Thats odd it didn't seem to mute my reflections at all really. Have you tried plugging the reflections into emissive and seeing how that looks rather than combining it with the diffuse?
Oh man, thanks a lot skillmaster; the answer was in the OneMinus node. Emissive only really brightened up a lot of the diffuse, which wasn't desired, but it did get me experimenting. I plugged the OneMinus in the alpha and got these results: It seems that many of the highlights in my reflections are coming from the green…