[WIP] Prowler

polycounter lvl 8
Offline / Send Message
Daven polycounter lvl 8
Hey everyone. I'm just posting progress work for a quadruped I'm working on for a private project. Feedback would be most appreciated.


Here's a piece of concept art I did before I started modeling. The model sheet is kind of shitty so I'll probably leave that out.

prowler.png

Low Poly Wireframe Shots:
3538 Tris, Not including Eyes
005.png
004.png
003.png
002.png
001.png

High Poly ZSculpt Shots:

ProwlerHighPoly001.png
ProwlerHighPoly002.png
ProwlerHighPoly003.png
ProwlerHighPoly004.png


High Subdivision PolyPaint

ProwlerHighPainted001.png
ProwlerHighPainted002.png
ProwlerHighPainted003.png


Low Poly with Diffuse and Normal
3538 Tris, Not including Eyes


ProwlerLowPoly001.png
ProwlerLowPoly002.png
ProwlerLowPoly003.png



Thanks a lot everyone for taking the time to look at my work. I hope to get some nice feedback.

Replies

  • SasoDuck
    Looks like something out of Avatar. Your textures look a bit blurred though. Modeling is excellent, except the front shoulders- the muscles there look kind of weird...
  • BCos
    Offline / Send Message
    BCos polycounter lvl 6
    I agree with Saso regarding the front shoulders. They need more protrusion and form. pull them out alittle bit by claytubing over them in the direction the muscle would go from the back to the arm to build out the muscle definition in there more. i feel that if you gave the shoulders a more shpere like form it'll look nicer. Maybe even drop the back and head alittle further to fit the "Prowler" role you've given it. current the side profile is rather otter-like, not very siniter and menacing. I'd drop down a bunch of sub-division levels and make some shifts with the move tool with a BIG brush radius and just play around and see what you get out of it.

    I myself recently delved into a quadreped beast, though mine was in fact directly inspired from Avatar. with my initial sculpt i came up with similar issues, if you care to take a peak for reference's sake, i documented my work process in a thread. the thread is available here.

    http://www.polycount.com/forum/showthread.php?t=75730


    also, you may want to go higher-rez for your poly painting. it appears you're losing some quaility due to lack of vertices while you were polypainting, theres alot of choppiness and aliasing. you may want to take another pass at that and perhaps jump up a bit on your texture rez for your low poly.
  • Baaaah!
    Offline / Send Message
    Baaaah! polycounter lvl 9
    Like the concept :)

    I might well be wrong here, but did you model your base mesh, drop it into zBrush, add lots of subdivisions and then start to sculpt? I've discovered that it's often more useful to work your way up through the subdivisions gradually, scultping larger forms and adding as much detail as you can at lower res. Then when you're happy with that, work your way up to the finer detail. Your sculpt sort of has that feel to it. As I said I'm just guessing at that though.

    The thing that really seems to catch my eye is the sharp protrusion of, what I'd imagine, are the shoulder blades? The lines of the body overall are quite smooth, but the shoulders really seem to be at odds with this. They seem quite far apart as well.

    The feet look a bit odd as well. Given this creature is quite feline, the feet don't really look like paws.

    Looking promising though, hope that helps a bit :)
  • SasoDuck
    Looking at your concept since it didn't show for some reason on the school computers.

    I think as far as texturing goes, you should make the skin have more variation of hues. Rather than just have a solid blue primary color, add in ripples and undertones of lighter and darker blues and bluish-purple..... Also there's some speckles and patterns on the skin, add those too. Lastly for textures you should make it seems more shiny. In the reference, it looks very much like a cross between a wolf and a salamander. Give it that sort of water-coated sheen.

    Again, the major modeling issue is the legs. Also the feet seem pretty square, give them a more natural shape, like a triangle but with the smooth fleshy curves.
  • Daven
    Offline / Send Message
    Daven polycounter lvl 8
    Wow, thanks a lot guys.

    Yeah, I did the high poly detail and the polypaint in one night just to get it ready for class, but I'm ready to put more effort into it now.

    The feet and shoulder blades have been bothering me for some time, so I'll see what I can do about fixing them and making it more conducive to the overall design.

    One of my teachers also told me to spend more time on the diffuse texture really getting those underlying skin tones and muscle structures. I also want to add some fine skin detail with pore texture and whatnot. As for the specular level, I haven't gotten a chance to make a spec map. I wanted to make him look all slimy like the picture of the salamander you linked.

    It sucks, the "gills" or whatever you would call them on the front of the chest were meant to be used only underwater when it was swimming. Most of the design work was done before I saw Avatar and I kind of got pissed when I saw what they had done with their Thanator. Whatever.

    But yeah, thanks a lot guys. I'll post with progress when I have a chance.
  • almighty_gir
    Online / Send Message
    almighty_gir interpolator
    you can push the sculpt so much further than you have... right now it's just so blobby and undefined. really push those shapes! also, take a look at big cats like panthers and leopards, look at their stance, the way their shoulders are hunched, the curve of their spine.

    these things give character, and that's really important when defining monsters... without character, they're not scary!
  • ludic
    Offline / Send Message
    ludic polycounter lvl 7
    i like prowlers :):):)
    as the others suggested i think the silhouette can be pushed and defined some more working on the lowres, and maybe you can sculpt it in a more interesting pose. But it's nice nevertheless.
  • Traix
    Hmm something looks off on the paws for me, I dunno maybe its how the toes come off from a larger part that makes the side profile look weird. And secondly I noticed that in the concept the prowler has 5 toes/claws on each paw and your model only has 4. But it looks great =)
  • Daven
    Offline / Send Message
    Daven polycounter lvl 8
    Yeah, when I was modeling the low poly version I realized it'd be better in the long run to give this thing only four toes on each foot instead of five.

    I think I might go back in and redo the low poly and add in some more detail. I could probably push the limit upwards of 6-7k tris.

    As far as the pose, I'm going to keep it in this stance for rigging and importing as I eventually want to use this guy in the UDK.
  • JimeeB
    I think that either the legs are too short, or the body is too long. More likely I think that your body is too long. I also think that if you got rid of the bumps ontop of the shoulders it would streamline them quite a bit more and rid you of the 'funny' look they have right now, but overall I feel the piece is coming along nicely. It'll be nice to see this thing animated and running.
Sign In or Register to comment.