Hey guys, working on my Final Year Project at Staffordshire University ad would really appreciate some feedback on my work s far. Both on my facial rig and blockout for my animation.
The first video is set to private. we can't see it.
Your mouth shapes really need work. It seems you are just opening the jaw a lot, rather than forming the shapes your mouth makes. your lips arent closing during "Bee" or "mm". Lips arent puckering during "oo". Basically, you don't have any common shapes that dictate the words you are saying. Study mouth shapes. There are plenty of resources out there for it. Something like THIS. These shapes are very important for us to believe the character is saying the words we are hearing. It adds to the realism of your animation.
I would not focus so much on the facial animation at this point. The thing that I would focus on is the overall movement of the head and neck. It feels like the head only moves in one or two rotation axis at a time, and during the holds it is literally just a hold, there's no overlapping or overshooting action going on.
I would also say to focus on part of the line at a time (2 minutes is waaay too long) and get every nuance of the line to come through on what the neck and head are doing. Once that is working, then start working on the facial animation (start with the eyes)
Thanks guys for the feedback I have to do between 2 minutes and 5 minutes for my final year project. However, I might keep it at the length it is now. Would much rather have 2 minutes of good animation then 5 minutes of mediocrity.
2 minutes is a hell of a long time to animate - it takes the 11 seconders' a month to do 11 seconds of animation. It might be better to practice on something smaller if you have the time? If not, this video helped me out:
If you need some reference, either repeat it to yourself in front of a mirror a couple of times, and then find where the most important mouth shapes are - or do the same but film it (pro tip, if you film it, do it from the front and the side. Watch for where you open you jaw, when the corners of your lips come in and out, and where you hit the mouth shapes.)
Quality over quantity. Try to focus on shorter clips, 2:26 is a lot of work and not needed, most people will know what you're capable of after 10-15sec.
Guys thank you for your feedback Here is the newer piece of animation rendered in Unreal 4 so would really appreciate your feedback on this. Thanks guys
Replies
Your mouth shapes really need work. It seems you are just opening the jaw a lot, rather than forming the shapes your mouth makes. your lips arent closing during "Bee" or "mm". Lips arent puckering during "oo". Basically, you don't have any common shapes that dictate the words you are saying. Study mouth shapes. There are plenty of resources out there for it. Something like THIS. These shapes are very important for us to believe the character is saying the words we are hearing. It adds to the realism of your animation.
I would not focus so much on the facial animation at this point. The thing that I would focus on is the overall movement of the head and neck. It feels like the head only moves in one or two rotation axis at a time, and during the holds it is literally just a hold, there's no overlapping or overshooting action going on.
I would also say to focus on part of the line at a time (2 minutes is waaay too long) and get every nuance of the line to come through on what the neck and head are doing. Once that is working, then start working on the facial animation (start with the eyes)
Also the length of this is far too long. Try just animating a selected bit of this.
Nice rig by the way! Loving the wiring that's going on there, good stuff!
[ame]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0fKjMvlP4CE[/ame]
also these are really helpful:
If you need some reference, either repeat it to yourself in front of a mirror a couple of times, and then find where the most important mouth shapes are - or do the same but film it (pro tip, if you film it, do it from the front and the side. Watch for where you open you jaw, when the corners of your lips come in and out, and where you hit the mouth shapes.)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kxH7OuCeM-Q&feature=youtu.be