What is the best way to solve this chamfer problem in curved objects?

sandrokaza

Crease set "1,0", or Hard edges, in all borders



Turbosmooth



Turbosmooth again



The problem. I've tried all the ways, but so far I haven't found a solution I used chamfer modifier, cut tool and nothing solved this.





Thanks

Ghogiel

Creasing doesn't affect the 2nd turbosmooth you added, it'll just subD smooth the geometry that is the  end result of the first turbosmooth modifier. That's the expected result in this situation - which is loose control loops not holding the shape you wanted it to.

I might personally inset the shape to be cutout of that cylinder and not just add loops and delete the shape from the cylinder. Like this but probably with different amount of segements on the cylinder(I just started with what you had after you did the first turbosmooth so skipped that stage)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mi4RIq9L_EU&feature=youtu.be


But you can probably slide some of those loops closer to the red lines to tighten up the edges pulling out from the edges too far and might be ok. https://i.imgur.com/MR2fAqm.jpg

sandrokaza

Ghogiel said:

Creasing doesn't affect the 2nd turbosmooth you added, it'll just subD smooth the geometry that is the  end result of the first turbosmooth modifier. That's the expected result in this situation - which is loose control loops not holding the shape you wanted it to.

I might personally inset the shape to be cutout of that cylinder and not just add loops and delete the shape from the cylinder. Like this but probably with different amount of segements on the cylinder(I just started with what you had after you did the first turbosmooth so skipped that stage)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mi4RIq9L_EU&feature=youtu.be


But you can probably slide some of those loops closer to the red lines to tighten up the edges pulling out from the edges too far and might be ok. https://i.imgur.com/MR2fAqm.jpg

Thank you! It really helped me!