Good read about the war

mr.toast · Apr 2005

wow, first medal of honor given out since vietnam, he surely deserved it for what he did

http://www.buffalonews.com/editorial/20050405/1071884.asp

AstroZombie · Apr 2005

What, exactly, makes this a "good read?"

mr.toast · Apr 2005

thought it was kool because he was their last line of defence and he single handedly took down about 50 enemy iraqi troops while defending his men, the guy sacrificed his life which saved a lot of soldiers in his unit

Daz · Apr 2005

Um yeah 'kool'. He got a medal. I bet his wife and kids are stoked.

JKim3 · Apr 2005

Well, to someone it is cool. He's a 'hero' in this day and age, when heroes don't get much news coverage. It's just not kool.

oXYnary · Apr 2005

To be deemed a Hero, one needs to be seemingly dead in this day and age.

KeyserSoze · Apr 2005

[ QUOTE ]
To be deemed a Hero, one needs to be seemingly dead in this day and age.

[/ QUOTE ]

It's a form of consolation. Giving him a medal or having a parade won't make much of a difference now that he's dead, but hey, at least it'll make us feel better.

Prs-Phil · Apr 2005

respect to him furfilling his duty and "saving" his soldiers. But the war did go on, the chance that people from that unit are/where/going to be killed in action is present and he is still dead, just like the 50 guys he killed. well, probably they where single

jzero · Apr 2005

Living heroes, especially military ones, are few and far between, and they probably suffer from PTSD. Not to diminish Sgt. Smith's sacrifice, but it's easier for people to remember you as a hero when you're dead. By that logic, the 50 guys he killed are all heroes, too. Not medal-worthy, perhaps, but heroes in someone's eyes.

Mr. Toast, read the bottom of that article and you'll see it's not the first CMH since Vietnam, it's the third. Two were given for guys who gave theirs in Mogadishu.

/jzero

Malekyth · Apr 2005

If a civilian killed 50 people, even in defense of his own family, wouldn't we consider him a psychopath? Can you imagine having a conversation with a man capable of killing 50 people single-handedly, under any circumstance? That'd be an intense, harrowing fucking experience, I think. Good thing he became a soldier and not a cop, or teacher, or my neighbor.

killingpeople · Apr 2005

[ QUOTE ]
Um yeah 'kool'. He got a medal. I bet his wife and kids are stoked.

[/ QUOTE ]
HAHAHAHAHAAAAaaaaaa! awesome.

Good read about the war

Replies