Holy Grail - critique needed

Baq

Hi All,

I'd like you to give me some feedback about the model I worked on.

The goal was to make the Holy Grail with more realistic look.

Chalice which survived over 2 thousand years cannot be in perfect condition and Christ wasn't some rich guy who could afford some jeweld gold cup, so I went with simple silver.

If you would give me your opinions, the technical ones and how good it shows the story, I would be greatfull.

Ashervisalis

Hey, your renderings are really aliased. If this was a video game prop, you could lose a ton of polys around the narrow part of the cup. Due to its age, you could also increase the contrast of the roughness.

JohannesAg

i guess my main crit would be that it feels kinda modern,  i think a sculpting pass with some wear and imperfections would probably do it good. Are you using any reference for this?

Baq

@Ashervisalis - thanks, definitely will change that.

@JohannesAg - all those details ( beside dirt) were sculped. There are more dents, but are bearly visible. As for references:

Baq

After some changes.