Well, I just researched the XNA and I have to say, it's crap as it sits right now IMO. I have to pay $99 per year to develop a game for the 360? Then the only way I can share it is if the other person has a Creators Club license? AND, you can't develop it to be on a CD/DVD or memory stick. Guess if I get a 360, I can…
This shouldn't even be a debate. With the title line up the 360 already has right now available and with other hot titles coming out. GTA 4, Assassins Creed, UT3, Halo 3, Halo Wars, etc. So many awesome games already. You mention wanting to make games. You can make games for live right now and publish them and upload them…