Search
-
Re: hows about a focused critique forum?
okay, yes, you guys are right, the examples i gave are extremely poor. i'm just trying to illustrate the lack of censorship involved in expressing someone's true opinion. i KNOW my friends at work don't give me the same level of critique that they can give to people they don't like. i think there's a critique level that… -
Re: hows about a focused critique forum?
... for example, you have me on bad days. Gauss on good days. Whos the ugly gonna be? -
Re: hows about a focused critique forum?
I'd rather they were polite about it like you had in your first example... Its the same crit, just in one, the guy is being an asshole. -
Re: hows about a focused critique forum?
I'm with Aesir on that. I believe that the first example crit you give is actually ''right'', because it is clearly stated that it's an opinion expressed. On the other hand, the second is just plain wrong as it is written like an absolute truth/rule to follow, which never ever happens in anything art related. Even if it… -
Re: hows about a focused critique forum?
Whats missing from the examples given are SOLUTIONS. Critiques dont do a bit of good when solution ideas aren't given along with the areas people find at fault. I could care less if someone says something on my work is "shit". As long as they give a good constructive* way to resolve the issue. *Constructive isnt saying…
5 results