Rock sculpts - Critique, please!

Rugollier

Hey! I'm sharing some work I made for a game I've been working on, I'd really appreciate some critique, as I'm not so experienced with rocks.

Thank you in advance!

Nyawning

i am no expert when it comes to sculpting, nor rocks, but i like the 2nd image; i think it's the one that looks like a real rock the most.

Dan Powell

Agree with Nyawning, I like the second one the most!

Personally, I don't think the current material is doing them justice - maybe try a material which highlights their edges a bit more?

macoll

From a modeling point, i like them all, gg   Rocks can be so various in the Nature then it is hard to criticize you!

Rugollier

Nyawning said:

i am no expert when it comes to sculpting, nor rocks, but i like the 2nd image; i think it's the one that looks like a real rock the most.

I agree - Thank you so much!

Dan Powell said:

Agree with Nyawning, I like the second one the most!

Personally, I don't think the current material is doing them justice - maybe try a material which highlights their edges a bit more?

I'll get right on that :')

macoll said:

From a modeling point, i like them all, gg   Rocks can be so various in the Nature then it is hard to criticize you!

Thanks!