Search
-
Re: Unwanted Criticism
Hahah! I was just being an ass, Cory...couldn't resist! :) More seriously, I don't think what KillnPC is asking for is necessarily 'gossipy' thing or a bad thing to think about...especially if we're talking about old threads, long locked or with people who have long left PC. I could see having good examples and bad… -
Re: Unwanted Criticism
Mrskullface: The satellite soda rules post sounds amazing. I should start posting art over there. Thread: IMO, The macho toughguy ruff critz attitude is toxic. It also promotes a very technician minded attitude -- that there are mechanical, cut and dry solutions to an individual artist's problems, and that they have made a… -
Re: Unwanted Criticism
As much as I like Kevin Smith and his work, I think he's a pretty good example of a person who just can't take negative critique and thinks it's all a personal attack on him. The whole "if you think I'm such a bad film-maker then how about you do it yourself!"-attitude is a big sign of this. Critics can be harsh and if the… -
Re: Unwanted Criticism
Yes I agree with you. It doesn't matter who gives you feedback. For example, people who aren't animators can tell you if something in your animation feels off, or if something doesn't come across as intended etc. It's really all about whether it's constructive or not. But I also believe that crits should be neutral,… -
Re: Unwanted Criticism
Haz, I've got to say that while our visions are almost as a rule diametrically opposed and while I have been and continue to be critical of your work not that I imagine that poor Zwebbie's opinion keeps you awake at night while all that's true, I always appreciate the depth and honesty of posts such as these that you… -
Re: Unwanted Criticism
I was under the impression that the irony was you criticizing them for defamation of character after you called them a talentless, egotistical c**t who has no business running their website, but I may have misinterpreted. More on topic, one of the biggest problems I've always had with "unwanted criticism" threads is how… -
Re: Unwanted Criticism
damn, I remember at least 2-3 examples from P&P but nothing concrete enough to search on :( . They were all awkward as hell, though. -
Re: Unwanted Criticism
Crits are rad! it's learning for free. I don't know how many people know about the website satellitesoda.com (it's mostly a 2D art site) but when me and a couple people created it and one of the main rules way you HAVE to crit on each thread that would you comment on. You also have to give feedback and not just use the… -
Re: Unwanted Criticism
I read the whole thread! I'm so proud of myself! I wanted to say that, while no examples come to mind (that I could possibly find), I know I've seen instances where the artist was actually asking for critique, but the critique they received was terrible; either very mean, way off base, or completely unhelpful. We have a… -
Re: Unwanted Criticism
I actually agree, EQ. It is a great idea for a thread when thought of that way, instead of as a sort of lions' den, where we throw the dead threads of artists past. It can be very helpful having specific examples of how people deal with critique, both good and bad. And perhaps, if there were a way to repost a thread, while…
10 results