Been trying out the unreal engine, and thought I've learned it best by putting together a simple scene.
It's pretty basic, all the props are done quite fast, 1-2 props a day.
The props look nice and it's a well put together scene. But it feels very generic (I know it's a theme that is very common). I think you could gain a LOT by changing the lighting to be more contrasted, and to get some gradients in there. Also it'd be nice to see something more saturated. At least it'd be nice to see some props pop out more in colour.
Personally I'd probably go with some nice bright color on the walls as well.
Feels a lack of cast shadows (props r floating) - after all its UE3 I assume :P
The floor looks a bit too simple - again, cauz of lack of shadows and also maybe some more decals with papers etc.
Also those rivets on metal beams look off to me. They kinda would not appear there - rivets r used to fix joits between bams. And also they r not square shaped - those kind of beams r usually T or double T chape
@PhilipK: You'r right, I really need some more colors, it's too grey right now
@Matroskin: yup it's UE3. the beams are actually double t-shaped, but maybe a tad to little.
Need to work a bit more on the beams, and add some more litter like papers laying on the floor, and add some more color to it all and add some more props. Perhaps I'll check some old screens from max payne
And the lightning needs some more work, more contrast, shadows and colors I guess
Its a great start. I agree w/ what others are saying -
- It's lacking some nice color focal points
- Lighting is very flat and washed out. Less ambient light, more direct.
- Wall and floor texture are fighting for attention - walls have too much contrast / detail IMO.
- Materials feel flat / don't pop because there is very little surface change / specular on objects.
Also, try breaking up the lockers with some decals perhaps? The dirt pattern is exactly the same across all three of them and it's particularly noticeable on the top slits.
been working with the lightning in udk , but I keep getting these lightmap erros in my bsp walls.
here's how it looks like:
I get very sharp edges where my polygons are. They are just simple bsp brushes with a planar mapping on them. And it doesn't help to render the lightning in production either...
I have remade the walls several times now but keep getting the same errors, what am I missing?
I would make those walls static meshes. They tend to take lighting a little better. Don't bake in production either until you are sure you have it final. I remember reading somewhere (I think JordanW posted it in the UDK Thread) that each quality jump in lightmass add 3x more render time than the previous. With this small scene that shouldn't be an issue, but why waste the extra time :P
I have a question, how did you get the texture under the vents to the upper right of the door? You ahve the simple vents then the base texture behind, but then you have a rusty dripping texture under it, how did you apply it?
@ nick 2730.. you can do that by just creating a decal.. a flat plane of geometry w/ a set opacity mask..in his case, rust.. so you can place it and blend it pretty much anywhere..
environment looks pretty good dude.. one thing ya might wanna add besides the fog might be some dusty particle effects.. might add a little more character to your scene.. up to you
For the brush above the door that has the issues, try just making a rectangle w/ 4 verts and extend it above the ceiling. Yes, you'll have some wasted BSP outside the room, but it should light better.
u can try to make a simpler brush for the wall with doorway.
I would just make additive cube and then substract smaller cube for the door. No need to make a complex additive brush with the door modelled by hand. Also it does not need to follow same shape on top as the ceiling - u can literally keep it as a box.
I case of 2 brushes touching you need to have one's surface follow another. In your case u made the walls' top follow the shape of the celling. That is technically correct but generates more complex geometry. Swich "roles" - make wall higher than the ceiling and snap ceiling's side to the wall :
Fluorescent lighting usually has a tint of blue to it. This will eliminate the flat white/gray/boring feel that your lighting has atm. Adding some contrast to your scene with darker shadows will help your scene pop more as well.
@Matroskin, gamedev: Been trying out some different approaches on the wall and solved the problem now.
Easiest way to solve it, was to simplify the brushes and it all works now, thanks for the tips
@nick2730: just like jmiles said, it's just decals. That decal is used a lot and it doesn't even has an opacity mask, it just rust on a white background that is set to blendingmode -> modulate.
@jmiles: i'll look in to the dusty particles asap, good idea started to work on a smoke particle from on of the pipes, but haven't figured out how everything works yet
@Snight: good idea, looks much better with a little blue tint
Replies
Personally I'd probably go with some nice bright color on the walls as well.
you nailed the mood!
Great work man.
Love the sharpness of the textures reminds me a lot of some of the work done on ETQW
Feels a lack of cast shadows (props r floating) - after all its UE3 I assume :P
The floor looks a bit too simple - again, cauz of lack of shadows and also maybe some more decals with papers etc.
Also those rivets on metal beams look off to me. They kinda would not appear there - rivets r used to fix joits between bams. And also they r not square shaped - those kind of beams r usually T or double T chape
http://comps.fotosearch.com/comp/UNW/UNW252/metal-beam-ceiling_~u25067801.jpg
glad you like it
@PhilipK: You'r right, I really need some more colors, it's too grey right now
@Matroskin: yup it's UE3. the beams are actually double t-shaped, but maybe a tad to little.
Need to work a bit more on the beams, and add some more litter like papers laying on the floor, and add some more color to it all and add some more props. Perhaps I'll check some old screens from max payne
And the lightning needs some more work, more contrast, shadows and colors I guess
I'll keep you updated
Second that!
- It's lacking some nice color focal points
- Lighting is very flat and washed out. Less ambient light, more direct.
- Wall and floor texture are fighting for attention - walls have too much contrast / detail IMO.
- Materials feel flat / don't pop because there is very little surface change / specular on objects.
-Tyler
Also, try breaking up the lockers with some decals perhaps? The dirt pattern is exactly the same across all three of them and it's particularly noticeable on the top slits.
here's how it looks like:
I get very sharp edges where my polygons are. They are just simple bsp brushes with a planar mapping on them. And it doesn't help to render the lightning in production either...
I have remade the walls several times now but keep getting the same errors, what am I missing?
I would just make additive cube and then substract smaller cube for the door. No need to make a complex additive brush with the door modelled by hand. Also it does not need to follow same shape on top as the ceiling - u can literally keep it as a box.
I case of 2 brushes touching you need to have one's surface follow another. In your case u made the walls' top follow the shape of the celling. That is technically correct but generates more complex geometry. Swich "roles" - make wall higher than the ceiling and snap ceiling's side to the wall :
Easiest way to solve it, was to simplify the brushes and it all works now, thanks for the tips
@nick2730: just like jmiles said, it's just decals. That decal is used a lot and it doesn't even has an opacity mask, it just rust on a white background that is set to blendingmode -> modulate.
@jmiles: i'll look in to the dusty particles asap, good idea started to work on a smoke particle from on of the pipes, but haven't figured out how everything works yet
@Snight: good idea, looks much better with a little blue tint
here's some progress screens: