Shield Design

Elodin

Hello, I designed a few shields for a contest. Tell me what you think.

Would be really cool if you vote for it too, but I can't really ask that.

This all was done in Zbrush + Photoshop

LMP

The Ash Lake shield, I'm really digging it, the other 2, not so much.

Ash Lake feels like a real object. With the blood wolf I like the outer circles, but the central design doesn't feel real, it feels like a digital design

John51

Nice

joe gracey

The Ashe one for sure. The other two don't feel real, like they don't look like actual shields.

Elodin

Man, everyone digs Ash Lake one ) I, personally liked wolf.

Tobbo

The Ash Lake one reads the best.

praetus

Ash lake is neat but it will be disqualified because of the changes you've made to the edges. All graphics must fit into the silhouette of the template. Just thought you should know.

GrevSev

Turn the teeth like things on the ash lake shield inward to fit the template it looks to cool to be turned down

Steve Schulze

The wolf one could work if you developed it some more. If you made the wolf head into an applied detail as you did with the squidy Cthulhu thing on the other shield, it could work quite well.

If you run with the Ash Lake shield, then I'd make the tentacles and body/head of the creature less noticeably symmetrical.

Elodin

Ah, right, thanks for the comments.

About the ash lake - it was indeed, disqualified but I turned the edges inwards,
now it doesn't look so good.

Now I'm currently running with the wolf one, but I'm pretty sure I'm going to loose against three thouthand votes on other shields. How can anybody get that high =/