Work I have done in Maya, looking for feedback.

Joey · Jan 2012

Hey everyone, I recently graduated with a BFA in media arts and animation. I am a 3D modeler and I wanted to share some of my work. Any and all feedback is much appreciated.

Thank You

www.JonesArtwork.com

BARDLER · Jan 2012

It looks like you understand modeling fine, but your textures are rather boring, no offense intended. Those 3 models are not really all that interesting and just for comparisons sake, lets look at this 3D Guitar and Tank
http://www.squier-talk.com/forum/attachments/squier-stratocasters/1546d1283972905-3d-guitar-model-clearacrylic-jpg
http://www.turbosquid.com/HDView/index.cfm/ID/469988/r/2/i/7

Joey · Jan 2012

Thank you for the feedback,No offense taken. texturing is something I am still working on. I appreciate your input.

Un_Delincuente · Jan 2012

I agree with BARDLER. You seem to understand the principles of modeling, but there's still a lot more you can do with texturing and lighting as well. Also I have to ask, do you know about strip modeling? Your bull piece looks like you box modeled it which is not the wrong way to do it, but when you are doing organic subjects like humans or animals, its usually recommended to use the strip modeling method.

Joey · Jan 2012

Hey Un_Delincuente, please elaborate on the term strip modeling. I may know of it by a different name. thanks

Sebeuroc · Jan 2012

I would like to echo what the others have said, your textures and lighting have a lot of room for improvement.

I'd also like to point out that though you seem to have a pretty good grasp on modeling, there are a couple instance in your portfolio where it becomes inconsistant. The skateboard model you did really jumps out at me because the board itself looks relatively low-poly while the trucks and wheels are a much higher mesh density. It looks like you're half way between creating game ready models and models for product renderings.
I suggest that for future projects you decide before you start modeling if you're going for a high resolution mesh or a game ready mesh and stick to those parameters.

Joey · Jan 2012

Thanks Sebeuroc for the feedback and for viewing my website. The comments have all been great. I have been meaning to upload the corrected images for the skateboard. It is a low poly model, I will fix that right away. thank you

Un_Delincuente · Jan 2012

Yea I probably should have elaborated a bit more on it. I think its also called "edge extrusion modeling" since thats pretty much what you do. Instead of starting with a 3 dimensional box you start with a Plane and extrude the edges out to create more polygons and sculpt it into form.

Heres a video that goes more into it.

[ame="

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FXdZfxmM-3Q"]3d Modeling a Head in Maya- edge extrusion method (1/6) - YouTube[/ame]

Joey · Jan 2012

Using this technique I see how you can have more control over specific areas of detail, this is very helpful, thanks for the video

Work I have done in Maya, looking for feedback.

Replies