who would you hire?

Rockley Bonner

A person with an awsome scene with 90% uniquely unwrapped terxtures and 10% tiling or a person with a decent scene with 90% tiling and 10% unique?

Pedro Amorim

the one that looks the best

theSixtyEight

90% unique and 10% tiling, coz he can work also with 90% tiling and 10% unique mostly likely

Snader

The awesome one, because it is awesome and the other is merely decent. Using a lot of tiling textures does not necessarily mean they are efficient or good tiling textures.

Though really, one sentence is not enough to make such a judgment call on.

scotthomer

Whichever one makes me think "yeah this guy is cool, I can work with him" and "wow this guy is enthusiastic and positive"