I'm in agreement about not having a vote. It's only a week. If you don't like the shape that week, just wait 7 days. Over complication will kill this thing before it gets going.
Thanks for the names, I just been naming them Week 3 and so on. As for James, I found by using a 50 sided cylinder and extruding back 3 faces/7 face gap will get you close to the correct proportions. I find it very crucial to do a little math before tackling on these challenges (I think I spend more time planning then I do…