I would suggest cutting out alot of the 'fluff' in the article too, I loved the example you gave of "Tag" criticism which looks like something that belongs on the back of a box, vs. one which is more engaging and describes the specific issue, the two paragraph's in between could have very easily be compressed to "Here's…
This. Also, Being an Empathizing Critic I'd just say that almost any form of criticism is a gift and it's in every artists interest to treat it as such. Bash me all you want, run me into the ground for all I care, because if your argument has merit I'll learn from you and I appreciate it and don't really care about anyone…
I believe that's more of an opinion than critique, so I don't think he/she would feel bad if you ignored the advice. And that's also something else to consider, it's up to you to decide what thoughts you take on board, and what you discard, you don't need to address every comment, especially if you feel as though the…
Hello everyone, I wrote a quick article on some thoughts I had about providing constructive criticsm. Since we are in the media age, a lot of artwork is shared and a lot of feedback goes back and forth. I decided to elaborate on some experiences of mine, and provide some feedback that i'd thought i'd share in terms of…