If a thumbnail system was put in place, it would be super cool if there was a system similar to CGHub's front page that cycled through new and popular content. A critique system like WIPNation's would also be amazing. Both would be a horrible fuckton of work, but I guess I just like to dream.
I love the idea of a filterable tags system. The major thing annoying me in P&P right now is the barrage of threads about art tests and external competitions. Tags solves that pretty well. Another thing that bothers me is threads full of pointless praise posts. I don't think a straight-up "like" system is the solution,…
Once the tagging (Horah my idea was already in the works) and thumb-nailing system are in place, I'm pretty sure PC will be attracting a much larger crowd. Just ease of access alone will populate threads more!
One thing I really like about polycount is that most stuff is in big category's (P&P/sketchbooks/technical discussion). And you don't have to go trough 5 different forum sections if you just want to have a look at what new works have been added in the last day or so. So for that reason I voted "it's fine to me", but I…
Yea I see how CA.ORG works with thumbnails and don't know how helpful that is. Your comment alone (not that you meant this) almost says hey if your not at such and such skill I'm not going to bother to look at your thread. Perhaps a tag at the start of the thread by the poster? Set by default by the system, that you have…
Thumbnail system would be great. And also maybe someone could do a good introduction video you had to watch and answer a few questions right to be able to post. The "rules" might get followed more. (Hope that pc don't got like deviantart, lots of people and stuff and not so many good comments.)
I also like the simplicity of the single forum we have right now, though a thumbnail system could be cool. Better naming conventions are something that people should get in the habit of doing anyway, and perhaps we can just lead by example? If newbs see everyone posting with a similar format, they might pick up on it, and…
I'm...I've seen writing critique forums where in order to post a new thread in a subforum you have to post several responses in that subforum first. Like, for every new thread you needed to accrue five replies/crits. It wouldn't ensure quality feedback, but if you required those posts to be 100-200 words each, it would at…
One idea we're certainly going to be noting is the idea of thread tagging that isn't obnoxious. -Tags don't appear by default. -Tags are added to a thread by the users, but chosen from a pre-defined list of tags. (Avoiding 'BOOBIES' tags, for instance). -Tags are easily added to the system if so requested from the…