Yes, but we seem to have used this thread as the voting thread already... And since there is a clear winner might be best to just start. Just my opinion though.
Yeah the biggest issue I noticed in the video was he didn't lay down enough key-lines to begin with. A little more thought to the topology and it might be a winner.
I like the overall shapes, and if your final piece can get a nice post-process going to match the photograph I think you'll be on to a winner :) *Subscribed*
this ended up being the winner here. seems like it was the only logical workflow for this. downside is multiple materials per asset, but cant win em all! thanks!
Looks like the people who made ICO which I friggen loved have another winner on there hands check out this new trailer... http://www.us.playstation.com/Content/OGS/SCUS-97472/Site/
I have to return some videotapes. [EDIT] I think I failed at comprehending the rules/didn't understand the next thread is posted by the last winner. If a mod could delete that would be great :(
too many loops in each "canister" compared to the errrrrr "coil" and the barrel, at least at the sections that create the silhouette, divide these and it looks like youve got a winner