Home 3D Art Showcase & Critiques

Props Thread for "The Travel"

Props from the game I'm working on, heres the first one. It's a cubicle dividers but waist height. The old office I worked in had these exact ones, and since the game takes place in hell, I though it be appropriate for me to recreate my hell.

RoundTopDividerSkin.jpg
Divider003.jpg
Divider002.jpg
Divider001.jpg

And a Painting! Still a wip. I'm trying to break away from doing my perspective shit too clean, because it always comes out too clean... Anyways.

OfficeintheCave.jpg

Replies

  • The Umbrella Man
    Heres the middle piece. This completes the lego set.

    MiddlePiece.jpg
    MiddlePeiceSkin.jpg

    Legos together
    Legos.jpg

    Nowthat I look at it, does anyone else think the black parts on the long divider look a tad bit noisy?
  • hawken
    Offline / Send Message
    hawken polycounter lvl 19
    maybe it seems like a lot to you, but it's very little to us.

    I'd be interested to see when you've spent more time on this, plus I'm actually sure that your boxes there have very little to do with time travel
  • pliang
    Offline / Send Message
    pliang polycounter lvl 17
    Might as well make a void and throw all sorts of clutter from different time periods if its time travel...from the concept it looks like an office space inside a cavern.

    And the cubicle can use a little bit of research since it looks more like something broken off a dumpster when I looked at it.
  • The Umbrella Man
    Time travel? Where did this come from? I don't see time travel in the thread anywhere. Am I dreaming?
  • pliang
    Offline / Send Message
    pliang polycounter lvl 17
    Oh I'm sorry I must've misread the title...(sad)

    Anyways, my point is the piece can use a little but redefine and perhaps some color values than the green you got there...
  • The Umbrella Man
    Some more unimpressive stuff. If anyone can offer some critiques on this stuff it would be great. Texturing is still pretty difficult for me, so any input on the previous models and this new one would help out a lot.

    Plus if theres a spot I should be posting this stuff other then in pimpin and previews please let me know.

    I spent about an hour on this skin, I'm not too terribly pleased with it, but don't know what else to do with it. When I get to that point I usually start adding arbitrary details that end up muddying things. Is there something I am missing?

    cabinet.jpg
    GreyFilingCabinetSkin.jpg

    In the level
    office001.jpg
  • Mark Dygert
    Those cubical walls look like concrete/mental barriers you would see in a run down theme park, not cubical walls at all. The metal shelving filing cabinets are much better and more like what you would expect. Even if your cube walls are built off of actual first hand reference go with something everyone will recognize as a cube wall. ie not so thick, not made out of concrete, normally covered in some kind of noise reducing cloth, like this.
    http://www.louisefoxprotocolsolutions.com/ProtocolPower/images/pp1.9/cubicle%20dwellers.jpg
    Adding in the brackets, end caps and base running kick boards will go a long way in selling the cube wall look.
  • notman
    Offline / Send Message
    notman polycounter lvl 18
    I agree with Vig. I thought those were supposed to be outside walls, like walls for a parking area. Cubicle walls are only a couple inches thick... yours look to be a foot or two. They are also usually a cloth material, not a stone look.
    The cabinets look good. You might want to add some sort of dent/ding look to them, just because I haven't seen one that hasn't been bumped somehow. The downside to that is that it would appear to repetitive in your arrangement. You'd need to make several variations. Also, the cabinet should have the little nameplate square under each handle.
  • TheMadArtist
  • pliang
    Offline / Send Message
    pliang polycounter lvl 17
    You could always break it up with some add ons like post its, paper stacks on top...

    The cabinet looks good but the problem I keep on seeing is that you tend to just use one color variation as if you used one color fill for the whole thing...one hting a lot of people so when the ymake something like street lamps is that they make it one color.

    If you take a closer look objects tend to have little bits of discoloration or worn to it.
  • The Umbrella Man
    The dividers are supposed to be the way they are because of not only their existence in the building I am trying to recreate, but because they are dividers not cubicals, and also for story purposes. The player needs to be able to see all the office personnel from the starting point. So sorry if it seems like I am just ignoring the critique I'm really not, it's just essential they stay this way. You'll get the full effect when the scene is done.

    @pliang: I've taken your advice and I have used alot more colors in this next texture. Let me know what you think. I have some green, purple, blue, and grays.

    Here's a desk.

    Desk001.jpg
    Desk002.jpg

    Skin
    DeskSkin.jpg

    EDIT: The scene so far, just basic lighting to show the scene.

    progress.jpg
  • Kovac
    Offline / Send Message
    Kovac polycounter lvl 18
    The big thing I see in these pieces are the unwraps. Your textures are turning out very blurred even though it seems like you're using the proper map sizes.

    I've always hated being the anal nazi about theory on unwrapping but it's such an overlooked process it drives me batshit.

    Obviously there's far more important things to pay attention to that are more art related, but it still effects the overall quality of the piece, especially when presenting it to a studio you may be applying to.

    From the looks of it, you could easily cut most of your map's textures in half or have a much higher resolution piece using the same map sizes.

    Onto pulling examples:
    The corner cement pieces - There's really no need to have every single face of that corner on one map... stack things! You could take two or even all of the sides and place them onto one face of the pillar, and just make sure the texture tiles itself. Players will more likely notice the general blurriness of the texture before they could even notice any repetition in the texture, especially when consideration is taken in avoiding obvious patterns.

    File cabinets - As with all these crits, simply ask yourself: Is it really necessary for every single drawer to use up unique texture space? There's really no rhyme or reason with such miniscule scratch differences. Exceptions to this would obviously be something unique on one of the drawers (say it was more techy and had some kind of unique data readout or screen on the top drawer), but even then, spending 2 more polygons to place a plane on top would usually be the wiser decision anywho.

    Table - Every face of the legs are taking up unique UV space without justification. These can be easily stacked on each other... the same goes with those squares that are all the same shape. In addition, I only see one truly unique mark on the tabletop, and the Torque ingame shots show that it really doesn't even make sense, especially with so many of those tables lined up alongside each other having the same hulk smash dent in the left side of them. With that in mind, you could have easily spared the extra polygons to just cut that sucker in half and just mirror the UV space.

    Again, focus on creating good art regardless of consideration of unwrap theory as it's more important. However, keep this in mind when doing future pieces and you'll dig yourself out of bad habits before they form. I know I suffered from 'unwrap every piece uniquely because it matters' mentality so I think it's very important now that I look at before and after thinking outside the box (I guess?) on unwraps.
  • The Umbrella Man
    [ QUOTE ]
    A bunch of awesome words

    [/ QUOTE ]

    @Kovac: I am going to go back and redo those parts of the unwraps to take all that into consideration.

    About the blurry-ness that could be due to the jpg compression, because they don't look that bad in engine. I'll take some higher res shots and see if they come out the same way.

    Thanks for the comments.
  • The Umbrella Man
    Another boring cabinet. tedious but someones gotta do it.

    Can anyone tell me if I need to start doing something different with my skins as far as detailing. Everyone of the skins I have done so far feels like it's lacking something, but I don't know what yet. I have to develop my eye for detail sure, but when I fell apprehension like this it usually means something is off. I guess what I am saying is it feels flat.

    SmallFilingCabinetSkin.jpg

    SmallFilingCabinet001.jpg
    SmallFilingCabinet002.jpg
  • pliang
    Offline / Send Message
    pliang polycounter lvl 17
    filer.jpg

    I think one the different things you can do would be making like a variation with the drawers pulled out and just array it in a way that even with similar textures...the models help make the scene pop because of the variation.

    As for the texturing, I think though you added more details to them, try starting a little discoloration on the surfaces and some contact shadows in the bottom areas etc.

    That way your cabinet would have little more dimension and less monochrome appearance.
  • The Umbrella Man
    Figured out with a friend what's been keeping things flat. He did a paint over and it opened my eyes. Still have to perfect the technique, but it looks about 10 times better in my eyes.

    SmallFilingCabinetSkin-1.jpg

    SmallFilingCabinet001-2.jpg
    SmallFilingCabinet002-1.jpg
  • notman
    Offline / Send Message
    notman polycounter lvl 18
    Again, the filing cabinet should have the label square on the front. Also, there shouldn't be a line going around the cabinet. Here's a quick reference I found:
    t-shipley_mini-file-cabinet.jpg
Sign In or Register to comment.