Some kind of general portfolio feedback READ THIS FIRST sticky sort of thing might be really helpful... if people used it. I'm sure people would read it, but they'd probably post their portfolio for crits anyway without making those changes, in hopes they'll get feedback not included in the sticky (which they probably…
If I might engage in wild speculation, I think its reasonable likely we'll see something portfolio related in the new fancy additions that are being worked on for Polycount at the moment.
Since you are in the idea giving mood, could you look at my portfolio quick? Yeah, just kidding. Sounds like a good idea to me as well. I've been noticing more and more of that stuff in pimping and previews. Might be to the point where a subforum would be justified.
I'd just like to add that there is nothing wrong with portfolio's, and I don't mind the threads being in P&P right now at all. I was just trying to convey that a subforum could be beneficial in general, just because you are too lazy/busy to click 2 times does not mean the people who are interested in (giving) feedback are.
Agreed with Meisse. While it's a good idea in general I can't help but think and convulse when I look at CGTalk. Granted I check P&P sometimes multiple times a day, I don't think we're getting enough threads to be bumping individual critiques down the list to the second page too quickly. Hopefully people just keep the…