Watch Model

Taj

Hi Guys

can you have a look at my model and tell me how realistic it looks.

http://tahajul.files.wordpress.com/2014/03/the-final-watch.jpg

My Blog - http://tahajul.wordpress.com/category/year-3/masterpiece-project/

Shiniku

This should probably go in Pimping and previews section. Also, I'm not gonna vote in the poll since I don't think the options you've provided are really much different. What is CG realistic? If it's realistic it doesn't look like cg. Just seem like arbitrary distinctions.

Anyway, my answer: if I showed this to someone outside of this profession they would probably think it's real, unless they really inspected it. There are some weird shading issues and artifacts that jumped out at me immediately. Not a bad model though.

lotet

ye, lots of rendering and shading issues. for exemple the frame of the watch looks like there are stretched geometry. there are also weird lines along the links of the chain.

EDIT: looking at it again it looks like the reflections are comming from a cube map rather then real time, and does not fit the scene.
I would really look into the PBR workflow and get a shader that supports it if I Where you.

Taj

Thank you for the feedback.

By CG realistic i meant something you would see in a animation movie, but i see why the poll doesn't make much sense so i will be redoing the poll.

The stretched geometry was done to add detail to the face not by stretching but moving polys.

Thankyou for your feedback, would be able to give me some feedback on what does work well?