Home 3D Art Showcase & Critiques

The Bi-Monthly Environment Art Challenge | March - April (83)

sublime tool
Offline / Send Message
Pinkfox sublime tool

Hello everyone! Welcome to the 83rd edition of the Bi-Monthly Environment Art Challenge for the months of March and April!

This challenge is a way for real-time 3D artists to test their skills and create a piece of work based on concepts provided. It's open to those of all skill levels and we do our best to provide meaningful feedback along the way so everyone can come away from the challenge with actionable points on which they can improve their craft!

Anyone is welcome in this challenge no matter your skill level! It's a test of your own ability not a competition between members. We're all here to improve as artists and learn from each other.

- ENVIRONMENTS -

HARD SURFACE ENVIRONMENT:

Half Timbered House by James Arkwright

https://www.artgram.co/a/half-timbered-house-gIvkmC


STYLIZED ENVIRONMENT:

Wóska - Concept Arts by Inès "Ourka" Rotzinger

https://www.artgram.co/a/bird-village-environment-concept-arts

If you're looking for even more of a challenge with this one, check out the artist's link to find a view of the interior space as well!


- PROPS -

HARD SURFACE PROP:

PREY - Props by Dmitry Sorokin

https://www.artstation.com/artwork/62OD5


STYLIZED PROP:

Concept Artist RPG 5 by Ekaterina Bek-Nazarova

https://www.behance.net/gallery/74230707/Concept-Artist-RPG-5


- RULES -

Please read all the rules before starting:

  • Try to post at least one critique for every post that you make. This will make for a better learning environment and help us all grow as artists.
  • Try your best to finish as much as you can in the time frame provided, but remember even if you don't finish by the end of the challenge we encourage you to keep pushing and finish your piece!
  • Post what you are working on in this thread so that way it's a more centralized place for advice and critique. Please avoid creating a new thread as we don't want to spam out the forums.
  • It is recommended to use a game engine to present your work. Unreal Engine, Unity, and CryEngine are very common engines that can be used but feel free to use any alternatives that you want. (Marmoset Toolbag for example.)
  • Feel free to change up your chosen concept a bit if you want! Interpret these concepts to your liking, especially if your aim is to add storytelling elements.
  • If you finish your project and decide to post it to Artstation, make sure you give credit to the concept artist in the form of a link to their profile. Additionally, it is recommended to ask a concept artist for their permission to post a 3D piece based on their work before doing so.

- RECOMMENDATIONS -

  • When you are just starting out making a scene, it can seem complicated or imposing. Take your time planning and blocking out, it will set you up for success later on.
  • Think about how you can re-use assets, re-use textures, break it down as simple as possible and plan it out. A lot of people will break it down in their own way when they start out their challenge. Gather some reference images as well for different parts of the scene, don't be afraid to make it your own.
  • We strongly encourage you to go and look at other games and see how they make their assets as well as get concept art to give it your own feel.

The goal is to learn and grow both artistically and in your ability to both give and receive critique, but don't stress about it and remember to have fun!

Good luck everyone!

Replies

  • AD_3D
    Offline / Send Message
    AD_3D polycounter lvl 4

    Really cool concepts here. That hard surface environment looks like it'll be a good challenge for modularity.

  • Fabi_G
    Offline / Send Message
    Fabi_G insane polycounter

    Hi! Decided to start with the Half Timbered House by James Arkwright. I don't know yet how much time I will have for this. But at the very least, I want to make a couple of nice texture sets.

    Rough notes about textures and structures:

    Current state of blockout:

    I find it particular challenging to imagine the obscured part of the structure. I decided to make the top floor for storage, so there should be some platforms and fixtures to lift things up. The vertical support currently in place might be a bit overkill.

    Looking forward to see more WIPs 🤓

  • elfennani

    So far I'm done with the model, I still need to study topology a lot, it's currently a mess

  • mxrxq
    Offline / Send Message
    mxrxq polycounter lvl 2

    @Fabi_G I love your idea for the back!

    I've also decided to go with the hard surface environment. My blockout isn't finished yet, but I've sculpted some rocks I'm really happy with. I'm not sure whether I will bake them into lowpoly models (I'm going with more of a next gen approach) or just into a material, but here they are :D


  • Fabi_G
    Offline / Send Message
    Fabi_G insane polycounter

    @elfennani nice, certainly resembles the concept 👍️ Some still renders would have been nice, to get a better look of the model. What's your plan for texturing? Will you bake details down or keep it as geometry?

    @mxrxq Thanks! I'm curious to see someone else's interpretation 🤓 Stones look like a solid start, nice! Could do both, a tiling material and a couple of single stones. Keep it up!

  • Jaesoul

    Hello!! Just found this forum love the challenges! Is there a discord? or just post here?

  • lucardo
    Offline / Send Message
    lucardo polycounter lvl 3

    Even the blockout looks so nice allready! How did you do the roof texture/material? Substance designer or, something more manual?

    The plaster texture, so far is looking a bit wierd. To me it feels like it is going in diagonal lines:

    Maybe if you try a plaster material that is more soft, it would ressemble the reference a bit more:


  • Fabi_G
    Offline / Send Message
    Fabi_G insane polycounter

    @lucardo Thanks for the feedback, absolutely agree. It should improve over time.

    My overall aproach is to bake down geometry to use as a base in Painter. In the case of the Roof, it's some low poly slabs arranged in a tiling manner. Going forward want to give them a sculpting pass for more detail.

  • mxrxq
    Offline / Send Message
    mxrxq polycounter lvl 2

    I kinda finished the first module (although it's still missing the stone wall, and there is a lot to be improved in materials). I really like how the roof turned out, and it has way lower polycount than I thought it would have (3k tris). In the future, I will definitely make a new slate material, sculpt the plaster a bit and add dirt masks to the plaster material, but for now, I'm happy with the progress :D

  • SimãoSilva
    Offline / Send Message
    SimãoSilva polycounter lvl 7

    Never had participated in one of those and they seem fun!

    I'm making the projector first, wanted to try out this method of making the high poly/ detail model in fusion 360 then used max to make a low poly version and bake and make the textures all up.

    here is the fusion 360 model done!

    tried to keep all of the shapes and silhouetes as close as possible while also maintaining the rule that the lense must be in the centes of the projector.

  • Gannon
    Offline / Send Message
    Gannon interpolator

    Taking a stab at this. Any notes on proportion would be appreciated.


    @SimãoSilva - Nice! I think there's some minor differences in proportions/placement of the projector arm and lamp on the back, otherwise super nice!

    @Fabi_G Nice write up breaking down the shapes and such. This is gonna be helpful for others taking on this concept.

  • Benny_Jam
    Offline / Send Message
    Benny_Jam triangle

    First post on the site ! Doing the projector for some hard surface practice. Here's my low poly , some of the cuts I'm gonna bake in. Any feedback welcome 👍️

    @Gannon - looks good from this angle 👌

    @SimãoSilva - Good job mate, nailed it ! Nice to see someone doing the same ref. Only critique I got is the lamp at the top, seems a bit to squished compared to the ref .

  • Al_crafts

    Hey all

    After a long time I've returned and looking forward to tackling this challenge.

    I have decided to go for the Wóska village by Ourka, it looks lots of fun.

    Not sure how much I’ll be able to do but I will aim on finishing it!

    This is what I have so fare

  • mxrxq
    Offline / Send Message
    mxrxq polycounter lvl 2

    Modeling is almost done, which means I have plenty of time for everything else :D I went with fully modeled stones. I tested a few different approaches and this looks the best in my opinion. It allowed me to only use a single material for all of the stone walls and the chimney while keeping the stones' placement aligned with wooden beams. This is desirable, since with nanite, polycount isn't really a concern anymore, but textures amount still is. Personally, I don't believe nanite is a good excuse not to optimize assets at all because bigger polycounts still take up memory, therefore the stones are baked into low poly meshes. The whole scene is now about 60k triangles, which I think is perfectly fine since there are buildings in God of War: Ragnarok with over 200k triangles, and this game doesn't use nanite :) With sculpted plaster this will definitely go up, but I think I will be able to keep triangles under 100k.

    Left to do: Sculpt pass on plaster, dirt mask, tweaking materials, vegetation, and obviously lighting and background.

  • Gannon
    Offline / Send Message
    Gannon interpolator

    Been working on some modular trims that i could duplicate around. Just started placing them, here's just some texture flats. Pink assets will be unique unwraps, blue/teal will be tiling.

  • Kraegin
    Offline / Send Message
    Kraegin polycounter lvl 10

    Block out finished! Now onto details :)

  • ItsReasonArt

    Hi, giving the Prey prop a go as its one of my favourite games!

    Just the blockout so far. I'm attempting to use the scale shown on the concept art sheet, with the Unreal Mannequin as reference (Looking at it now I might need to scale it down a bit). Screenshot taken in Unreal, Modelled in Maya. Any feedback is welcomed :)


    @Benny_Jam Looks amazing! I don't know if its the angle, but it looks like your missing the back wheels.

  • Benny_Jam
    Offline / Send Message
    Benny_Jam triangle


    Ok was able to finish off the model . Was a fun little exercise! Blender, Substance and Marmoset were the software used for the piece.


    @ItsReasonArt Thanks man . Yeah the wheels are there . Just hard to see in most angles

  • mxrxq
    Offline / Send Message
    mxrxq polycounter lvl 2

    @Benny_Jam Looks great! My only critique is that I would add a little bit more variation in the roughness, but it's definitely a preference.

    I think I'm done with that project :D


    I decided to take a more next-gen approach with this building. It has 93,000 triangles (not including vegetation and props). I knew I was going to use Nanite, so triangle count was never an issue, however, I still decided to bake sculpted slate and rock to low poly models for the sake of memory optimization and to make working with those models more manageable. there is definitely one big thing I learned the hard way - Nanite actually does support vertex color. You cant paint it per instance in engine, but you can still import it. At first, I thought I will use texture masks for detailing the plaster, so I heavily decimated the meshes after sculpting and that kind of topology is really inconvenient for vertex painting.

    I have only used a few materials for this building: wood trimsheet, rope and steel trimsheet, stones that are baked and uniquely painted and then assembled into walls and chimney, slate which was made the same way, and plaster, which is a tiled material with 3 grunges that are mixed in using vertex color masks.

    Huge shoutout to James Arkwright, who created the original concept art, and my amazing colleagues at Paradark Studio who provided me with feedback through this project

  • Gannon
    Offline / Send Message
    Gannon interpolator

    current state of things as I chip away at this.

    @Benny_Jam Really nice job!

  • PeculiarSana
    Offline / Send Message
    PeculiarSana polygon

    Hey all! This is my second time joining this challenge, and although I didn't finish the project last time I did, I'll hopefully manage it this time!

    I decided to go for the stylized prop this time around, as I really want to work on my prop art and I figure I could also have fun animating this little guy, too! Gonna try to make it game-ready so I'm forcing myself to not go too crazy with the poly count (heh!).

    Here's where I'm at after about 2 hours:

    @Gannon Really liking that wood material! Are you making them all yourself?

    Edit:

    After a handful more hours, I've finished most of the modelling - still need to work on the actual 'map' which is relatively terrifying to say the least, as I'm likely going to have to rig it.

  • Fabi_G
    Offline / Send Message
    Fabi_G insane polycounter

    @mxrxq Congrats, turned out nicely! Like the solution you found for the back side.

    @Gannon Wood texture looks great! Keep it up!

    @PeculiarSana Nice! Already has some character. Do you use any baking or paint the texures directly? If I had to make a rigged prop, I would probably make a mockup first, to identify potential problems.

    Found some time to continue working on the house. Added some Megascans foliage.

    Currently simple materials use a vertex painted mask to add some variation.

  • PeculiarSana
    Offline / Send Message
    PeculiarSana polygon

    @Fabi_G Looking great! Two suggestions I'd maybe have is to extrude the roof a bit, maybe? Having the main tile surface as just a plane does stand out on the edges a fair bit. Even though the reference is fairly flat too, adding just a bit of depth would help, I think! Wouldn't add too many extra polys either, I imagine. Also, you could perhaps have the moss on the roof more confined to crevices or anywhere it'd be more protected from the sun (unless you're trying to go for a more abandonned look!).

    Also, what do you mean by a mockup? For the animation? I have a solid idea of how I want the whole thing to move, and only the map section would get weight painted. I intend to scale down the bones that are inside the body so that I can move the whole assembly in cleanly.

    As for my progress for the day, I finished all of the modelling phase (outside of the rope for the pen, but it's sitting at a cozy 6,400 polys), and fully UV unwrapped it. Easily my most complex UV map and I'm honestly pretty proud of it! 😅 I could probably optimise the space I use further, but I was kind of impatient to jump into Substance instead… The textures are very basic still, mostly just slapped some quick layers on in Substance with my mouse since I don't currently have my pen display, but I'm really happy with how this is turning out!

    I was sort of hoping I could also work on the Stylized Environment concept, too, but this is taking me a lot longer than I expected. Maybe I'll do it in my own time after this challenge is done! Looking forward to seeing everyone elses' progress, too!

  • Gannon
    Offline / Send Message
    Gannon interpolator

    @PeculiarSana thank you, and yep. sculpting all the wood things is cathartic. The hard part is figuring out the size of the bevels out of context. Your prop is turning out stellar. I'm so excited to see the material phase and the animation phase of it.
    @Fabi_G Thank you, I feel like i'm hitting my stride finally. What are your thoughts on putting a couple of deformers on your building to help taper it as it goes higher?

  • Fabi_G
    Offline / Send Message
    Fabi_G insane polycounter

    @PeculiarSana By mockout I meant, doing rigging early with placeholder/blockout mesh and texture to see how it deforms, but it seems you already have a clear idea how to want to do it. Textures coming along nicely! How will you make the eyes change state?

    Thanks for the feedback peculiar and gannon! Added roof thickness and made adjustments to geometry so it's less simple/uniform/straight. Also worked over vertex colour masks and added height lerp into the blend. Altough there is more to improve (roof could be better, both, surface and geometry, surfaces/materials overall, …), I have to move on to other things.

  • Gannon
    Offline / Send Message
    Gannon interpolator

    Weekend progress on the roof
  • exitshadow
    @SimãoSilva it looks really great! I wondered how it did go to port it from Fusion to a poly-based modelling tool? I love Fusion360 but exports have been so headachy for me especially when it comes to optimization.

    I finished the main shape. My intention now is to duplicate the model to add bevels, then optimize the simpler model and bake the normals from the beveled mesh to the optimized one before texturing.


  • Fabi_G
    Offline / Send Message
    Fabi_G insane polycounter
    @Gannon textures look very nice! Is the roof a unique mesh?
    @exitshadow Wireframe looks cool! Will you keep all the gratings for the lowpoly? I imagine all those faces would amount to some noticeable texture space.

    Looking forward to your updates!

    Gave the projector a shot with the goal to experiment a bit with mid-poly and floaters. Baked the shading down to a low-poly which used a bevel modifier with two segments and a profile of one to add support loops to the edges and an edge split modifier to preserve the hard edges - this helped to reduce the skewing when baking with averaged normals. The final geometry consists of the same meshes, just without the bevel and edge split modifiers. To maximize UV space all parts are mirrored, except the body in the middle with the veneer. The model is using a 2k texture set.

    Sketchfab screenshots:

    midpoly + floaters:

    lowpoly:

    model

  • Gannon
    Offline / Send Message
    Gannon interpolator
    @Fabi_G Turned out really nice. Do you think you could take it to the next level by giving it some emissive and projection lighting FX similar to the concept? Imagine how sick that would look.

    Yes, the roof is a unique mesh that mixes tiling materials to maintain a nice texture resolution. I'm using a lot of different techniques just to refresh myself and learn some of the new quirks that are associated with Unreal 5 and Nanite, such as no displacement vertex blending. I'll have to learn RVT to create some transitions between the stone pavers and the building itself.

    Little more progress. 


    Next steps, I'll create some transition models, redo the base of the chimney, some foliage and additional supporting props such as curtains for the roof window, a doormat, and maybe even some of those birbs.
  • exitshadow
    @Fabi_G Your low poly came out just pristine!

    For the texture spaces of the gratings, that’s a very good question! To be honest I’m hesitant to remove them since gratings tend to look really messy and weird when projected with an alpha on objects starting from a few meters close. I guess that can work for something that is on the background or just beyond mid-distance, so I think it’s more of a LOD2 candidate. My LOD0 is currently 9.6k triangles and I was really surprised it wasn’t that bad. It’s mostly taken by the wheels and the lenses. (I’d say 4k for wheels and lenses, 2k for the gratings). But you are right, they do take a lot of texture space and that is really annoying.

    So I think the way I’ll go about it is to set all the grating UV islands on the same spots and also mirror part of the UVs, like a sort of texture sheet mixed with proper texturing. Then for the LOD1 basically doing exactly the same but without the bevels and the non-geo gratings as well as a lower resolution for the curved shapes, then the LOD2 having alpha textures instead of the gratings and very low cylinder resolution, just enough to hold the silhouette from afar.

    And after that, an emissive map and some cone lights to make it look exactly like the ref. My face is melting a bit. But hopefully this will all be done this week!
  • Pinkfox
    Offline / Send Message
    Pinkfox sublime tool
    Hey everyone!

    Wanted to say how awesomely you've all been killing it with this challenge! It was great to see all the information sharing and the ways everyone could improve throughout the process. Really happy to see that throughout.

    As May is upon us a new challenge is here! Would love to see everyone pop in to participate or even just provide feedback to those who are!
    https://polycount.com/discussion/233029/the-bi-monthly-environment-art-challenge-may-june-84/

    For anyone still working on their piece, please keep going and keep us up-to-date in this thread! It's always excellent to see people reach the end and that's a goal you should always strive for.
Sign In or Register to comment.