3D Ripper DX - question concerning normalmaps

THE 5 · Aug 2010

So I tried this tool today, capturing Starcraft 2.
Now the normalmaps that it creates are just partly correct.
The ground textures seem allright but for other objects some of the RGB channels are blank. Any thoughts on this, maybe sollutuions?

EDIT:
I am sorry if that whole 3D tripping storry is a nono on PC

Feel free to kill this thread then.

felipefrango · Aug 2010

Weird. I've created orange normal maps like this with Nvidia Texture Tools 2 command line DDS exporter but only when I put in the wrong commands. Never saw this happen with 3D Ripper though. Is there any chance they would intentionally store only one channel worth of normal information?

Bal · Aug 2010

Because of the DXT5 compression for normal maps I think? They stick one channel in the Green (the channel that is the less degraded in DXT compression I think?) white in red, black in blue (not sure why, probably again, gives the less artifacts in the green channel), then put the other channel in the Alpha (stays super clean after compression in DXT5). They ditch the blue altogether, as it's not necessary.

I think the ground textures look more like uncompressed normal maps because they are compressed in DXT1.

felipefrango · Aug 2010

Hmm, that sounds feasible indeed. THE5, what's in the alpha channel of the orange map, if there actually is one?

THE 5 · Aug 2010

(sorry for the late response)
Yup it's inside the alpha

Strange I did not see the alpha was not just pure white.

Now I got one more thing to ask.
I,d like to view the mesh inside 3ds Max with the 3 Point Shader.
The problem is that the correct Mapping channel for the textures is channel 5. The 3 Point shader is using channel 1 by default. Normaly when assingning a bitmap to a standart material you cna select what channel it is supposed to use. How can I get the 3 point shader to use channel 5, or even better, how can I swap texture channels in general (exchange 1 for 5)?

r_fletch_r · Aug 2010

there is a utility in the utilitys tab called 'channel info' that will let you copy and paste mapping data between channels.

utilities - more -> channel Info.

seeing all these hacks makes me wonder why the hell there isnt dxt format that stores 2 channels specifically for normal maps. (edit DX 10 has this with BC5/3DC)

http://developer.nvidia.com/object/real-time-normal-map-dxt-compression.html

THE 5 · Aug 2010

OK, thats it!
Thanks guys!

Bal · Aug 2010

r_fletch_r, that site is a good read.
I can't test cause I'm still on DX9, but what's the memory difference with the BC5 compressoin? Is it less than DXT5, or the same? It's not obvious from the description (for me anyways).

It's strange that there's DXT1 and BC5 in UDK, but no DX5nm (or maybe they removed it when BC5 was added, thus ignoring the DirectX 9 crowd).

tcn42 · Sep 2015

Hello!

I have been using 3d Ripper DX to capture some directx drawcalls then importing in to 3DS Max. When I import and scale, all is good. Textures are where they should be. See the following image:
original?v=mpbl-1&px=-1

The only thing I have done is imported and rescaled at this point. I have not touched anything that has to do with textures or maps. All looks good so I decided to export as .3DS (I've clicked yes to preserve max texture coordinates). However, upon looking at the exported .3DS file it is clear that the mapping of the textures is incorrect.

original?v=mpbl-1&px=-1

The exported .3ds textures are flipped, skewed, etc......I am a beginner with 3DS Max, so maybe I am making a bonehead mistake?

Any ideas would be greatly appreciated!

tcn42 · Sep 2015

Sorry for replying to such an old post, my account will not let me create a new thread.

3D Ripper DX - question concerning normalmaps

Replies