Home 3D Art Showcase & Critiques

[UDK & Uniry] Ethelwood Museum, Th3 Cl0ckt0w3r, Casino Bar portfolio pieces

My name is Dan and I'm a graduate student studying Game Design with a concentration in Environment Modeling, currently living in the Los Angeles area. I will be graduating soon so I'm getting my portfolio together to start my job search for a Junior Environment Artist position, and I thought that this would be a great place to get some feedback on these pieces that I've been working on.

The first is is a natural history museum designed to be used in a survival horror game involving a zombie apocalypse. It's still WIP, and I'd appreciate any comments or critiques you guys have for me. I used Maya for the meshes, Photoshop for the diffuse textures, and XNormal and Crazybump for the normal, AO, and spec maps (as needed):

ethelwoodMuseum_01.jpg

ethelwoodMuseum_02.jpg

ethelwoodMuseum_03.jpg

ethelwoodMuseum_06.jpg

ethelwoodMuseum_07.jpg

ethelwoodMuseum10.jpg

ethelwoodMuseum_08.jpg

ethelwoodMuseum_09.jpg

This second piece, Th3 Cl0ckt0w3r, is intended to be an ancient clocktower repurposed in the future as an evil layer. It was created with Unity, Maya, Mudbox, and Photoshop. This piece includes explosive barrels and cover objects, and is intended for a more action-oriented FPS:

theClocktower_01.jpg

theClocktower_04.jpg

theClocktower_06.jpg

theClocktower_02.jpg

This last piece is the interior of a bar. I had an open-world style game in mind when creating it. It was also put together in Unity, and the pieces were created in Maya, Mudbox, and Photoshop.

casinoBar_01.jpg

casinoBar_03.jpg

casinoBar_02.jpg

casinoBar_04.jpg

Replies

  • Rhoutermans
    Offline / Send Message
    Rhoutermans polycounter lvl 12
    Some tips perhaps, ur lighting seems flat in the last screenshots, looking at the last one the couch seems to be floating because there's no shadows beneath the couch etc. Liking the glass tables tho..
    All the rooms, every corner, is clearly visible. That wouldn't really happen at night with such small lights. The metal materials/spec are still flat, don't see any spec coming from them at all.
    Liking the car crashing through the gate tho,Keep it up!
  • DWalker
    Overall it feels a bit dated; modern engines are capable of pushing out a ridiculous number of polygons (1.2M is the figure from Crysis, and I believe the others are similar.) Of course, mobile platforms are still a great deal lower, and it's always necessary to do the best with whatever budget you have.

    I'd recommend creating nice, hi-definition models and baking them into low-poly meshes before moving on to entire scenes. Once you are ready for full scenes, start simply, with a single room before moving onto an entire building.

    Remember that as a junior artist, you aren't expected to create an entire level. On a large team, your first job will probably involve creating minor props - the flotsam & jetsam that help flesh out levels.

    A slot machine would make a good project - it's a fairly uncommon choice, so the reviewers won't have seen a thousand; there are plenty of small details that will bake well; and the material has enough variety to remain interesting without being overwhelming. I'd recommend one of the old analog machines; they just seem to have more personality than the modern computer-driven ones.
    8119_B.JPG

    On your existing artwork, the proportions seem off, with most things being too tall overall. The rooms themselves also feel too tall, especially the casino. According to https://www.venetian.com/uploadedFiles/Common/Meetings/meetings_floorplans.pdf, the ceilings in the casino of the Venetian (a fairly high-end Vegas casino) are 13.5' tall; yours feels considerably taller. Furthermore, that extra height feels very empty.

    Your embellishments feel much too deep, from the ceiling bas relief in the museum to the ceiling panels in the casino. It seems as though you were exaggerating their depth to ensure that they would be noticed.
  • dan_shiriwastaw
    Rhoutermans - Thanks for the tips! You're right about the couch, I didn't notice that at first but it's definitely missing a shadow underneath. I will correct that. I also will either have to change the lighting or create a realistic source.

    DWalker - Thank you as well for the advice. I see your point about the empty space above and I'll begin to try and find a way to make the space more true to life proportionally. That's good for me to know moving forward and creating new scenes. I also thought what you said about perhaps not creating entire scenes, but just creating high-poly meshes and baking them down to lower-poly ones makes a lot of sense.
Sign In or Register to comment.