B - 7.5 (needs bottom part of the pillars plus stair wideness from c to get closer to 10) EDIT - the more i look at B i decide the roof shape and edge lip part isnt as good as C either. so i drop Bs rating to 7.5. C - 7 A and D 1-2ish
A: 4 B: 7 C: 6 D: 2 experience: industry pro ~1.5 years I agree with what konstruct said about context; it all depends on how players are going to interact with this building.
A:4 B:6 C:5 D:4 exp: 7 yrs none of them seem to have their measurements right and have taken their own creative liberties on objects that are easily seen and created. Rating them rather low on the fact that it doesn't seem any of them tried to find a constant object on there to get a reference of measurement. like using a…
A - 2 B - 3 C - 5 D - 1 Experience: 7 years Its cool you guys are trying to pick apart which method is best suited for a particular job. Something to keep in mind however, is context. Is this meant for a hero piece? Its this an asset to be used in an open world environment? How close does the viewer get? should we be able…