Home General Discussion

Need an honest opinion, in a mid life crisis at the moment

So I'm suppose to be going to VFS (Vancouver Film School) in August. Today I got a friend request from a student who is attending. After talking for a while he has completely turned my opinion around to the dark side. He said it's not really worth it, and it's a business not a school. I'm trying to be not hard headed and take is warning seriously. this is a big decision because I'm bound up in a $70,000 loan that I might cancel...He referred me to digital tutors and Gnomon if I want to learn the same thing for cheaper. What the hell do I do?

Zack

Replies

  • scotthomer
    Personally, although there are both plus's and minus's to any educational establishment, especially those teaching Games Art, the most useful thing is the time. Ie, it gives you time to develop your skills with the support if you need it. You will learn very little from your course, its alot more likely that you'll make your own way, but the course teachers will help you get past the hurdles that you meet along the way.

    In all honestly, Video Games is a business, so the course will most likely be emulating this in its structure. If your course gives you the opportunity to network with industry guys and you can motivate yourself to put the time and effort in then it should be worth it. That being said $70k could probably be spent on keeping yourself afloat through a couple of years of learning on your own, however you'll most likely struggle to maintain the motivation without having deadlines in place to work towards.

    I hope this makes some sense... :D
  • Mark Dygert
    That's a hard decision to make and only one you can do. VFS has a really good reputation and I personally think its worth it if the money isn't going to be a huge burden. I think you should have a plan to pay it off without doing what you are training to do.

    It sounds like your friend might be dealing with what a lot of people deal with when they hit college. There isn't a lot of hand holding and you're expected to carry the lions share of the work load. It really is more like assisted self teaching. Those who walk in expecting the money they spend to net them a degree and a job with little effort probably aren't going to go that far and will feel cheated. They'll also have a hard time making in an industry where there is even less hand holding.

    It really takes a focused, dedicated and disciplined person to pull off the self educated route. Either path you take it will be a lot of work and the end goal is a smoking hot portfolio so don't lose sight of that. Good luck, relax and find the joy in creating. Projects are often a reflection of what you put into them. Worry, frustration and aimless toil are not what you want to show off in your portfolio. If its going to be this stressful learning then maybe you would be better off keeping this as a hobby until you find the joy?

    I honestly don't have an answer one way or the other and I don't know you well enough to recommend a path so its up to you... good luck.
  • Nemlet17
    Thanks Mark and Scott for writing.

    He gave me a list of names of other people that are in his class for an opinion. I understand it's a lot of self will, and animation I'm really passionate about but am wondering if it's really worth going to be in debt around $147,000 when all said and done after fees.
  • Habboi
    Offline / Send Message
    Habboi sublime tool
    Yes, I agree with Mark. Most dummies think schools will hold your hand and turn you into some super developer. And yeah, if it's stressful and you need a job badly, perhaps you should keep doing this as a hobby. I had the opportunity to work towards my job thanks to my parents support but not everyone has that chance and often have a real job and work on their portfolio on the side.

    A debt is a tough one. Take Zipfinator, I believe he skipped out on school and decided to teach himself to avoid being in debt. I went to university and while the course was...lacking, I would still go knowing what I know now. I met some great friends, spent three years doing what I loved and it looks nice on my CV / resume.

    I wish you luck, if you want to pursue this dream then keep at it and use all the time you have to improve yourself. They'll be days where it might cause great stress but you basically have to push past that, all the top artists did and look at them now!
  • Ark
    Offline / Send Message
    Ark polycounter lvl 11
    $70,000 seems absurd when you can basically get a subscription to Gnomon, FXPHD, Digital Tutors, EAT3D and 3DMotive etc... for a fraction of the price.

    I was considering a course at Escape when i was first starting out learning, but the fees where to much and hence i couldn't enroll. A few years later they started to do most of there classroom courses online and after checking some of the free trials out, i came to the conclusion that i would have been soo pissed if id have folked out so much money for what they was offering, most of it was available online free, the rest could easily be found at the sites listed above for a fraction of the price.

    I don't buy into all this "Oh such-a-bodies teaching it." They may well be very talented artists, but teaching is a whole different story.

    I think the only good thing imho about being stuck in a classroom is that your focused on doing the work as opposed to watching some stuff at home and then your mind starts wondering and you fire up a game midway through a DVD.

    I've heard most of the ones that get the jobs from these classroom based studies are the one that put the extra time in and stayed to work after class had ended. I Wouldn't go in there thinking paying $70,000 will get you what you need without putting in the extra effort.

    For CG related stuff, im personally against these classroom studies when theres basically soooo much help available online, like here on Polycount, and the other CG sites.
    I've learned so much stuff off the many talented people on these boards that think Polycount would do so well making there own teaching literature.

    I don't think this is something you that can just go diving head first on, consider the price and the amount of time its gonna cost you to pay it back.

    Maybe you can get a different opinion apart from your friend, has i said earlier some people may think that $70,000 is a ticket straight into the industry without putting the work in, i'm not saying he isn't, but more opinions will probably help you make a more informed decision
  • Nemlet17
    That's what I was thinking Ark. He gave me list of his classmates in which I'm adding and talking to on Facebook. I think I could get the same education with online course, DVD's, and you guys without being in debt for 20 years of my life.
  • m4dcow
    Offline / Send Message
    m4dcow interpolator
    Does VFS give actual degrees, or is it like some sort of certificate? I ask because while learning through polycount, Gnomon, Eat3d etc... could be a better and cheaper option if you are a highly motivated person, it may not provide you the credentials you need to work outside of your country.

    Something to keep in mind, but if that isn't an issue and you can focus outside of a classroom setting then do the online thing.
  • Nemlet17
    Yeah, VFS gives you a certificate and I would want to work outside of the country if the opportunity came up.
  • Jason Young
    Offline / Send Message
    Jason Young polycounter lvl 14
    Nemlet17 wrote: »
    Yeah, VFS gives you a certificate and I would want to work outside of the country if the opportunity came up.

    That'll be tough without an actual degree, at least in the US. There are quite a few ways to do it, but without a degree you'd likely need 12 years of experience.
  • Ark
    Offline / Send Message
    Ark polycounter lvl 11
    But then again a certificate isn't a ticket to jobs in other countries. Sure it may help with the immigration, but i'm pretty sure someone with a kickass portfolio with no certificate and someone with one just that particular certificate, the guy the kickass portfolio is gonna stand a better chance.

    You've not said where your from, i assume your Canadian judging from wanting to go to VFS, maybe if you plan to move to the US, as i hear it's quite strict with regards to immigration, but in Europe, it's quite easily to move around due to the EU. Even more so if your Canadian due to the Commonwealth.

    Maybe studying Art at your local college and doing 3D stuff at home gives you the best of both if you really want that piece of paper.
  • Joopson
    Offline / Send Message
    Joopson quad damage
    I'm going to the Art Institute in LA, and while it is a different school, it sounds like it's very similar. Truthfully, I realized for me it isn't worth it. Why pay $100,000 to do what I could do on my own? I don't know what I expected when applying to this college; maybe that I would learn more from the teachers or something. But I have yet to learn anything, save for on my own. Except for one anatomy class I took, that is.

    So, if you can do it on your own, I would suggest it.
  • nordahl154
    Offline / Send Message
    nordahl154 polycounter lvl 9
    I started 3D art over a year ago, and having spent $100 or so on tutorials, I totally avoided having to go to college to learn this stuff. There are advantages to college like working with people doing the same thing around you and a cool campus full of great people to motivate you, but for 70k? Nah brah. The problems with doing it yourself though are lack of motivation, nobody to tell you what to do next, and how to get there. I just wish I had somebody to work with in real life, but Polycount is a great place and you'll eventually learn most of that stuff with our help! :)

    Lol, my friends and family are all concerned about my turning down of college and doubt my art, but I can't wait to see their reaction when I land a job in the game industry that I actually like doing instead of working in a lab drawing blood all day like my parents. Go for the gold and do what you want to in life. Like that saying "find a job you love, and you will never have to work a day in your life."
    I just loathe the attitude about the absolute necessary need to go to college to succeed. I realize that this industry is out of the ordinary and that a lot of others do require a degree, but I find them shoving this in our face every damn day is annoying as shit.
  • ae.
    Offline / Send Message
    ae. polycounter lvl 12
    Dont goto college its a waste of time, especially for game art there are so many tutorials out there that you could either buy or watch online that paying 40k would make you a crazy person.
  • Delerium
    scotthomer wrote: »
    Personally, although there are both plus's and minus's to any educational establishment, especially those teaching Games Art, the most useful thing is the time. Ie, it gives you time to develop your skills with the support if you need it. You will learn very little from your course, its alot more likely that you'll make your own way, but the course teachers will help you get past the hurdles that you meet along the way.

    In all honestly, Video Games is a business, so the course will most likely be emulating this in its structure. If your course gives you the opportunity to network with industry guys and you can motivate yourself to put the time and effort in then it should be worth it. That being said $70k could probably be spent on keeping yourself afloat through a couple of years of learning on your own, however you'll most likely struggle to maintain the motivation without having deadlines in place to work towards.

    I hope this makes some sense... :D
    Fully agree with this, see the education as you are buying your self time, time to grow and level up. You can do it on your own really but if you are in school you get more motivation and a lot of spare time to practice. If you are lucky your class will have some other students that have the right mindset and that will push you forward to excel and that is something you can not get from staying in your bedroom and doing art.
  • Gav
    Offline / Send Message
    Gav quad damage
    I'm not going to go into too much depth as I've made a write up on my experience as a Canadian working in America that you can search for on the forum - but - if you're Canadian, working in America isn't THAT hard, there's just a lot of hoops you need to jump through. You'd be working under a TN Visa as a Graphic Designer which requires a degree or 1 year of post secondary education and 3+ years of industry experience that needs to be proven (that's the route I took - my advice is to just not burn bridges as I had to call up old employers for big favours.) The idea that you need 12 years experience isn't true, at least from a Canadian to America perspective.

    That being said, I'd strongly recommend NOT putting yourself that deep in debt as it'll probably be a while before you get a job out of school. If you'd doing it JUST to get a piece of paper, it doesn't matter what school it is as long as you get the piece of paper. Meaning, border officials don't know that VFS is a su[er awesome school - for that matter they don't even REALLY know what you do.

    From the standpoint of actually 'learning', that's all upto the individual. Most people in this industry don't need to follow the broad curriculum a school would provide and are just fins learning on their own and developing their portfolio while, say, studying something else or working at Kinkos.

    The education doesn't guarantee anything and, really, even being the 'best' school for that type of education doesn't put you any further ahead of someone else coming out of school. If your portfolio sucks, that's it. VFS (and other reputable schools) will help you out with networking - but so would a membership to the IGDA, attending GDC and chatting up folks on Polycount.
  • r_fletch_r
    Offline / Send Message
    r_fletch_r polycounter lvl 9
    Only thing college really gave me was a good life drawing teacher and a working atmosphere. 90% of the other stuff was available online, and often more up to date.
  • Ace-Angel
    Offline / Send Message
    Ace-Angel polycounter lvl 12
    College
    Pros = Connections / Working Environment / Deadlines / Group Projects / Paper Work for easier aboard work.
    Cons = Assholes / Outdated workflows / Teachers who don't know what normal map padding is / Expensive

    Online Tutorials/Polycount

    Pros = Godhood
    Cons = Not meeting your wife/husband on a cig break
  • RyanB
    Nemlet17 wrote: »
    Thanks Mark and Scott for writing.

    He gave me a list of names of other people that are in his class for an opinion. I understand it's a lot of self will, and animation I'm really passionate about but am wondering if it's really worth going to be in debt around $147,000 when all said and done after fees.

    If you invested $147,000 for 25 years and earned a 7% average annual return, you would have $800,000.

    The industry you want to work in is notorious for not paying overtime and laying employees off regularly. This will often cost you a significant amount of lost income.

    The lifestyle of the games industry is also generally poor.

    This adds up to a very poor investment.

    I would suggest you choose a better career, work on indie projects in your spare time, and take traditional art courses locally. You will probably enjoy a much healthier lifestyle and be better off financially in the long and short term.
  • David-J
    Offline / Send Message
    David-J polycounter lvl 11
    Ace-Angel wrote: »
    College
    Pros = Connections / Working Environment / Deadlines / Group Projects / Paper Work for easier aboard work.
    Cons = Assholes / Outdated workflows / Teachers who don't know what normal map padding is / Expensive

    Online Tutorials/Polycount

    Pros = Godhood
    Cons = Not meeting your wife/husband on a cig break

    Big one for me. I met my wife at VFS, we were in the same class.

    On another note, it is very important that you know that you are going to get out of it what you put in. If you don't put in the extra hours you won't get anything out of it. And when I mean extra hours is be there at the very least 12 hours each day every day. Those 70,000 amount to nothing by themselves.

    Remember that VFS doesn't offer you a degree, so for legal purposes the certificate they give you it's not very helpful. You will get very good connections out of VFS, a lot my classmates are employed at game companies or VFX studios. So that is always good to have.

    Like everyone has said. If that debt is not going to be quite the burden go for it.

    Also what level of knowledge you have when it comes to 3d in general? I've noticed that if you are very new to 3d you really won't get the best out of VFS. You will learn a lot there but your reel won't be good enough to land you some jobs.

    cheers and good luck and PM me if you have some questions.
  • Zipfinator
    Offline / Send Message
    Zipfinator polycounter lvl 9
    nordahl154 wrote: »
    I started 3D art over a year ago, and having spent $100 or so on tutorials, I totally avoided having to go to college to learn this stuff. There are advantages to college like working with people doing the same thing around you and a cool campus full of great people to motivate you, but for 70k? Nah brah. The problems with doing it yourself though are lack of motivation, nobody to tell you what to do next, and how to get there. I just wish I had somebody to work with in real life, but Polycount is a great place and you'll eventually learn most of that stuff with our help! :)

    This is pretty much the same situation I'm in. I decided not to go to school and although I did attend Futurepoly (A small 3 month program that's very cheap compared to 4 year schools) I'm still mostly self-taught. Motivation is definitely a problem sometimes. It's hard to get yourself to work the amount you need to each day even though you know that the only way you'll improve and progress as an artist is by working more. I believe that once I get over a few motivational humps and learn to focus more I'll be better off for it compared to having gone to a 4 year school where I'd have assignments to keep me in line.

    The connections you make is definitely a loss though. As Nordahl said I don't think that's worth the $100,000 in debt though. I haven't met any new contacts (Friends or work related) in person outside of Futurepoly, which I don't really keep in contact with anymore, since I was in High School over a year ago. I just sit on the computer all day working or reading Polycount. I'm still meeting new people on Polycount though and I still have my old friends from High School to play games with over Steam since they're all in Illinois, but it's definitely not the same as being at a school in person surrounded by likeminded people, even if they're completely new to game art.
    nordahl154 wrote: »
    Lol, my friends and family are all concerned about my turning down of college and doubt my art, but I can't wait to see their reaction when I land a job in the game industry that I actually like doing instead of working in a lab drawing blood all day like my parents. Go for the gold and do what you want to in life. Like that saying "find a job you love, and you will never have to work a day in your life."
    I just loathe the attitude about the absolute necessary need to go to college to succeed. I realize that this industry is out of the ordinary and that a lot of others do require a degree, but I find them shoving this in our face every damn day is annoying as shit.

    My family is kind of like this too. After I went to Futurepoly and the Arenanet Artists said I was one of the best students in their classes they're a bit more confident that I will succeed but they definitely used to badger me about getting a job or taking classes at the nearby college when I need to just sit on the computer and work on art.
  • xvampire
    Offline / Send Message
    xvampire polycounter lvl 14
    wtf 30.000 more expensive than when i got there? T_T

    anyway, it depends, I really love vfs back there, amazing working environment.
    and yes. you will find people who spend time working in something after class.
    maybe because of the expensive amazing "toys" vfs has there. including all the drawing tool, and sculpting tool.
    the best class I ve seen is the class who share each other. it really help.
    ( like i remember 3d59 guys , these people are monsters lol )


    some class are very individualistic, thats a problem, maybe your friend just had class that people keep their secret technique no jutsu for his/her own.


    as for degree thing, yes it doesnt give you degree, but in canada, starting from 2010 certificate from vfs is qualified to earn work permit, even before you get a job. that means paperwork thing should be less bothersome ...


    last word :
    vfs WAS the best school, it still good now, BUT , there are many other education institution that offer good quality or even better than VFS.
    thats why , when you saw some vfs student got CGTALK or zbrushcentral , frontpage exposure before, now , i think is much less ...
  • EtotheRic
    Offline / Send Message
    EtotheRic polycounter lvl 19
    I'd suggest a traditional arts/animation program that offers a bachelor's degree over some computer arts certificate.
  • Rwolf
    Offline / Send Message
    Rwolf polycounter lvl 18
    m4dcow wrote: »
    Does VFS give actual degrees, or is it like some sort of certificate? I ask because while learning through polycount, Gnomon, Eat3d etc... could be a better and cheaper option if you are a highly motivated person, it may not provide you the credentials you need to work outside of your country.

    Something to keep in mind, but if that isn't an issue and you can focus outside of a classroom setting then do the online thing.

    They gave me a diploma in Modeling, whoop-de-doo.

    I don't even put it on my resume since it's so silly. I let my previous work talk for me.
  • Gmanx
    Offline / Send Message
    Gmanx polycounter lvl 19
    You're potentially investing $70,000 in a business, hoping that their product will help your chosen future career. Ask them what percentage of graduates get work, and what salaries they actually pull down.

    Personally, I'd invest in some online courses - as detailed earlier, and teach yourself, IF you have the determination and will-power to push yourself.
  • CheeseOnToast
    Offline / Send Message
    CheeseOnToast greentooth
    I suggest you get a traditional degree in art, something like painting, sculpture or illustration/graphic design. It'll be cheaper, the skills are transferable and you can learn the 3D side by yourself. Digital Tutors do great (but very slow-paced) DVDs for absolute beginners, while the likes of Eat3D and Gnomon deal with the more advanced stuff at a fraction of the cost of a course.
  • Nemlet17
    Thank you all for the suggestions. I just wanted to say that I don't expect them to spoon feed me and I am willing to work hard as hell. I see VFS as making more connections to the industry as opposed to going to a community college but then again I'm paying for those connections. It could be the worst decision of my life but then again I could see you all in a couple of years and tell you it was the best. Over the past few days thinking about I realized that I must just do what I simply think is best, that feels right to me. When something always bad happens to me or I'm in conflict, I always joke about it being another chapter in my autobiography (I've got quite a story, as I'm sure we all do). I'm deciding to go to VFS, and had to calm down from my mild panic attack. I don't care if I have to live on Ramon Noodles for the next 15 years of my life, as long as I'm doing what I love. Plus, going into a school already knowing some stuff, I plan to use that as an advantage but then again my mind might race again tonight. I would once again like to thank you (Polycounter's) for the continuing support and suggestions. You guys are truly the best.

    Zack Dembinski
  • Ben Apuna
    I dunno, this thing about paying $70,000 for connections...

    Personally I met quite a few people in the industry going to a community college. Though I didn't take full advantage of it like I should have. One of my instructors was from Dreamworks, one from Disney, another had worked on a couple of feature films. I met some employees of Square and a few from Konami. I even got to attend a couple of presentations by Craig Mullins among other noteworthy concept artists. All that for probably ~$3500.

    I actually think you're probably in the best place to make a good impression and great connections with industry people right here on Polycount, for free.

    Some related info to consider:

    http://www.polycount.com/forum/showthread.php?t=86061

    http://www.polycount.com/forum/showthread.php?t=78406
  • bluekangaroo
    Offline / Send Message
    bluekangaroo polycounter lvl 13
    anything you'll learn at a school you can teach yourself and more just by studying online. It really is possible, plus you'll save yourself a whole lot of cash. In my opinion school's these arent worth it.
  • ceebee
    Offline / Send Message
    ceebee polycounter lvl 14
    Ben Apuna wrote: »
    I actually think you're probably in the best place to make a good impression and great connections with industry people right here on Polycount, for free.

    This.

    Polycounters are so amazing at helping each other out as long as you prove you're determined and willing to show people how much you're working at becoming the best artist you can be. If I had the choice between only Polycount or my $55k education at Gnomon then I'd easily take Polycount over Gnomon. This community is literally priceless and there is unlimited knowledge you can gain from it unlike a formal education.

    If you really do think you need a formal education then go for it, but I highly recommend being a regular here even if you do.

    Start making art and posting it already! This goes for a lot of people I see worried about what to do with their future or education.
  • Mark Dygert
    Good advice, but I suggest not taking it. That's a lot of ******* money to pay off, and the truth is, colleges in NA are becoming businesses very quickly. I'm not sure about Canada, but I suspect he's right. It's less about providing information and more about marketing.
    Yea I wasn't telling him to do it. I'm normally one of the most vocal people on the boards telling people not to throw their money away and saddle themselves with debt. I've been working in the industry for 5 years and I left school when it wasn't giving me what I wanted. Mind you that was at a time when the only place to learn 3D was by yourself...

    I only think it MIGHT be worth it if the money isn't an issue. As in it's already paid for by parents or through the government then its probably worth it to go its not like VFS is ITT tech... Have you seen District 9?

    But if its going to mean he basically bought a house without a house to show for it, before he even moves out of his parents basement then well... its a bad idea, especially for a certificate that won't help you land a job elsewhere.

    Either way its going to be on him to learn what he needs to learn and demonstrate he has what it takes to deliver. Just having some Gnoman DVD's sitting on your shelf doesn't make you a good FX artist, just like showing up to class doesn't guarantee you a job.
  • Acr0
    Offline / Send Message
    Acr0 polycounter lvl 5
    Many companies use forums like this one and other to find potential employees far more than schools.
  • DrunkShaman
    Offline / Send Message
    DrunkShaman polycounter lvl 14
    Nemlet17 wrote: »
    So I'm suppose to be going to VFS (Vancouver Film School) in August. Today I got a friend request from a student who is attending. After talking for a while he has completely turned my opinion around to the dark side. He said it's not really worth it, and it's a business not a school. I'm trying to be not hard headed and take is warning seriously. this is a big decision because I'm bound up in a $70,000 loan that I might cancel...He referred me to digital tutors and Gnomon if I want to learn the same thing for cheaper. What the hell do I do?

    Zack

    Hez right. VFS and AODt are not really worth spending money on. Instead if you wish to spend money, try Sheridan college. They have good CG programs.

    If you want to go really really cheap and learn on your own, try Digital Tutors. you spend approx $500 a year and they will guide you enough for you to be aware of how things work. You will have to improvise and do projects of your own to keep the practice in check after that.

    Sheridan college:

    http://www.sheridancollege.ca/Programs%20and%20Courses/Full-Time%20Programs/Programs%20A-Z%20Index/Bachelor%20of%20Applied%20Arts%20-%20Animation.aspx

    Digital Tutors:

    www.digitaltutors.com
    Ben Apuna wrote: »
    I actually think you're probably in the best place to make a good impression and great connections with industry people right here on Polycount, for free.

    lol, ya right, like thats working out for me right? I have to beg people to give me some crit on my work so I know if I am NOT going wrong. Making connections are far out of the question. lol. Make connections.

    But it may work for the OP. :)
  • maze
    DO NOT GO!!! SAVE THAT MONEY!! IS A HELL LOT OF MONEY AND YES YOU'LL GET THE SAME OR EVEN BETTER CONTENT ON THOSE SITES YOU VE MENTIONED.

    sorry for the caps, but man I understand your situation.

    If you really want it you'll do it on your own, its a lot harder because you need to be ultra disciplined. But you can do it.

    I dont say vfs is a bad school. In fact I heard very good comments about it. But even with that Idont think its worth all that money for what you will really get out.

    The only really good point willl be industry contacts for me.

    Edit: and for that last one yeah you ve got polycount dude.
  • nick2730
    Not worth it, im in similar boat and thought same thing went to school still cant find a decent job 1 year later
  • moof
    Offline / Send Message
    moof polycounter lvl 7
    I honestly can say although my life experiences at college were important, you don't need them to get a job.

    Gnomon DVDs, and tons and tons of projects done on your own time actually seem like a super legit way to get a job.

    All you need is a hot portfolio to post around to get a job.

    I suppose if you're a social butterfly, and are not looking specifically at an art path into the industry, there are benefits to college in terms of networking...

    otherwise if you can stay diligent at home with projects (to the point of almost becoming a recluse imo, you almost must give up your social life for awhile to get a lot better) then you could definitely try it out.
Sign In or Register to comment.