hi Andrew, I am sorry you are taking offense to my feedback. the thing is here in polycount forum and in this thread where i am giving feedback to you (however brutal or honest it may be) is not same as speaking to a group of impressionable students/learners. also how am i pretending to possess ultimate knowledge ? where…
Hey Mark, sorry I should have given more context, it's in relation to developing as an artist. Not evaluating while you create does not develop your artistic judgement on aesthetics. Self-reflection and specifically following accurately concept art is definitely important as you learn how to do it and you improve your…
This is the correct workflow because you are experienced, it was the slides with the bar chart that could give inexperience students the impression when they create their own artwork they need this amount of composition, this amount of colour etc. For example a student might deconstruct their favorite piece of artwork into…
Mashru, we are exactly agreeing on all the subjects only you insist on using the language more convenient to you. And I think I know why. Because what you think you heard in the talk offended you, heck it did offend me when I was first thinking about it. And I'm very sorry if it did. We each pick our own battles. And if…
absolutely :) from my brief observation there seems to be several technical problems in that work that contribute to the lack of "beauty". the assets themselves do not look satisfactory and have some inconsistency issue. here are some areas that are noticeable right away: 1. models dont follow the aesthetic style of the…
You're very kind MrHobo. Qualified or not I just want the argument to stand on it's own feet. Some people will find a way to benefit from this greatly, others will disregard it completely even before watching. That's life :) I am indeed no Feng, aleksdigital :) . Sorry I put some slides that actually required context,…
Phew, thanks for the write up Rogelio! I in no way disagree that everyone's taste for sublime is different. In fact this subject is extremely difficult to discuss exactly for that matter. Although it is very interesting seeing everyone's different take on it. It's amazing seeing how drastically we differ even in the…