Search
-
Re: How do YOU give feedback?
Actually, there is a way to give proper concrit for stylistic choices... But it involves finding similar styles and digging into the philosophical grounding of a style(yes, yes, put on your monocles). For example, if someone does a handpainted model, we can analyse the style and assume it's inspired by looney tunes, or by… -
Re: How do YOU give feedback?
Well I value a piece over it's artistic merit, as in traditional values, I think it's the most important thing, above technical details or functionality. For example, if it's a drawing, I might look at overall composition, in the classical sense (framing, point of interests, color contrast, etc), and then on details like… -
Re: How do YOU give feedback?
I usually try to keep my critiques as objective as possible with reference whenever possible. The fact that I don't like the overall style or design of something because of personal preference would end up creating friction in the critique and make it less beneficial. If it is someone I know well, I may toss out a few… -
Re: How do YOU give feedback?
I try hard being harsh because so little people give any good comments, especially the good artists never seem to get anything valuable out of their threads, and just say what I think. I personally find it very sad when I cant get any good harsh critique on my work so I try doing that as much of that as possible, thats…
4 results