The cobblestone is really hard to ignore, it makes your crate look really really tiny.
Your scratches are just, uh, everywhere. That's not really how materials scratch. I'm not talking about the edge cracks, i'm talking about the places where it looks like it was keyed by someone.
What are your geometry restrictions here?
You could really use some bevels on the corners that are more than 90 degrees (especially if the assignment is just this prop, as opposed to a full environment) Also it appears your metal needs a bit more of the UV space dedicated to it. It's not very sharp. Can you post your UV layout?
The crate size was okayed by my teacher. The scale versus the view from the player camera gave it a pretty decent size, the cobblestones are just pretty large.
Yes, I need to redo the scratches. I originally did them at my dad's house who didn't have 3d max for me to compare to. I will attempt to fix them soon and update.
I'm sorry, what do you mean by geometry restrictions? Like how many polys I was allowed? Our teacher limited us to 1000
Pretty much when you have two or more sides that will look the same it is safe to have those right on top of each other. Ill edit this post soon with a example.
Oh like with items that are symmetred? I have all those in stacks. The top and bottom are separate because the top has the cylinder bit and the bottom doesn't. Not sure what else could have potentially been overlapped. Maybe the top and bottom parts of the clamps?
I circled everything that looks like it could be overlapped. The top and bottom could also because you have to think about how the player will see the prop. If it does not move and ill never be flipped the player wont see it. So it wont matter if the bottom has the cylinder on it because the player would never know.
Replies
Your scratches are just, uh, everywhere. That's not really how materials scratch. I'm not talking about the edge cracks, i'm talking about the places where it looks like it was keyed by someone.
What are your geometry restrictions here?
You could really use some bevels on the corners that are more than 90 degrees (especially if the assignment is just this prop, as opposed to a full environment) Also it appears your metal needs a bit more of the UV space dedicated to it. It's not very sharp. Can you post your UV layout?
Yes, I need to redo the scratches. I originally did them at my dad's house who didn't have 3d max for me to compare to. I will attempt to fix them soon and update.
I'm sorry, what do you mean by geometry restrictions? Like how many polys I was allowed? Our teacher limited us to 1000