I wish that every time someone said something was a slap in the face, they actually got slapped in the face. That would be pretty cool. My favorite game for 2009 was Batman, but I've just started playing Uncharted 2. With so many big games still to come, this thread would make more sense in January.
I'm glad somebody had sense to mention Stalker even though COP is not out yet i'm playing Clearsky and it looks awesome. The choices on this poll are pretty weak though. Aion?! Isn't that 11 months old and the art style is cock awful. My votes in no order:- Batman Call of Juarez Resident Evil 5