless you were retarded.

..and yes, they accidentily get shipped to Africa.

ElysiumGX · Oct 2005

if chicken little sucks...Pixar will have the advantage over Disney. Disney can have its own 3d studio, but not likely it'll ever have a unique idea to compete.

Major Clod · Oct 2005

Surely this had to have been in production first. Why would you rip Madagascar, it was horrible.

Mark Dygert · Oct 2005

I don't think the general public will care which project was green lighted first. It comes down to who made it into the theaters first. Please Disney don't mess this one up and then sign a deal with pixar and ride them into pixel paste.

thnom · Oct 2005

I loved madagascar. This may have gotten the green light first but you at least change the fucking placement of it. I mean NY Central Park.. they could have at least changed that, minimum.

Daz · Oct 2005

It looks like utter turd. I can't believe they're released shots, but then I did some digging around.
A character TD friend at work interviewed for this gig ages ago and turned them down based on the amateurness of it all. This is being made by Core in Toronto, directed by Steve 'Spaz' Williams, who has on his resume 'visual effects supervisor for Spawn' Lol, go figure

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0405469/

aesir · Oct 2005

idiots...

MoP · Oct 2005

Daz: Haha, his nickname is giving the game away!

Steve Schulze · Oct 2005

Has Valiant come out in the US yet? It looked pretty decent from the preview and its usually pretty easy to tell if something if one of these animated films is going to be crap at that point, but the website seems to be suggesting its complete rubbish. Anyone seen it?

MoP · Oct 2005

Jackablade: It was fairly heavily advertised over here in the UK this summer, but if it ever appeared in the cinema (and there's no evidence that it did), it sank without trace pretty rapidly.

The DVD looks like it'll be out in December.

thomasp · Oct 2005

so i guess spawn was pretty bad cg-wise? anyway the trackrecord of that guy is impressive: abyss, red october, terminator 2, jurassic park, the mask ...!

i wouldn't mind having these on my resume

and yes, that movie looks like crap. madagascar trailers screamed crap aswell, so it might just be a very good copy

Justin Meisse · Oct 2005

I remember seeing a few commercials for Valiant , I think it bombed, it's rated fairly rotten at rottentomatoes.

Steve Schulze · Oct 2005

Thats a pity. I was looking forward to that one. Still might be worth a look on DVD I guess.

man_o_mule · Oct 2005

Why are you guys ripping on Madagascar so much? that movie was great. Especially the Planet of the Apes reference......Pure genius (although i like the Planet of the Apes reference in Jay and Silent Bob allot more)

Scott Ruggels · Oct 2005

Valiant came out in the U.S. My Mother's Family Sued them to get a character name changed, and many of my friends who formerly worked in Television and feature animation, before moving into games, and real estate and stuff, saw it, and said it was pure crap, and made them all want to see Wallace & Grommit all the more.

Scott

pogonip · Oct 2005

Blaizer · Oct 2005

for real? This is a rip!!!
Really incredible.

WOW disney is getting desparate

Replies