Hmm, so far it seems that 10 is in the lead maybe. 8 is getting a lot of votes too. I'll let this run till tomorrow, then make a decision and move into a final concept. Thanks you all!!!
I like 3 and 12 the best, or 10 if you really want that external switch. Most of those silhouettes are too complex for their own good and certainly more complex than your reference. I'd stick to simpler, clear forms both for readability and because this would supposedly be a fairly small asset.
I agree with Mark, I think the Silhouette is really going to sell what these grenades are and what they do. I think your shapes are awesome, and your approach and references are really smart ways to do this! At a first glance, the grenades look like (to me): 1.) Looks like an orbital artillery laser device, (push the…