As much as I hope inFamous wins GOTY, I'm fairly certain that it won't. I really hope either Uncharted 2, or Assassin's Creed 2 wins (though I still stand by my opinion of the controls just being horrible at times.) here's to hoping COD4:MW2 doesn't win.
L4D2 is highly enjoyable. Uncharted 2 was an amazing experience, but didn't have much meat. I hate to say it, but I think Modern Warfare 2 is going to take the cake. It's got a huge amount of upgrades over it's predecessor and they even managed to upgrade all of the graphics as well. It's a solid experience offline and…
Its split down the middle for me. Single player: Uncharted 2. Multiplayer: MW2 Killzone 2, and Forza 3 as my honorable mention. I was some what surprised with my PS3 this year, to bad its online is terrible for me. Being able to play with 10+ friends on the 360 any day is awesome. Playing with 1-0 people on PSN = fail.
For me it's a punch up between Uncharted 2 and Dragon Age. I still can't put dragon age down despite being able to fault the thing to high heaven, but that's classic bioware I guess.