Home General Discussion

Able to draw, born talent or hard work

1
Hey guys, at age 23 i found all of this CG thing. Been lurking, searching reading stuff about all of stuff. I was interest in everything.
especially in FX, sculpting stuff.

Was okey, until, i read for better character artist need to know drawing. Damn it. to be honest i never draw in my life, all of my drawing made my mother lol, when i was in elementary and high school.

But now, it's come to me that, i need to learn to draw. And i have no idea where to start. Got books, but, i am just reading them, and no idea how to start, there is no explanation how to start etc.

Even i will go for online course for drawing, but there anything like that. There is for 3D, FX, Zbrush, but not drawing.

Is drawing is a born talent? Or it's from hard working? I know kids you are not even 15, know to draw, everything, 2 of them are my cousins both 13, and can draw, fucking good. Whatever they are interest.
I feel like dump, useless compared to them.
Ye maybe. when they grow up, might work in Blizzard for example.

Replies

  • passerby
    Offline / Send Message
    passerby polycounter lvl 12
    both, some people are just good at it, some people worked hard to get good at it, than there is hte people who have done both and are fucking amazing.
  • skylebones
    Offline / Send Message
    skylebones polycounter lvl 10
    Some people have the ability to learn things faster than others. But I don't believe in born talent. All the greats I know are great because they have a large volume of work. They just carefully choose what they show.
  • Justin Meisse
    Offline / Send Message
    Justin Meisse polycounter lvl 19
    thread number 20 about drawing.

    It's not a born talent - I don't know if you're joking or not but if your mom laughed at your drawings as a kid and that discouraged you from continuing, that's a really sad story :(

    I'd consider myself OK at drawing, if I posted some of the stuff I drew when I was six it would probably look no different than your drawings at six - the only major difference is I never stopped drawing.

    Drawing is not required but it is a great foundation skill that you can practice anywhere at a moments notice.
  • kraylex
    It's not "born talent", but some folks "get it" easier than others simply based upon the way they process information, the same way some people "get" math faster than others.

    Like anything else, drawing well can be learned through practice and hard work, as well as paying attention to principles and rules of design.
  • seforin
    Offline / Send Message
    seforin polycounter lvl 17
    Short answer.

    some people can do things easier then others...like some people are natually muscular while others are not. To say its impossible to get like that for the most part isnt something that isnt feasible, it will just require alot more hardwork then someone who natually has that.


    Drawing, math/programming, writing etc..All are things that can be learned by doing constantly. Sure there some people better at drawing or math etc, but unless you have some REAL disability there is no reason why you cant do it...just time to practice is all.

    for every 1 good drawing you will make you will probably have 100-1000 mediocre drawings to get there. Its not bad, its just practice.


    Btw , I have the SHORTEST amount of patience possible and im telling you that! ;)
  • bounchfx
    You can learn to draw, anyone can. Put lots of time and effort into it and you will reap the benefits.
  • Pinuja
    I believe that it is all about interest and practice. If you have interest when you are a child, you will practice and will be good at it, at least better than your friends =)
  • Stromberg90
    Offline / Send Message
    Stromberg90 polycounter lvl 11
    The ones that always seemed to be able to draw might say they have talent for it, the ones that learned how to draw says it's hard work.

    I have heard people say they where kinda born good drawers, which I look as a bit of bullshit I think they case is rather they did draw at home, draw at school and was slightly better than the rest and got encouraged to do it, when I was young all teachers and the rest of my classmates(me as well) would always admire the ones that drawed a bit better than the others and they got better at it and found it fun, the rest of us did not want to compete(very young here).

    But for those who learned at a older age, or has a bit of insight in how things work, know it's all hard work in the end, if you want to be a good drawer, draw if not then don't easy as that.

    I for one has not spent enough time drawing to be able to make anything that is identifiable, so if or when I want to do something about that it's all up to me.
  • MagicSugar
    Offline / Send Message
    MagicSugar polycounter lvl 10
    Drawing is definitely learnable. You don't even have to learn it by being hard on yourself or memorizing anatomy by rote or learning all aspects known about perspective theory. Just regular practice if you want to make it into a marketable skill someday.

    A lot of concept art "rockstars" like Jason Chan or Craig Mullins, when you look at their very early works...a lot of their pieces don't hold up by today's pro standards (some concept art for the game Marathon Man, for example that Craig did ages ago). But these guys obviously became better by just constantly working on their skills and/or getting training. Jason went to Art Academy (university now I heard) of San Francisco.

    You can't rush being competent with it but if you persist eventually level-ups will happen as well as affirmations that you have what it takes via landing paid art gigs.
  • squareko
    Offline / Send Message
    squareko polycounter lvl 4
    Work work work!
  • 3DKnight
    Offline / Send Message
    3DKnight polycounter lvl 17
    "Obstacles cannot crush me. Every obstacle yields to stern resolve. He who is fixed to a star does not change his mind."

    Leonardo Da Vinci
  • Snader
    Offline / Send Message
    Snader polycounter lvl 15
    Talent is born. Skill is learned. Talent makes it easier to learn skill.
  • dii
    When Craig Mullins started at school he had 3 instructors tell him to go do something else with his life because he clearly had no talent for it.

    Everybody starts terrible.
  • Krio
    So, me without, talent have no change to learn drawing?

    But, i am not really interest in drawing at all. My goal is doing 3D, like creating characters/creature sin Zbrush.
  • Brandon.LaFrance
    Online / Send Message
    Brandon.LaFrance polycount sponsor
    "If people knew how hard I had to work to gain my mastery, it wouldn't seem wonderful at all."

    -Michelangelo
  • dii
    If you don't want to do it then don't do it...
  • Calabi
    Offline / Send Message
    Calabi polycounter lvl 12
    Of course lots of babies draw in the womb.
  • MagicSugar
    Offline / Send Message
    MagicSugar polycounter lvl 10
    Krio wrote: »
    But, i am not really interest in drawing at all.

    LOL

    Then why waste your time? Drawing skills...it's not just some item you can just buy or swallow like a pill and expect to upgrade as an artist all of a sudden.

    Nothing wrong pursuing what you're naturally intested in. A lot of famous Pixar animators aren't into drawing. Same with many game artists. It's good to have in your portfolio if you're really good and can do good show-of pieces. If not...and you're just pretending (or worse, stealing somebody's art)...you'll be exposed eventually.

    I heard this one podcast episode by "guyswithpencils". The hosts both went to the elite animation school Sheridan. They had a classmate in their first & second years who was a "natural" drawing talent. Better than them when they were newbs. He was good but found his heart wasn't into drawing for a living so he switched to cooking school instead. And he was happier and content to go that career route.
  • Mark Dygert
    It's totally a gift that you where not given, any amount of work you put in will only prove fruitless. Don't listen to these jokers when they tell you that you can achieve anything with practice, you where born with sucky art talent and you will die that way. Now go be an accountant and stop trying to make art.

    There are the people that give up after reading that, and then there are people who tell me I'm an asshole and prove me wrong and it is entirely possible to prove me wrong but it takes a lot of work and honestly I don't think you have what it takes. You are already years behind anyone else that has been practicing all along. You gave up the second someone criticized your work and it seems like you need a constant cheerleader squad following you around to even you to brush your teeth, so save yourself the heartache and give up, go do something else.

    If you still feel like giving it a try then you don't need anyone here telling you that you can do it.
  • Krio
    I just, listen other people advice. Some told me to draw, some do not.
    SO how to learn then, human anatomy, proportion, etc tec? With Zbrush, max, maya?
  • D4V1DC
    Offline / Send Message
    D4V1DC polycounter lvl 18
    Krio wrote: »
    i am not really interest in drawing at all. My goal is doing 3D, like creating characters/creature sin Zbrush.

    You could get away with that a bit but you'll have to follow the rules as someone said in an earlier post in this thread. You can draw and not post any progress and learn all on your own in secret so no one can say your not good but doing little things here and their will help you.

    Also how are you going to make characters/creatures with no idea or concept art?
    Krio wrote: »
    SO how to learn then, human anatomy, proportion, etc tec? With Zbrush, max, maya?


    Human and Animal Anatomy yes, proportions yes.

    All things in moderation and it will take time, you'll be better each day!
  • dii
    Yeah you can use ZBrush.

    But the fastest way to learn is probably to draw it.
  • MM
    Offline / Send Message
    MM polycounter lvl 18
    Snader wrote: »
    Talent is born. Skill is learned. Talent makes it easier to learn skill.

    this.

    drawing is a skill that is learned, not something people are born with.

    but different people are born with different level of intelligence. it is just genetics and matter of how well your brain can calculate. rest is nurture.

    either way, you dont really need to draw to learn anatomy.

    i see this being said a lot in polycount. people keep suggesting to draw to learn anatomy.

    while drawing is a good approach, it is a slow approach.

    start modeling and sculpting.

    while drawing you actually have to think in three dimensions/perspective and put all that down in paper by hand.

    while working in 3d modeling/sculpting you are actually thinking in two dimensions since the third dimension is taken care of by the software.

    so technically your brain does less calculation while modeling/sculpting.

    so to get better at anatomy faster, start modeling or sculpting and use lot of anatomy reference of real people while practicing.
  • Ruz
    Offline / Send Message
    Ruz polycount lvl 666
    I believe in born talent, but you still have to work hard on top of that 'BUT'
    no amount of practice can make a dullard good at art:) which is how it should be.
  • Justin Meisse
    Offline / Send Message
    Justin Meisse polycounter lvl 19
    I don't believe in talent, everyone can be an artist but you have to enjoy doing it enough to get past the early stages were you suck.
  • Ruz
    Offline / Send Message
    Ruz polycount lvl 666
    but justin if I practiced for a thousand years I wouldn't have the concept skills of bobo or nick carver so why pretend otherwise.
    I hate giving people false hope saying yeah you can practise and you will be a top notch artist. you do need a certain amount of natural aptitiude to get somewhere in art.
    it's like some folks are good at maths or physics so why should art be any different.

    my missus has an amazing natural aptitiude for art, its nowt to do with practise she can just do it.

    i used to play snooker/pool to a fairly high standard and got pretty good, but I had to practice like mad to get to that standard on top of a 'reasonable' amount of talent. I had a friend who i practiced with but he was in a different league, he was just damn good. He hadn't played in 6 months but still got a 68 break and beat me easy.

    I one made a '1200' break at bar billiards though and that was because I was very drunk:/
  • MM
    Offline / Send Message
    MM polycounter lvl 18
    I don't believe in talent, everyone can be an artist but you have to enjoy doing it enough to get past the early stages were you suck.

    do you believe in heritability of certain traits?
    or more specifically that IQ is a genetic trait in most cases ?

    anyways, i do agree that it depends how one uses their born talent or pushes its limits with lot of hard work.
  • dii
    but justin if I practiced for a thousand years I wouldn't have the concept skills of bobo or nick carver so why pretend otherwise.
    I wonder if they would agree.

    If you asked me 3 years ago if I'd ever be good at painting I'd have said fuck no. Now I think it's actually possible.

    Making arbitrary decisions about your future/potential has a lot less to do with reality and more to do with your confidence level.
  • MagicSugar
    Offline / Send Message
    MagicSugar polycounter lvl 10
    [fuck cut n paste EDIT]
  • Ruz
    Offline / Send Message
    Ruz polycount lvl 666
    dll thats just not true mate. I know what i am good at and having worked in art for the past 20 years I know what I am good at and what my limitations are. you can't force yourself to be good at everything, I am quite happy being good at modelling texturing
    it not jut a question of technique, it's about how your mind works/visual memory.
    I have a lousy visual memory but am good at observationl drawing, therefore I find myself not very good at concepting, but ok at the other.

    i think people who are good at somehting gravitate towards that kind of work. why try and force yoursefl if you are not suited for it. I used to work in accountancy and can quite honestly say i was rubbish at it, because my brain doesn't work in a methodical way. I would not try and push myself to work in accountancy with no aptitude for it?

    MagicSugar - yeah I always thought the same way ie there are top notch guys who i will never match but I can still find a niche, but that wasn't really the argument.
    it's like saying someone who is crap at art can somehow magically achieve the status of a great asrtist just by practising hard. it could be true in some cases, but on the whole it's the folks with talent who do well.
  • Justin Meisse
    Offline / Send Message
    Justin Meisse polycounter lvl 19
    MM wrote: »
    do you believe in heritability of certain traits?
    or more specifically that IQ is a genetic trait in most cases ?

    anyways, i do agree that it depends how one uses their born talent or pushes its limits with lot of hard work.

    luckily intelligence has nothing to do with art ;)

    It all boils down to how much you doubt yourself.
  • MagicSugar
    Offline / Send Message
    MagicSugar polycounter lvl 10
    Ruz wrote: »
    MagicSugar - yeah I always thought ...

    Ah...good to see you've read that post. :thumbup:

    I pooched it fixing your re-quote.
  • MM
    Offline / Send Message
    MM polycounter lvl 18
    luckily intelligence has nothing to do with art ;)

    It all boils down to how much you doubt yourself.

    hehe self confidence can get you far, but talent will help you get there faster.
  • Justin Meisse
  • Ruz
    Offline / Send Message
    Ruz polycount lvl 666
    MagicSugar - yeah I kind of read your post as I was typing my answer:)
  • MM
    Offline / Send Message
    MM polycounter lvl 18

    you must be a genius(talent) dis-liker :D

    funny stuff, but not really based on science of genetics or any science for that matter.

    http://lmgtfy.com/?q=heritability+of+IQ

    and dont say IQ has nothing to do with art.

    also, just for fun:

    http://lmgtfy.com/?q=malcolm+gladwell+is+an+idiot
  • Justin Meisse
    Offline / Send Message
    Justin Meisse polycounter lvl 19
    MM wrote: »
    you must be a genius(talent) dis-liker :D

    I'm a person who's been accused of being talented and/or a genius my whole life. I feel everyone that is desperately clinging to the idea of talent just want an excuse - it's not your fault, it's this mysterious thing called talent.

    Your let me google it for you link is a failed attempt at being snarky, I didn't argue either way the inheritibility of IQ.

    The fact that there Autistic artist and people who suddenly become artistic due to brain injuries or disease calls into dispute that high IQ = great artist.
  • MM
    Offline / Send Message
    MM polycounter lvl 18
    it might hurt your ego if you are called a genius because you feel like "you didn't work hard enough" but that doesn't change the science behind it.

    just deal with it, and make good use of the talent if you have it.

    also, there are tons of people with born talent who just waste it away drinking, doing drugs and nothing creative at all.

    so dont feel bad, it all balances out in the end.

    born talent or not, if you lack the determination and dont do the hard work then you wont get better. talent just helps you get better faster.
    The fact that there Autistic artist and people who suddenly become artistic due to brain injuries or disease calls into dispute that high IQ = great artist.

    wait what ?

    that actually makes the point even better of relating cognitive functions of the brain to art. autistic artists may have low IQ but in the rare case that they show this symptom of savantism it only shows how the unbalance of the brains cognitive function plays a strong role in this. common cognitive functions get worse while some specific abilities get heightened. brain injuries is similar case of shifting the brains cognitive capabilities radically.
  • Justin Meisse
    Offline / Send Message
    Justin Meisse polycounter lvl 19
    ugh, you ever have an argument with someone that swears ghosts are real? I've got that feeling right now. I'm done with this thread :P

    To the OP: the current gen workflow doesn't require you to have much in the way of drawing skills so you should be fine. Maybe I'm a bit biased because I work in the "old school" field of diffuse only games, so it's basically like concept art without perpective.

    I'd like to just make a request, try to work on your drawing when you have free time because there's two sides here: I believe you have the potential to be a great 2d artist while the other side believes you lack talent (and may possibly be stupid because IQ = talent)
  • xvampire
    Offline / Send Message
    xvampire polycounter lvl 14
    in graphic art
    talent could be high obsession to art and design.
    they voluntarily draw or make things over and over because simply love it ( or if that the only source of their income)
    then artistic growth became autopilot.

    some example ... :
    http://video.nationalgeographic.com/video/the-magazine/the-magazine-latest/ngm-big-cats-art/

    "my precious..."
    960023_0.jpg
  • MM
    Offline / Send Message
    MM polycounter lvl 18
    I'd like to just make a request, try to work on your drawing when you have free time because there's two sides here: I believe you have the potential to be a great 2d artist while the other side believes you lack talent (and may possibly be stupid because IQ = talent)

    i think i understand where you are coming from now.

    what you refer to as talent, i call it skill that is learned over time and not something someone is born with.

    i was only talking about hereditary cognitive ability and how it can help learn that skill or say talent faster/slower.
  • CordellC
    Offline / Send Message
    CordellC polycounter lvl 11
    "Natural born talent" really just means an interest in the subject. You have to pursue it if you want to be great.
  • Nick Carver
    Offline / Send Message
    Nick Carver polycounter lvl 10
    I think the only questions you need to ask yourself are:

    1. Do you like drawing?
    2. Can you think about things analytically?
    3. Are you willing to work hard at it to get better?

    This is the same for any skill that you acquire really. You have to want to get better, but just as importantly, you need to be able to work out HOW you are going to get better. Being able to break problems down into their component parts and solve them individually is the smartest way to tackle drawing, or any other difficult skill that takes a long time to master. Trying to do too much to soon and not meeting your own expectations is the easiest way to discourage yourself. Small incremental steps is the way to go.

    If 'talent' does exist, I think it just means that someone develops those critical thinking faculties at an earlier age and advances more quickly as a result. But anyone can learn to think that way and become good at drawing or whatever else if they have the discipline and the persistence to keep at it. I was a late starter with drawing too as I didn't really work at improving at it until I was about 24. And although I'm not saying I'm great at it or anything, I've surprised myself in terms of how much hard work, particularly the right kind of work, can improve you as an artist.

    So yeah, enjoy learning and know that you'll get where you want to go if you apply yourself correctly.
  • Tairii
    Offline / Send Message
    Tairii polycounter lvl 9
    Don't mean to be off topic here, but when it comes to IQ, I'm miles ahead in my family (which means I don't think it's genetic). I did have a point in my education where I wanted to learn more and so I worked harder at memorizing facts and critical thinking. Now that I'm walking the art path, I kind of suck now (still new), but in my Drawing class I'm pulling ahead by so much, my teacher even commented on how well I did a rendering of an image (we had to draw lines to visualize form, which looked like a wireframe render, so I used my 3D knowledge in 2D!). I believe you can learn to draw, you just have to have patience and you have to want it. Next week, I'm starting my 365 days of drawing just so I can get past this dip.
  • MagicSugar
    Offline / Send Message
    MagicSugar polycounter lvl 10
    Just take the Kim Jung Gi test. If you're discouraged after seeing his talent...probably best to focus on something else other than drawing. But if you're discouraged but at the same time inspired to draw even though you know there's no way you'll reach the heights he's reached as a draftsman...maybe there's some potential for you there to become a better artist :)

    kimjunggi.jpg
  • Ruz
    Offline / Send Message
    Ruz polycount lvl 666
    I bet that anyone who turns out to be good at art after some practice/focus was born with that ability anyway, they just had not discovered it yet.
    if you are on polycount knocking out nice work then you are doing yourself a dis service if you think that just anyone can do that or that you don't have any kind of gift.
    kind of like a false modesty. fact is that not everyone could do what most of the people here do even if they practised a lot.
  • MagicSugar
    Offline / Send Message
    MagicSugar polycounter lvl 10
    Ruz wrote: »
    I bet that anyone who turns out to be good at art after some practice/focus was born with that ability anyway, they just had not discovered it yet.

    This is not a response, but it reminded me of this (particularly the sketch artist):

    http://www.nola.com/crime/index.ssf/2012/07/new_orleans_police_seek_9th_wa.html
  • JacqueChoi
    Offline / Send Message
    JacqueChoi polycounter
    [ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HhxcFGuKOys"]Why You Need to Fail - by Derek Sivers - YouTube[/ame]
  • Docm30
    Offline / Send Message
    Docm30 polycounter lvl 10
    Ruz wrote: »
    I bet that anyone who turns out to be good at art after some practice/focus was born with that ability anyway, they just had not discovered it yet.
    if you are on polycount knocking out nice work then you are doing yourself a dis service if you think that just anyone can do that or that you don't have any kind of gift.
    kind of like a false modesty. fact is that not everyone could do what most of the people here do even if they practised a lot.

    That doesn't make any sense to me. How can a person be born good at making something that doesn't inherently exist? There's no section of the brain used specifically for making art. I think some people are born more inclined to work hard and not give up (which is how one gets good at art) but that's not being born good at art, it's being born good at getting good.

    And frankly I think it's somewhat insulting to tell skilled people that they were born with the abillity and all their hard work was for nought.
  • Joseph Silverman
    Offline / Send Message
    Joseph Silverman polycounter lvl 17
    jacque choi, super cool link, thread's over (I hope)
1
Sign In or Register to comment.