I still think the judging process is a complete joke.
I have absolutely no idea how Hazardous and SuperOstrich were left out of the final 36, when they were easily top 5 (both front paged here at Polycount).
Then that stupid 1-5 judging system doesn't lean towards a very good averaging, because some otherwise amazing pieces are completely left out. It HAS to be a 1-10 grading system.
zomg no batman... anywhere in the top 10!!! Jocz you got totally ripped dude! Congrats to all the winners - sick art, I always liked me some comicons!!
Jacque: Thanks for the props dude, but my character isn't really your typical comic book heroine lookalike - that's probably one of any number of reasons it didn't make even the top 36, along with the fact that my submitted images for the comp were ordinary..... Strange that Kid Batman wasnt up there tho.....
For me we should remove the 1. 2. 3. stuff and call only top-5 top-10 top-50 or something like that.
I def agree with this. Alot of the entries and then some are executed so f'n perfectly that it's impossible to judge it without bringing an extra amount of personal taste into it...
Replies
Overall it's almost the same as how I would vote, except maybe a couple.
Real inspiring work in there.
I have absolutely no idea how Hazardous and SuperOstrich were left out of the final 36, when they were easily top 5 (both front paged here at Polycount).
Then that stupid 1-5 judging system doesn't lean towards a very good averaging, because some otherwise amazing pieces are completely left out. It HAS to be a 1-10 grading system.
Congrats to Link. Amazing entry.
Just very upset over how this all panned out.
Frankly all the top 10 are amazing and deserving, just my 2 cents.
EDIT: Nevermind. they're just laid out weird. hum!
My top 3:
1.Old Batman
2.Old Link
3.Jaco' Catwoman
Amazing standard of work. Well done all!
But regardless of that amazing entry's, I mean WOW, that Batman model is going straight to the inspiration folder. wow
Jacque: Thanks for the props dude, but my character isn't really your typical comic book heroine lookalike - that's probably one of any number of reasons it didn't make even the top 36, along with the fact that my submitted images for the comp were ordinary..... Strange that Kid Batman wasnt up there tho.....
Hubba Hubba
Do the judges only choose their top 5 favorites?
He got third, the layout is just weird.
Congratulations to all the winners, fantastic work.
there's a typo in the 3d winners name.
crap your right! I'm getting old you see. deviations of line of sight etc.... its difficult.
Some very cool stuff in there!!
and the placement is strange too but I got already used to it
it doesn't change the quality of the work.
For me we should remove the 1. 2. 3. stuff and call only top-5 top-10 top-50 or something like that.
I def agree with this. Alot of the entries and then some are executed so f'n perfectly that it's impossible to judge it without bringing an extra amount of personal taste into it...
and that's bad mmkay.
:thumbup: :thumbup: :thumbup: :thumbup: :thumbup: :thumbup: :thumbup:
http://www.gameartisans.org/contests/competitions/7/preview_finals_2_5747.html
Hehe. Funny. :thumbup: