It's not even close to a harsh, rude, or even impolite critique. People asking for critique are looking for information, not a pat on the back. If you like to be very polite and nice that is great but it's not necessary and mostly just fluff, meaning it has little value. There is no information to do anything with. If you…
I'm by no means an expert, but I feel like they don't pop? I think it's the lighting. They're not flat, but I feel like it doesn't really make them stand out; I think perhaps more contrast could be good. Darker shadows, and lights positioned so the shiny parts really catch the light and highlight the details, like the…
poster above doesnt know how to give feedback, was unnecessarily harsh and had no constructive criticisms so ignore them, I'm not a hard surface artist but i will do my best to advise on what i can. First of all, your work is really solid so far and shows a lot of potential. You're getting some great results and I can see…