I think I'd go with Arkham Asylum as well. Uncharted 2 has amazing production values and Assassin's Creed II is very impressive in terms of scale, but Arkham Asylum looked great and (more importantly) was really fun to play. Rocksteady managed to combine elements from a bunch of different genres andthey all came off…
Game of the Year, for me, is one of the following: Uncharted 2 - Probably my fave game of the year, and if they don't announce a movie version soon with Nathan Fillion I don't think there will be a power in the verse than can stop me sending them some dirty granny porn hate mail... Batman: Arkham Asylum - Because it just…