I was going for a harsh sharp looking edge. no these rocks are anything but wet :P ,but thank you for the post. I probably should tone down that scrape spec.
Thanks happybell, I will try and keep everything sharp for this next sword. edit: found a good reference for the gold trim, wish I would've looked at this sooner
Since your environment is cloudy, you should tone down the shadows on your trees. Your 2 reference images show this, their are no sharp shadows to speak off.