The truth is, I don’t think there is a substantial amount of evidence to conclude whether or not the writers intended for the audience to interpret the game in this fashion. I choose to believe that this is how the game was intended to be understood because, to me, the game makes no sense otherwise. Everything that happens to the characters after the first disc is ridiculous. The ending is like recapping the game on acid. There has to be something more to the story than a simple ‘Hero Takes All’ plot.
Saw that site before, and heard the theory originally just after the game came out. There are one or two other theories floating around, but this one always seemed the most plausible to me.
Afaik Square staff never clarified wtf was up with the story, I guess they just really wanted people to figure it out for themselves.
I had a debug mode on a memory card that had some crazy NPC-UI type thing, where you'd talk to certain NPCs and they'd teleport you to other areas, some had dialog about the designers, one would let you watch the FMVs on disc 1, 3, and 4. There was a strange puzzle room too... i need to see if i can find it.
I'm feeling half tempted to quickly play through the game again with this theory in mind just to see how it applies.
Just reading that page connects my dots of confusion with various parts of the game, but it'd be cool to replay it accepting the idea that Edea killed Squall.
hahaha. nah ff8 was cool, never finished it, but being about 15 at the time the emo kinda longing after a girl storyline was easily identifiable. If i could stomach the cheese and terrible ps1 graphics I would probbaly love to go back and play it again. i remember the card game being awesome as well.
If anyone knows anything about Japanese anime exaggeration no one dies from being impaled by a shard of ice unless its through the heart. He was clearly hit on the side. By jp fantasy logic that is a survivable wound.
Though its pretty brilliant how a small change in interpretation can make the game story seem much more deep and grounded.
Glad to see some FF8 love here :> I don't believe in that theory, if plot seems confusing or nonsense to you, that's because it's japanese game haha :]
Don't care what haters say, but I still find graphics very cool (aside from being lo-res), they have some artistic feel to it. Also great mix of sci-fi and fantasy.
As nice as that theory is, it seems unlikely. The entire idea revolves around the second half of the game being a "dream," but it would be the first time in the history of ever that someone was portrayed to have some ludicrously long and elaborate dream because they were dying. It just makes zero sense to me in that regard.
Flashbacks, yeah. But stuff that never even happened?
As nice as that theory is, it seems unlikely. The entire idea revolves around the second half of the game being a "dream," but it would be the first time in the history of ever that someone was portrayed to have some ludicrously long and elaborate dream because they were dying. It just makes zero sense to me in that regard.
Flashbacks, yeah. But stuff that never even happened?
...so...it makes zero sense for that to be the story...because it would be...original?
Well if i remeber right a Squerasoft member working on the game already said that Squall infact didnt die on Edeas ice bolt (he read about this idea) but when i first readed that page i found it interresting as well, but i kinda gave the game up when reaching the final boss lol and Squall never was a hero i liked either.
Someone should just ask Yoshinori Kitase (wrote FF8s story) about these things already so the games mysteries can be put to rest. Though considering its been 15 years he might not even remember the specific details anymore.
I thought this was awesome, but I can't say I agree with everything after disc 2 being a dream.
One of the bigger points was that the first disc was more believable, vs the Moogles later on in the game.
Did this guy forget that the first SeeD training mission you do in the game involves talking to and fighting a giant fire beast? (Ifirit). I don't think the second half of the game feels like a weird dream, I think it feels like a typical JRPG.
Still though, I loved the article and it presented an interesting point of view (and brought back some memories).
As nice as that theory is, it seems unlikely. The entire idea revolves around the second half of the game being a "dream," but it would be the first time in the history of ever that someone was portrayed to have some ludicrously long and elaborate dream because they were dying. It just makes zero sense to me in that regard.
Flashbacks, yeah. But stuff that never even happened?
I'm not saying the long and convoluted dream itself is unlikely, just that it being triggered by dying specifically makes no sense. It would make more sense if the entire second disc was triggered because he ate some bad eggs or something.
It's no different than saying that magic exists in the game because oranges are actually green in that world. There's no logical correlation.
"Perhaps the rumour started because I haven't been much in the press lately. I have done enough press for a lifetime, and I don't have anything to say these days. I am happy to be with my family and I will work when I work. I was switched on for ten years and I never switched off. Now I am switching off whenever I can. I would rather be a little less famous these days"
Someone should just ask Yoshinori Kitase (wrote FF8s story) about these things already so the games mysteries can be put to rest. Though considering its been 15 years he might not even remember the specific details anymore.
About the theory, in my opinion... Squall not dies in the game. (spoilers) If he die on Disk 1 everything that follows from disc 2 onwards would not make sense, we would not know the role of Edea, the connection with Laguna, Ellone, etc.
Now, I want to mention the point "d) Just stay close to me."
There is a translation error in english version: "If I didn't, I wouldn't be talking about it." In the japanese version is: "If I did I couldn't talk about it like this", then she no longer likes Seifer. See: lokasenna.pe.kr/ardente/etc./
One more thing, the line: "I wonder how he felt...?" if I am not mistaken in the Japanese version is: "I wonder what he thought of me", indicating further that among them there was more friendship that anything else.
Speaking as what is presented here, she does not see to Seifer on the dance floor (actually he was not there), but she see at the director Cid Kramer and talk with him. This is indicated in the "Rebellion Princess" page, a page that brought information of Ultimania and other sources.
Also, Rinoa in the game NEVER says and ensures that Seifer was her boyfriend, then obviously they were not boyfriends. It is also important to say that she THOUGHT loved Seifer, NOT assures us even hinting several things: that she was confused with his feelings (for me the most reasonable choice), she was not interested, I had no desire to formalize a relationship with him, etc. And to top Seifer did not know if some feelings / what he thought about her. To me, that is not a relationship at all.
For me, They only had a relationship purely business, hence Seifer falls in the summer with the Owls of the Forest, and he has a dream to meet a child (Rinoa is not a sorceress/witch when he met, so it makes sense that he are not interested in her), and apart is a revolutionary type, who loves battles, for he delighted to release Timber, and continue increasing their ego.
If Seifer risked his life by Rinoa can not ensure, do not forget that he never says why, will not know your reason, but remember that Squall is also there, and he is his rival. Seifer fears that Squall and Rinoa are defeated for the Galbadia's army for majority and experience, and that's why going to his aid.
Squall does not die in disc 4 (spoilers) because the the video where Selphie and Irvine filmed the celebration after beating Ultimecia, everyone is happy, that means that everything went well (include Squall alive).
Replies
i like it!
Afaik Square staff never clarified wtf was up with the story, I guess they just really wanted people to figure it out for themselves.
[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7S1SVkysIRw"]Game Theory: Is Link Dead in Majora's Mask? - YouTube[/ame]
[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lu_WAmtr_hg"]Final Fantasy VIII Debug Room - YouTube[/ame]
That said, i watched the end of FF8 about 30 times, and never really got it. i like this interpretation!
Also, that empty-hollow face...Fk, NIGHTMARE!
Just reading that page connects my dots of confusion with various parts of the game, but it'd be cool to replay it accepting the idea that Edea killed Squall.
hahaha. nah ff8 was cool, never finished it, but being about 15 at the time the emo kinda longing after a girl storyline was easily identifiable. If i could stomach the cheese and terrible ps1 graphics I would probbaly love to go back and play it again. i remember the card game being awesome as well.
Though its pretty brilliant how a small change in interpretation can make the game story seem much more deep and grounded.
Don't care what haters say, but I still find graphics very cool (aside from being lo-res), they have some artistic feel to it. Also great mix of sci-fi and fantasy.
Nope. I think this is why I liked it so much as an angsty teenager, though. I recall trying to play it several years ago and I couldn't stand him.
Flashbacks, yeah. But stuff that never even happened?
...so...it makes zero sense for that to be the story...because it would be...original?
it is.
it's so awesome that people have emulated JUST the card game for pc haha.
One of the bigger points was that the first disc was more believable, vs the Moogles later on in the game.
Did this guy forget that the first SeeD training mission you do in the game involves talking to and fighting a giant fire beast? (Ifirit). I don't think the second half of the game feels like a weird dream, I think it feels like a typical JRPG.
Still though, I loved the article and it presented an interesting point of view (and brought back some memories).
not because he was dying, but...
[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OwYw2i2icNg"]"Newhart" - Series Finale - YouTube[/ame]
8 seasons of a dream :P
It's no different than saying that magic exists in the game because oranges are actually green in that world. There's no logical correlation.
"Perhaps the rumour started because I haven't been much in the press lately. I have done enough press for a lifetime, and I don't have anything to say these days. I am happy to be with my family and I will work when I work. I was switched on for ten years and I never switched off. Now I am switching off whenever I can. I would rather be a little less famous these days"
http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/197343-final-fantasy-viii/68548821?page=1
About the theory, in my opinion... Squall not dies in the game. (spoilers) If he die on Disk 1 everything that follows from disc 2 onwards would not make sense, we would not know the role of Edea, the connection with Laguna, Ellone, etc.
Now, I want to mention the point "d) Just stay close to me."
There is a translation error in english version: "If I didn't, I wouldn't be talking about it." In the japanese version is: "If I did I couldn't talk about it like this", then she no longer likes Seifer. See: lokasenna.pe.kr/ardente/etc./
One more thing, the line: "I wonder how he felt...?" if I am not mistaken in the Japanese version is: "I wonder what he thought of me", indicating further that among them there was more friendship that anything else.
Speaking as what is presented here, she does not see to Seifer on the dance floor (actually he was not there), but she see at the director Cid Kramer and talk with him. This is indicated in the "Rebellion Princess" page, a page that brought information of Ultimania and other sources.
Also, Rinoa in the game NEVER says and ensures that Seifer was her boyfriend, then obviously they were not boyfriends. It is also important to say that she THOUGHT loved Seifer, NOT assures us even hinting several things: that she was confused with his feelings (for me the most reasonable choice), she was not interested, I had no desire to formalize a relationship with him, etc. And to top Seifer did not know if some feelings / what he thought about her. To me, that is not a relationship at all.
For me, They only had a relationship purely business, hence Seifer falls in the summer with the Owls of the Forest, and he has a dream to meet a child (Rinoa is not a sorceress/witch when he met, so it makes sense that he are not interested in her), and apart is a revolutionary type, who loves battles, for he delighted to release Timber, and continue increasing their ego.
If Seifer risked his life by Rinoa can not ensure, do not forget that he never says why, will not know your reason, but remember that Squall is also there, and he is his rival. Seifer fears that Squall and Rinoa are defeated for the Galbadia's army for majority and experience, and that's why going to his aid.
Squall does not die in disc 4 (spoilers) because the the video where Selphie and Irvine filmed the celebration after beating Ultimecia, everyone is happy, that means that everything went well (include Squall alive).